2 ms·
> Now, I agree in theory that bank accounts for example may be regarded as “identities”, and it follows that banks could be regarded as “identity providers” (Id
by scotty79 7y ago
> Now, I agree in theory that bank accounts for example may be regarded as “identities”, and it follows that banks could be regarded as “identity providers” (IdPs). But these conceptual models have proved sterile. How many banks in fact see themselves as “identity providers”?
In Poland if you want anything from your government online you need to prove who you are. Easiest way to do that is to get redirected from government website to your bank website and login there then be bounced back to gov website.
Not sure how the system came to be but I'm very glad it's in place.
- NKCSS 7y agoSame here in .nl, you have a government digital id called Digid, but it’s just a login and password with optional sms 2fa, but we also have IDIN, which uses your banks hardware token, etc, to identify, which is better.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- madmaniak 7y agoI'm not so glad as this kind of integration is a huge threat to privacy. You should know you're not allowed to use public services you described if you will not provide your mobile phone (it looks like it's a civil duty to have one now). So you're tracked on each step literally.
- jeremyboom8 7y agoSame here in Sweden with the BankID system which I can use to 'sign' things on my mobile device, for example to do my taxes online (usually tax forms are pre-filled, so I only have to double check that it's correct), and do many other things. https://www.bankid.com/en/ https://www.bankid.com/en/
- PeterisP 7y agoWe have the same here in Latvia. There's an integration process available also for private services that essentially has the following workflow: 1) You redirect the user to the state 'identity service' with a specific token; 2) the user authorises either with their gov't ID card chip (less commonly used since most users don't have the chip reader) or with the bank of their choice (not all banks but most of the major ones are part of that scheme) for authentication; 3) the user gets a prompt like "company ABCD wants to get obtain the following data : Name, legal ID number" and can authenticate as normally; 4) you (as the service provider) get a response with your token, that legal ID number, and who authenticated that ID. It seems quite reasonable - it provides a reasonably secure way of verifying someone's identity (preventing e.g. the SIM-porting impersonation scams that seem to be a problem in USA) without giving anyone the ability to impersonate someone (the ID numbers aren't considered secret like USA social security numbers - they're PII so there are restrictions in storing/using them, but knowing them isn't sufficient to so anything).