3 ms·
I think a default search engine and default first tab is fine as two examples where that list of demands is excessive. And depending on what “no network connec
by sokoloff 7y ago
I think a default search engine and default first tab is fine as two examples where that list of demands is excessive.
And depending on what “no network connections to third-party hosts unless I’ve explicitly opted in” means, this probably breaks CDNs, multi-host content serving, and lots of common js distribution mechanisms in ways that normal users will find confusing and result in “Firefox doesn’t work” if that’s the default it ships with.
- thrower123 7y agoI'm not sure why that is excessive, except that Mozilla made (maybe still does, I'm not sure) most of their money from getting paid to put search engines as their default. How hard is it to pop a dialog in the installer or on first run to let you pick? I don't think that is unreasonable. And the default tab just means loading a blank tab up. The last time I used Firefox, this was already a setting that you could pick.
- sokoloff 7y agoWhen I last installed it, the default tab was the Firefox home page (or some other Mozilla landing page), which seems perfectly reasonable to me. I find a lot of open source software insufficiently opinionated. Can't decide? Make it an option. Want to be "fair" to all? Make it an option and prompt the user during installation! As a user, I like when I have options but when some kind of sensible default has been pre-selected to shorten the time and mental effort between deciding to install and the first "wow" moment.
- brianpgordon 7y agoYou may be surprised at what the default looks like now- https://i.imgur.com/hGe837H.png https://i.imgur.com/hGe837H.png
- bwat49 7y agoAgreed, I was totally on board with the parent comment until those points. All browsers have a default search engine and start page... it's expected.
- asymptotically2 7y ago>All browsers have a default search engine and start page... it's expected. Maybe on the first launch you could get a wizard allowing you to pick your search engines, or to have none at all.
- smolder 7y agoI'm pretty sure the poster meant no 3rd party connections initiated by Firefox independently of what's in the actual HTML it's loading. No telemetry, in other words. I strongly agree that telemetry features should be excluded.
- sokoloff 7y agoReally? Isn’t the telemetry in the HTML on most sites? I assumed they were looking to block any cross-origin fetch that they hadn’t whitelisted.