4 ms·
Conversely, I don't know why people still buy cars in urban areas. Rural, I get. But I've lived in cities all my adult life, and I don't even have a drivers lic
by vidarh 7y ago
Conversely, I don't know why people still buy cars in urban areas. Rural, I get. But I've lived in cities all my adult life, and I don't even have a drivers license. It feels like a waste of time, and owning a car feels like a pointless waste of money. Why would I pay to have a car that I need to worry about, including thinking about where it happens to be located when I want a car.
I like being able to open up Citymapper, tell it where I want to go, and now they've started not just suggesting Uber and others for the whole ride as an alternative to public transport, but suggesting it for parts of the way. A car you own can't compete with taking you to a train station and picking you up on the other side.
Today it takes ~3 minutes on average to get a car to the front of my house. That's with human drivers, spaced out inefficiently. Get driverless, and you can get a mix of ride shares and individual cars based on spacing out cars based on predicted demand and picking the most efficient solution based on customer preferences with very low wait times at even lower cost.
Owning a car just can't compete in my eyes. Maybe that's shaped by living in European cities where driving long distances almost never competes favorably with mixing and matching with trains and underground (a typical commute for me in the days I used to commute in to central London would have taken twice as long with car, and maybe ~30% less if a car/rideshare service could guarantee to be here in 3-4 minutes instead of waiting for the bus or walking to the train station; with apps suggesting the best route I'd still take the bus when the wait is low, but know I could start my journey later because I'd have a shorter maximum wait)
EDIT: Even more so because parking restrictions are getting stricter and stricter. The London borough where I live won't even entertain planning applications for housing if it includes more than 1.5 parking space per unit. That's expected to drop further as density increases - note that this is not permits for the road etc., but applies whether or not you build your own off street parking. The reason is that restricting parking is seen as a way of discouraging car ownership to reduce demand on surrounding road infrastructure.
- kalleboo 7y agoI was 100% with you until I got a kid. And then a second one. With car seats, baby carriages, spare diapers, towels, tissues etc etc the value of having a car always packed with "your stuff" goes up a lot.
- adrianN 7y agoMany families still manage fine. My siblings an me were raised without a car and since then the availability of public transport and things like cargo bikes has only improved.
- kalleboo 7y agoCertainly you can manage fine. And it gets easier when the kids get older and are more independent. But if you can afford a car, it's still a big help. So families will keep buying cars. I'm just trying to explain GPs "I don't understand why people buy cars", not saying that it's a requirement.
- yellowapple 7y agoEven without kids, I find having a vehicle with "my stuff" in it to be invaluable. It's also handy when I need to haul something, or if I want to go somewhere not readily serviced by public transit (which is, you know, the vast majority of even California, let alone the United States); sure, I can rent a car or truck or whatever for those occasions, but it only takes a few instances of that to become less costly than just buying a used car.
- vidarh 7y agoIt did get harder when I got a kid, but I took him on the bus and in taxis just fine from he was a baby. It was a pain for a bit, but not enough to make me want a car.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI'd recommend getting a drivers license anyway. It opens up some opportunities + will come in handy if, at some point, you decide to move to more rural areas. Having lived almost my entire life in 1M city, I don't have one either, but I recently moved to a ~15k city and this is forcing me to finally get that license.
- Tepix 7y agoIf vidarh manages another 5-10 years without getting a license it may be a moot point.
- Piskvorrr 7y agoOh puh-leeze. 1970s called, they want their flying cars back. And the Moon colonies and strong AI. (Spoiler: jam yesterday and jam tomorrow, but never any jam today)
- vidarh 7y agoI grew up in a ~25k town and public transport was still just fine. There are certainly places where it wouldn't be, and of course big differences between how small you can go and get decent public transport depending on country etc. (e.g. my brother lives 20-30 minutes by car or probably twice that by bus outside that ~25k town, and if I lived there I might feel differently), but I just can't see myself willingly moving anywhere where it'd be a problem.
- wvh 7y agoDo you have children?
- vidarh 7y agoYes, I do, and it still didn't change my mind,.
- pwinnski 7y agoIn the US, the urban/rural distinction isn't enough. It's more like NYC or SF/everywhere else. I'm in a very large city (Dallas), and my choices for commuting back and forth to work include busses and ride-sharing. Taking a bus means literally hours per day, and it would cost me more to take Lyft every day than it currently costs me to maintain my car, and I live extremely close to my office by Dallas standards (3.2 miles, 5.15 km). It's possible the math would change if I both lived and worked within walking distance of a light-rail stop, but only a small percentage of residences or offices fall into that category, and neither my home nor my office are included. It probably also helps that my car is paid for, so my monthly costs are only: insurance, fuel, 1/12th of my inspection and registration fees, and a few oil changes per year. Over a long enough time frame, I'd have to include whatever it will cost me to replace this car someday, but eventually the VC money underwriting Lyft is going to run out, so I'll take my chances.