4 ms·
On the other hand, a 12C with a handsome IPC improvement from last generation at $499 feels pretty tempting to me...
by jchw 7y ago
On the other hand, a 12C with a handsome IPC improvement from last generation at $499 feels pretty tempting to me...
- gravypod 7y agoYou can also buy into TR4 Threadripper 1950x for ~$500 [0]. I'm using one to write this post. It's a great system and you can likely buy used for cheaper than $500. I'm also assuming this price will fall further once they announce another TR4 chip. [0] - https://www.amazon.com/AMD-Threadripper-32-thread-Processor-YD195XA8AEWOF/dp/B074CBH3R4 https://www.amazon.com/AMD-Threadripper-32-thread-Processor-...
- opencl 7y agoI think the whole system price basically ends up as a wash with TR4 motherboards being at least ~$300 and needing a ~$100 cooler, I'm assuming these consumer chips will continue to have bundled coolers. The 3950X also draws 75W less than the 1950X so you can probably save a few bucks on the power supply and of course your electric bills over time. The performance comparison will be interesting though. The 3950X should be quite a bit faster than the 1950X when it's not bottlenecked by memory bandwidth, but of course the 1950X still has twice the memory channels. Slightly offset by the Zen2 memory controller supporting higher frequency RAM. So which one is better will depend heavily on workload. I suspect that for a developer workstation the 3950X would be the better performer, most compilation workloads are not very sensitive to bandwidth.
- gravypod 7y agoYea, the platform cost is higher. I ended up making a build you could make for ~$1,500 now. It was ~$1,600 when I made it. The biggest feature I'm interested in is the availability of PCIe lanes. I want this for adding a 10G nic later and two GPUs at some point as well (host & guest). If you don't need those features you're completely correct about the 3950x.
- jchw 7y agoAh, GPU passthrough? My biggest problem with virtualization is USB. I have a libvirt with GPU passthrough setup that works great, but have been unable to get a USB controller of any sort to passthrough; always winds up in a group with a bunch of other PCI-e devices. And ordinary forwarding with SPICE or something isn’t really sufficient for what I’d like to set up...
- voltagex_ 7y agoHave you tried IOMMU splitting? https://forums.unraid.net/topic/72027-iommu-group-splitting-for-pcie-passthrough-no-success-please-help/ https://forums.unraid.net/topic/72027-iommu-group-splitting-... (disclaimer - I don't own a board that can do this, I will one day, though).
- jchw 7y agoI have, though it causes a lot of stability problems :(
- simcop2387 7y agoIt's technically a security risk, but take a look at the acs patch that's out there. It'll forcefully split up the iommu groups to the hypervisor so you can do the pass through, but it does mean that the cards that were in the same group before can technically see each other's dma and other stuff on the bus. For anything other than a shared host it's pretty much fine though.
- floatboth 7y agoThis should be doable on desktop Ryzen. I currently have one GPU (x16) + NVMe SSD (x4) + 10G NIC (x4 from chipset). The 16x can be split x8/x8 for dual GPU. https://linustechtips.com/main/topic/799836-pcie-lanes-for-ryzen/?tab=comments#comment-10061434 https://linustechtips.com/main/topic/799836-pcie-lanes-for-r... — nice diagram of lanes
- gravypod 7y ago
- reitzensteinm 7y agoI do wonder if they'll continue with Threadripper. If it exists in the next generation, it might simply be as rebadged and slightly nerfed EPYC chips rather than something custom.
- opencl 7y agoAMD has already stated that they're going to continue with Threadripper. It would leave a fairly big gap in the lineup with nothing to compete against Intel's X299 platform. AM4 is lacking in memory channels and PCIe lanes. Epyc has much lower clockspeeds, much more expensive CPUs, and more expensive motherboards than Threadripper.
- bitL 7y agoI hope as well; moreover, I hope they'd release a 64 core TR next year that could last a decade (even if it costs 2,500+). There are rumors Zen 3 should bring 4-way SMP, i.e. 4 threads/core instead of 2, so that might lead to ridiculous numbers of threads in normal systems. As Lisa said, TRs were distinct to Epycs; I guess using UDIMMs vs RDIMMs and much higher base clock (except for the high freq EPYC 7371) led to a few changes.
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y ago> it might simply be as rebadged and slightly nerfed EPYC chips Well, that is what first-gen Threadripper was. Same socket and all, but with half the connected DDR lanes and a pin telling the motherboard it's not EPYC.
- reitzensteinm 7y agoThe first-gen Threadripper only had two dies, and even the WX series was a bit weird internally, with two of the four dies not being able to perform IO. I know it's not a big difference, but given the changes to IO and the 16 core consumer version, I don't see why there would be any internal difference to EPYC this time around (which this article claims will have a variable number of chiplets).
- 7y ago
- DuskStar 7y ago12C with 64MB cache for $499 is looking more and more like the sweet spot to me, too.