7 ms·
Much of peacetime military procurement is all about keeping defense contractors alive "just in case" (which you could look at charitably as "maintaining readine
by nostrademons 7y ago
Much of peacetime military procurement is all about keeping defense contractors alive "just in case" (which you could look at charitably as "maintaining readiness for the next war" or uncharitably as "corporate welfare and pork barrel politics"). Right now, we're at peace. There's no reason for these companies to exist - except that if they didn't, it might encourage adversaries who believe it would be an opportune time for war.
A lot of things that don't really make sense on a military level make a lot more sense on a corporate welfare level. Each Virginia-class submarine is built half at Newport News in Virginia and half at Electric Boat in Connecticut; this is far more expensive than just building the subs in one yard, but is intended to keep both submarine manufacturers in business. The Ford class carriers and F-35 warplanes both contain numerous design innovations that don't really work in practice, but could be viewed as experimentation so that we have engineers with experience in various techniques should we ever need to rapidly build up the military later. The F-35 itself has a large number of subcontractors; you could look at that as a way to make sure that expertise in the program remains widely distributed across as many firms as possible.
I suspect the government is content to allow mergers because it doesn't really reduce the deterrent value of having these programs exist, and the whole point of their existence is to funnel money to defense contractors. If we actually got into a major arms race you'd probably see an explosion of new defense contractors as people start chasing the money available, but for now we're at peace with a shrinking military.
- lbotos 7y agoI agree with you re: keeping them alive, but the US is very much perpetually at war: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_the_lengths_of_United_States_participation_in_wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_the_lengths_of_United_... Almost so much so, that it seems like a reason to keep them alive.
- rhino369 7y agoThose low-grade conflicts aren't what much of the US military is designed for--a large conflict with another capable military force like China, Russia, etc. They are occupations and anti-surgency operations. A major conflict would require a lot of new manufacturing.
- nostrademons 7y agoIt's interesting to see the U.S. military retooling for these low-level occupation and anti-insurgency operations. Systems like the Zumwalt destroyers, littoral combat ships, America-class amphibious assault ships, Predator/Reaper/Avenger drones, and laser weapon systems are all adapted to low-intensity, close-to-shore work. I also wonder whether the assumption that the next big war will a great-power conflict with China, Russia, etc. will actually hold. Our template for what war looks like is WW2, because that's the last time in living memory that the whole world erupted in high intensity warfare. So we've naturally built a military machine to fight the last war, but with bigger and more high-tech weaponry. But historically, Peter Thiel's observation that "each moment in history happens only once" may be closer to the truth. The era of nation-states duking it out with industrialized armored weaponry started with the Russo-Japanese war in 1905 and ended with WW2 in 1945; it had never happened before, and it never happened afterwards. The previous template for wars before then were the "wars of nationalism" (U.S. civil war, unification of Germany, unification of Italy) in the 1860s-1870s - these had some use of industrialization, but still featured things like cavalry charges and generals personally leading troops into battle. Before then was Napoleon's conquest in 1812, and before that were the American and French revolutions, both of which were very different types of war with entirely different political groups on each side. For all we know, the next major war might look like Syria but on a global scale, with numerous non-national actors all fighting over territory, resources, and mindshare.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Our template for what war looks like is WW2, because that's the last time in living memory that the whole world erupted in high intensity warfare. So we've naturally built a military machine to fight the last war, but with bigger and more high-tech weaponry. This criticism might loosely have been true in the 1980s to 1990s, but doesn't seem particularly relevant now. > But historically, Peter Thiel's observation that "each moment in history happens only once" may be closer to the truth. It's obviously literally true, and it's been recognized as true more broadly in military matters since before Thiel was born. What is always in dispute until the next war starts is which lessons learned from the last one are critically in error now, not whether that will be the case somewhere.
- Relys 7y agoWe've always been at war with Eastasia.
- thinkpad20 7y agoConflicts which the military industrial complex has no interest in us ever getting out of, as recent events in Yemen demonstrate. Not to mention what's looming on the horizon in Venezuela or Iran. https://www.opensecrets.org/industries/lobbying.php?cycle=2018&ind=D https://www.opensecrets.org/industries/lobbying.php?cycle=20...
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>Not to mention what's looming on the horizon in Venezuela or Iran. Lol. Regarding Venzuela, there is still exactly zero appetite among the general public for another nation building boondoggle. So what if they have oil. We have plenty of oil too. The idea of "building" a friendly nation that's dependent on us to sell us oil has little upside these days. Regarding Iran, the defense industry is drooling over the idea that the next president may thaw relations and they'll be able to sell to both sides of the Iran/Israel standoff.
- 6nf 7y agoThe US is perpetually at ‘war’ on purpose. It helps to justify the military spending which in turn boosts the economy.
- branchan 7y agoBy saying that there is no reason for defense companies to outside of war, you are vastly underestimating the kind of projects they are involved in.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- avip 7y agoTo put it shortly, it may be the case that "we don't need F-35 because we have peace". But a more realistic POV is "We have peace because we build more F-35s" Si vis pacem, para bellum.
- aerophilic 7y agoInteresting perspective, but let me throw out this perspective from Sun Tzu: The greatest victory is that which requires no battle. Part of why we invest in defense is to ensure we never have to fight. True war is costly, by definition. It should be used as a last resort, when no other tool is available. Conversely, if you do have to deploy it, you want to be sure that it “changes the equation”. In other words, If it didn’t truly hurt/disable you or your opponent at the end if it, then there was no reason to do it in the first place. How does this relate to current US defense posture? In short: we want to make it such that no one wants to have a real fight with us, that instead they prefer discussions/diplomacy (at least at the nation state level). While folks complain about how much we spend in defense, a lot of it is not for the result per se (though ensuring cutting edge capability is important), but more to make the point that we are spending X times a given country A. This is intended to make country A less interested in being a bad actor to the US. Is this perfect? Probably not. Is there lots of waste? Certainly. But overall it has generally worked, and as such underlies much of why the US does what it does with military spending.