2 ms·
Pretty sure the mechanics as detailed in the article are factually wrong. Google does not sell personal data. It collects all the personal data it can and the
by nostrademons 7y ago
Pretty sure the mechanics as detailed in the article are factually wrong. Google does not sell personal data. It collects all the personal data it can and then stockpiles it, where it becomes an asset that the company can use to build products and charge rent (largely from advertisers, but also from consumers). Selling an extremely valuable proprietary asset to competitors would be a really dumb move - the money in today's economy is in owning monopoly assets and charging rent for them.
The actual mechanism behind the behavior the author observed is that the user went to Google, searched for a product, and then visited the product's website. The product's website contains a tracking beacon that associates a unique cookie for the user with the visit. The website's owner can then choose to run ads on Facebook or Twitter that are shown only to people who previously visited the website. This program is well-known among Facebook advertisers (it's apparently quite profitable to them), but Facebook understandably doesn't publicize it much to the general public.
Agree that it'd be cool if the person involved could actually control who and where it went to and was compensated for the use of it, but that'd likely require a fundamental change in how the web works.
- delinka 7y agoI propose that it would require a minor change in web browsers only. Consider that we have 'incognito' and 'private browsing' sessions. The implementations are slightly different between browsers (e.g. Firefox appears to allow sharing between tabs in a window; Safari keeps each tab completely isolated), but the principle is the same. Modify the browsers so they're always in 'private' mode, and to only permit sharing once the bill is paid.
- nostrademons 7y agoPageviews within an individual incognito session still share cookies. If they didn't nearly every login on the web would break. When you create an incognito session just for one specific task and then close it, this doesn't matter. When you're always in incognito mode you're back where you started: a site that you're always logged into will have all the data from any site you visit with its tracking beacon.
- sp332 7y agoGoogle does sell personal data, a little at a time. If I make an ad that targets young dog owners in Seattle, then when someone clicks that ad I know Google thinks they're a young dog owner in Seattle. Google sold me data about that person.
- Kalium 7y agoSome might opine that you did not so much buy that data as buy the benefit of using that data. Afterwards, Google still has the data they used and you still don't. This might be a distinction worth discussing.
- sp332 7y agoNow that someone has visited your site through a particular ad, you do have that data about them.
- nostrademons 7y agoI guess, but that's basically the same information that you can get through the referer header in HTTP or by A/B testing different print ads. If you put up flyers in a certain neighborhood telling people to visit a URL, and you put up flyers in a different neighborhood with a different URL, then when somebody visits your site you know where they live. This is of a dramatically different scale from the information Google has for its own purposes.
- sp332 7y agoI would be a lot more OK with this if Google were only using that data about me themselves instead of letting anyone with a little money use it too!
- clairity 7y ago> "I would be a lot more OK with this if Google were only using that data about me themselves instead of letting anyone with a little money use it too!" that would be better, but google would still be subject to attacks by adversaries and (secret) subpeonas by governments. much better would be if they did their analytics on user data in real-time and store only the results while discarding the source data right away.