4 ms·
Google does sell personal data, a little at a time. If I make an ad that targets young dog owners in Seattle, then when someone clicks that ad I know Google thi
by sp332 7y ago
Google does sell personal data, a little at a time. If I make an ad that targets young dog owners in Seattle, then when someone clicks that ad I know Google thinks they're a young dog owner in Seattle. Google sold me data about that person.
- Kalium 7y agoSome might opine that you did not so much buy that data as buy the benefit of using that data. Afterwards, Google still has the data they used and you still don't. This might be a distinction worth discussing.
- sp332 7y agoNow that someone has visited your site through a particular ad, you do have that data about them.
- nostrademons 7y agoI guess, but that's basically the same information that you can get through the referer header in HTTP or by A/B testing different print ads. If you put up flyers in a certain neighborhood telling people to visit a URL, and you put up flyers in a different neighborhood with a different URL, then when somebody visits your site you know where they live. This is of a dramatically different scale from the information Google has for its own purposes.
- sp332 7y agoI would be a lot more OK with this if Google were only using that data about me themselves instead of letting anyone with a little money use it too!
- clairity 7y ago> "I would be a lot more OK with this if Google were only using that data about me themselves instead of letting anyone with a little money use it too!" that would be better, but google would still be subject to attacks by adversaries and (secret) subpeonas by governments. much better would be if they did their analytics on user data in real-time and store only the results while discarding the source data right away.
- nostrademons 7y agoThey have a project to do exactly that: https://ai.googleblog.com/2017/04/federated-learning-collaborative.html https://ai.googleblog.com/2017/04/federated-learning-collabo... IMHO this'll end up being one of the most influential research developments of the last few years, but it's only a couple years old at this point and needs a lot of supporting infrastructure (which'll have to be done by people outside of Google - the mothership has no economic incentive to support this) before it really works well.
- cameronbrown 7y agoNot that I'm saying we shouldn't be careful with our personal data, but: There's some serious mental gymnastics going from "young dog owners in Seattle" to selling somebody a dossier with their location, search & browsing history (all of which you can turn off).
- behringer 7y agoWhat? You can't turn off any of that. It's recorded whether you see it or not.
- cameronbrown 7y agoWhere's your evidence for this? Are you saying Google violates their privacy policy billions of times per day (every search, location update, page view)? (i.e. fraud)
- wmf 7y agoPresumably when you "turn off" various Google features that data is no longer used for ad targeting. For Google to do otherwise would invite a scandal. (I wouldn't expect all copies of the data and its backups to be deleted immediately since that would be a lot of work for the tape robots.) Check out https://www.google.com/ads/preferences/ https://www.google.com/ads/preferences/ and https://myaccount.google.com/activitycontrols https://myaccount.google.com/activitycontrols
- lucideer 7y agoThe mental gymnastics is in defining "selling data" as "selling all data Google has about you". This isn't a binary where it doesn't count if it's partial. Google provides selective contextual data about individuals to advertisers who target those individuals in exchange for money. Those advertisers are 3rd parties. Google sells data to 3rd parties. End of. They don't need to be handing over the full database for it to be a sale of data.
- cameronbrown 7y agoFine, how about a subset? Prove that an advertiser has seen one instance of my exact location, or an instance of my search or web history. 90% of the 'valuable contextual data' is that I searched for something related to an ad's keywords. The other ~% is targeted data. Targeting anonymised, generalised demographics/keywords which billions of people fit into does not class as selling private data. I'm not arguing to trust Google, nor am I denying that there is massive data brokerage in the advertising industry - just that there is a big difference between targeted ads and selling data.
- tzs 7y agoThat's one of the concerns I've heard raised over ad-supported email providers that target ads based on the content of your email. One way that could alleviate this but still allow targeting, although it might be too expensive to implement in practice, would be only allow ad targeting to be based on attributes of the viewer that are either very broad (e.g., gender, income quartile, age group, geographic region) or that correlate highly with use of the advertised product and do not correlate will with non-users of the product. For example, targeting "young dog owners in Seattle" would be OK on the "young" part and the "in Seattle" part because age group and region are whitelisted broad categories, but would not be OK on the "dog owners" part unless the product was in a category that dog owners use but people who are not dog owners do not. Dog food, for example, or a dog walking service. The idea is that if someone ran an ad for dog food targeting "young people in Seattle", rather than "young dog owners in Seattle", the respondents are going to largely be dog owners, and can reasonably expect that they are outing themselves as such to the seller. So allowing using "dog owners" in the targeting doesn't really give away any more information on the responders. The targeting just serves to not waste the time of people who don't own dogs seeing ads for dog food. If, on the other hand, "dog owner" could be used on the targeting for unrelated products, someone could target "young dog owners in Seattle" with an ad for something that almost everyone wants, and the people who respond out themselves as dog owners without having any way to reasonably know that they are doing so.
- wdr1 7y agoThat's pretty different from what's in the article.