6 ms·
The ice bucket challenge dramatically accelerated the fight against ALS
- wolco 7y agoGetting people involved helps causes push forward.
- kleer001 7y agoSometimes. And even then only really when the problem is a single problem, and when it is solvable by throwing more money and people at it.
- murph-almighty 7y agoThis is wild- anecdata but I feel as though a lot of campaigns like this get a lot of "put your money where your mouth is"-type responses that are skeptical that web activism will have any impact. It's a relief that this pulled through and had a positive effect!
- jimbob45 7y agoThis appears to be a PR piece by the ALS-fighting company, The ALS Association, themselves.
- SEJeff 7y agoAnd if by company you mean registered nonprofit dedicated to fighting ALS, then yes, spot on.
- berdon 7y agoBeing a registered non-profit doesn't really exclude you from making money or being "evil". The majority of hospitals are non-profit, for example. I am in no way saying the ALS Association is evil.
- JamesBarney 7y agoI think it's pretty common to equate making money to making a profit for a corporation, and in that sense they don't make money.
- SEJeff 7y agoBut the context the GP used was to make it "evil" that the ALS non-profit released a post on the Ice Bucket Challenge benefiting ALS, which was sort of bone headed. Well why wouldn't they post that the money was used to help their cause? That's a good thing!
- rolltiide 7y agodoes that really discredit it instead of amplify ongoing efforts? like seriously what other organization on the planet is going to fund or even talk about any particular study, than the organization already incentivized to. what you want to look for is repeatable results that another generic organization can then do, not merely saying "hey look the sugar industry did this study about sugar, follow teh moneyz!"
- jMyles 7y agoI don't understand why you are being downvoted. This is certainly a PR piece and it makes no mention of whether any actual metrics have moved, just that a lot of money was raised.
- chc 7y agoPointing out that a press release on an organization's website is PR by that organization is simply not a useful comment. The only thing that comment added beyond pointing out the obvious was a way of phrasing it that implies that ALSA is somehow nefarious, which could generously be called a middlebrow dismissal.
- jimbob45 7y agoI commented when there were few comments on the article hoping to head off people from thinking it was a substantive article. My comment now seems like I'm trying to discredit them. I'm not. I want to see ALS conquered more than anyone. However, it is very difficult to learn anything new from a PR release and I was hoping to save everyone some time.
- oh_sigh 7y agoIt's literally a press release on the ALS associations website. Did you believe you were making an insightful comment when you hit the submit button?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- melling 7y agoHundreds of millions of dollars for research... The US alone is a $20 trillion economy. Harvard has a hedge fund of almost $40 billion, Yale is about $30 billion, ... We spend $18 billion on bottled water yearly. There’s a lot of money in the US economy that we just need to figure out how to get into basic research. Give up bottled water and donate the money to medical research for a few years?
- godzillabrennus 7y agoSpending money on research is one thing. Making it count is another. We spend enormous amounts of tax payer money on research that isn't reproducible. Lots of research isn't published. Research that is published is often produced in paid journals that restrict access. We need to upend the research industry. We need more of a sci-hub approach to research and less of an elsevier approach.
- DoofusOfDeath 7y agoI suspect your points are spot-on, but I wish we had concrete numbers associated with your bullet-list. Otherwise I'm not sure if I have things in proper perspective.
- melling 7y agoSure. That’s a separate problem. If we spend $1 and only get 50 cents worth of research, we should try to spend the money more effectively. Then if we double the research spending and double the effectiveness, we’ll get 4x the research.
- krick 7y agoExactly. It's naïve to think money is the problem. It's not like you can pile up a $1B in cache, make a huge bonfire out of it and cure some deadly disease for all humanity forever just like that. If it was, I'm pretty sure you could find a million people on the planet to donate a $1000 on average for that cause. But in reality, you are unlikely to get a $1000 from me even for the cause I find extremely important. For all I know, my money is going to end up in the pocket of some medical research center director, who is basically a politician and a fraud, with an income far surpassing mine to start with. And the new car he buys will provide zero help to solve the problem. Basically, I believe much more that government will spend my tax money wisely (which I don't believe, obviously), than I believe academia is able to somewhat efficiently convert money into solutions. And it doesn't matter if I'm right or wrong, it only matters that I'm not the only one like that, and it isn't even a human problem as much as the nature of how things are: and that exaplains, why the whole "there's so much resources(/money) in the world, why cannot we..." argument is silly.
- 0xfffafaCrash 7y agoThe article doesn't seem to make any references to concrete advances. It's unsurprising that an influx of donations resulted in an increase in research grants and money spent, but that's not the same thing as decreased mortality, morbidity, or even breakthroughs in understanding. A lot of research money is effectively wasted so until specific evidence is provided that there was a deep impact, I just see this as a particular special interest applauding money going in their direction (potentially at the expense of other causes which could make better use of it).
- Jmilin 7y agoAs a result of the funding, researchers were able to discover NEK1 - a newly tagged identify genetic factors contributing to amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). The article was published in Nature and can be found here. https://www.nature.com/articles/ng.3626 https://www.nature.com/articles/ng.3626. The discovery was a direct result of the money raised from the Ice Bucket Challenge.
- 0xfffafaCrash 7y agoThanks, on p.15 of the linked RTI report[0] a number of other recent publications are also pointed out as particularly significant (seemingly based on number of citations). Unfortunately, it's hard to gauge the extent to which these are likely to result in actual medical advances as someone who does not know the domain well. Would appreciate any insight from any researchers who can break it down a bit. [0] http://www.alsa.org/assets/pdfs/RTI-Report-FINAL.pdf http://www.alsa.org/assets/pdfs/RTI-Report-FINAL.pdf
- JamesBarney 7y agoWe probably won't know that for a long time. The lag time from basic research to FDA approved treatment is measured in decades.
- shpongled 7y agoDecades and billions and billions of dollars, plus a 90%+ failure rate.
- dannykwells 7y agoI am skeptical. Until they publish a number on "number of new trials funded" this is just the usual "more money is good because we get to spend more money" type of press release.
- Theodores 7y agoPink ribbons raise awareness of breast cancer, not how to tie a pink ribbons. The Ice Bucket Challenge raised awareness of how to do the Ice Bucket Challenge far more than awareness of what ALS is. Maybe that is why the money rolled in, it was an internet meme that wasn't rocket science to do but everyone wanted in on the fad. Fortunately for the ALS charity the default was for the money to go their way. So maybe not a win on awareness raising even if they did get the cash.
- chc 7y agoI don't see how you figure. There is no default place for money to go when people pour a bucket of ice water over their heads. It's not like the ALSA was selling ice. The only way it raised money was by raising awareness.
- Jmilin 7y agoAs a result of the funding, researchers were able to discover NEK1 - a newly tagged identify genetic factors contributing to amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). The article was published in Nature and can be found here. https://www.nature.com/articles/ng.3626 https://www.nature.com/articles/ng.3626. The discovery was a direct result of the money raised from the Ice Bucket Challenge and can be used today as an indicator of genetic predisposition to ALS.
- jshowa3 7y agoNot to be a Debby downer, but these posts always make me think of how many people just did this for a fad instead of meaningfully contributing. I almost think, why can't we just keep donating over and over, without the fad, at a lesser quantity if the fad produced such a significant contribution. I can understand that giving money can be just a waste, but if it really made such a significant impact, it seems like just taxing everyone and sending it directly to ALS would've done the same thing.
- MagicPropmaker 7y agoDoes it matter why people donated and/or became more aware of the disease?
- yingw787 7y agoMight be O/T, but I'm always surprised at how much our understanding of medical science comes down to basically a set of integration tests. You don't really know if your solution is going to be a global optimum (it probably isn't); you have to memorize a bunch of stuff in order to have the full context of a problem available when you approach a subset of it at work; and sometimes the "ideal" solution is so stochastic that you need multiple opinions / consensus. I guess it's kind of like hardware engineering; I think we only glossed over how the physics worked in a CPU worked before working on higher-level things like NPN/PNP transistors and such, but even so there's a digital abstraction layer in computer architecture that make effective reasoning so much easier (even though there's really no such thing as "digital", only analog and clear thresholds) Am I (hopefully) wrong on this? Can modern medicine ever come from a first-principles approach?
- astazangasta 7y agoNearly all medical advance goes like this: 1. Administer treatment to some patients. 2. See benefit. 3. Try it on more people. 4 (optional). Do research to understand mechanism. By and large medicine is not a "science" in the sense that it is interested in results, not building models.
- thoughtstheseus 7y agoAwesome, glad to see dumping ice water on your head and uploading it to social media accomplished something.
- RIMR 7y agoI was actually just talking about the Ice Bucket Challenge the other day, in regards to unexpected side-effects of an otherwise shining campaign. This viral challenge raised an unprecedented amount of money for awareness of ALS, as well as research and treatment. It was the first social media campaign of this type, and you'd be hard-pressed to find someone who hasn't heard of it. But it also created a very - weird - secondary effect. It encouraged teenagers to dump ice-cold water on themselves on camera, and upload it to YouTube for attention. You might see where this is going: Ice Bucket Challenges featuring teen girls were far more popular than any featuring men/boys. And the more revealing the girls' clothing, the more attention still. This has actually lead to a variety of water-based "challenges" that serve no other purpose than to put a wet, partially-dressed child in front of a camera for long enough for a pedophile to "enjoy" it. Now there are tens of thousands of generic "water challenge" and "pool challenge" videos that serve no altruistic purpose whatsoever. They exist just to attract views - and money. Many of these channels are run by parents who film their own tween daughters in skimpy bikinis a few days a week for ad revenue. "Desafio da Piscina" ("Pool Challenge" in Portuguese) is one of the most prevalent, with almost all videos shot in Brazil. I imagine that at $20USD/10k views, people in third-world countries can rake in a decent passive income selling sexualized videos of their children to the Internet. Sad part is that YouTube lets this happen, because it earns them money too.
- asdf333 7y agocan we have one for climate change?