4 ms·
I really am not confident that the ‘think tanks’ and the govt has even two brain cells behind this idea. 1. In 50 years, I predict that automation will erase m
by jelliclesfarm 7y ago
I really am not confident that the ‘think tanks’ and the govt has even two brain cells behind this idea.
1. In 50 years, I predict that automation will erase many jobs.
2. The notion that we need to live near where we work is going to become outdated and useless.
3. This is just another way for the govt to get it’s claws deeper into the tax payers wallets.
4. High density is incompatible with affordability. Any affordable housing is subsidised housing with monies that is redistributed.
5. We need more local governance rather than tyrannical regional governance in California with Sacramento dictating everything for everyone.
- raldi 7y ago> High density is incompatible with affordability Could you clarify this? There are countless affordable neighborhoods that are all apartments.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoI have never seen a highly populous city be affordable. It becomes a pressure cooker of market forces with the initial subsidized affordable housing ending up costing more and resources being redistributed to the point of infrastructure failing leading to more taxes leading to more unaffordability. It’s a vicious cycle. Affordable houses pay less taxes than market rate. High density still absorb more infrastructure. Where one house used stand, if there are 10 apartments..it’s that many x 2 cars on the street. It’s almost that many more children in public schools. It’s that many more households consuming water, power and need for general services. But schools don’t multiply..fire stations and police stations don’t increase to cater to the increase in population. Roads are not built to take care of the traffic nor is public transport improved. More housing = more taxes. That’s why the govt encourages. Affordable housing actually fatten up the funds for the care and feeding of big Gov more because what they don’t offer in high per household tax, they make up in volume. Net net, govt gets more $$ and the public gets less services. These 20 and 5@ year old multi billion projects never translate because they never see the light of day as they get obsolete quickly. That’s why the Bay Area looks so run down and unaffordable housing and traffic woes only keep increasing and never finds solutions.
- raldi 7y agoNYC's median household income is $51k. Half get by on less.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoBay Area isn’t NYC. We are earthquake country with dismal public transport. We are more people and more sprawl. And definitely more jobs. Not comparable. Do you think NYC is affordable for those earning 51k? Really?
- raldi 7y agoThe dismal public transport is what the proposal on the table will be taking aim at. What makes you think NYC is unaffordable to households making under $51k, and how do you explain the fact that half the populace is doing exactly that? What do earthquakes have to do with it? Half the megacities of Asia are in earthquake country.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoOn NYC: NYC is affordable to them only with rent control. Most people don’t have cars due to its public transport network that we lack in the Bay Area. The city has entertainment, easy access so people don’t have to leave their boroughs..never mind the city. We have land in California and can provide housing IF we improve public transport. Sacramento takes money earmarked for public transport and channels it for affordable housing. It is a pattern of deception. On Asian mega cities with high density, I am going to assume that you have lived there as you brought it up. Is that the kind of standard of living you think affordable high density housing advocates want in California? I see that you are housing advocate and I assume high density as you are dedicated to building more housing stock in San Francisco. I have lived in high density Asian cities and have commuted at 20 km/hour. Which is what is happening in the Bay Area too. How many parts of Asia do you think are earthquake prone? Please name them and their population density. I would like to compare quality of life between them and the bay area.
- kelnos 7y ago1. Assuming you're correct (which is certainly up for debate), what do we do for the next 50 years? Suffer? 2. Service jobs will always exist. Restaurants, bars, shops, museums, schools, etc. need people present to make them work. Even in cases where people aren't strictly required, people will still want people around. People will always need stuff that will need to be delivered to wherever they are. People also don't want to just stay in their homes all day; transit demand is not solely shaped by work commutes. 3. You draw the line in one place, other people draw it in others. Such is life. 4. There are quite a few cities in the world that will disagree with you, and be right. 5. We need people who will actually cooperate for the greater good. In the US that seems to be a rarity, as our culture is centered around individualism and competition, unlike many other places in the world. If we leave it up to a bunch of local governments cooperating we... oh, right, end up in the exact situation we're in now. (I agree with you in principle on #5, but a solution that has as a prerequisite, "change the deep-seated culture of millions of people over a relatively short period of time", isn't something I see as doable.)
- jelliclesfarm 7y ago1. We don’t have to suffer. We also don’t have to hand over 100 billion $ to the govt because they want it. Many of us may not even be around in 50 years. It is essentially paying for the next generation and also agreeing to pushing them into debt. Millennials will then be blamed not unlike baby boomers are blamed by millennials for ‘messing up the next generation future’. Where in fact, it’s agreeing to unrealistic long term plans like this and signing carte blanche whenever the state decides that we need to shell out without them being accountable. 2. I disagree that we will need to have service jobs. Or that people need to travel to be ‘around other people’ who want them around. Having said that, we do need public transport. We don’t need to lump affordable housing with public transport costs. Just like part of the gas tax was set aside to train prisoners to make them employable. It’s necessary but what’s with the shifty shenanigans? The public are lured into supporting housing and affordable housing imagining that it benefits them but that’s a marginal side effect. The real purpose of random and especially questionable rezoning to keep building is to create a stream of income through property taxes. Ditto with job creation. Jobs have an inflationary effect. An unemployed person in the rural area can still have avocado toast if he has a garden. He doesn’t need $10.00 to buy an avocado toast. However he can’t participate in the same economy as a 6 figure earning Silicon Valley resident of CA. However do note that all of them will be paying the same tax for public transport. As will their children over 50 years. 3. Sure. I will vote as inspired by my line. 4. I disagree. I literally don’t know any affordable city that is high density. If you include Mumbai’s slums or Hong Kong’s coffin apartments or NYC rent controlled and subsidized projects, I reject them. It’s not affordable. The cost of expensive living morphs from currency to something else that can be quantified in currency terms. There is a cost to cramming people in resource restricted areas which is also a fixed land area. 5. It’s such a general statement to say ‘ we need people to cooperate for a greater good’. It’s a feel good statement that means nothing unless we get down to specifics. The US is a better place to live in than most parts of the world. We don’t have tribal wars or bloody religious uprisings or bomb threats everyday. I disagree with you. I don’t know what cooperation you are talking about in ‘other parts of the world’. Admittedly there are other parts of the world where people cooperate and set aside individualism, but I am willing to bet that they are low density population areas where people have enough space. Cooperation thrives when everyone has the opportunity to make things work for everyone without just one group shouldering the burden. It is another way to make sure everyone carries equal responsibility. Cooperation is NOT co dependency.