4 ms·
I'm not harmed if I'm sitting next to a someone who is consuming sugar. What we should have is health insurance premiums based on risk factors such as obesity,
by kazinator 7y ago
I'm not harmed if I'm sitting next to a someone who is consuming sugar.
What we should have is health insurance premiums based on risk factors such as obesity, even in public systems.
- rootusrootus 7y agoThat could get exciting. Think of all the factors we could base health insurance on. Risky outdoor activities? Higher premiums. Biking to work? Higher premiums. Alternatively, we could work to help everyone become healthier, and then use as large a risk pool as possible to leverage the benefits of insurance.
- humanrebar 7y agoThe problem with "we can work to help" is that "we" will at times be helping even if another "we" doesn't see it as particularly helpful. I have a problem with the presumption of unrelenting competence, good faith, and humaneness in a bureaucratic organization despite the inevitable pressure from various political factions and lobbying groups.
- kazinator 7y agoShrug; I'm honestly just grasping at a straw there to form a plausible hypothesis of how someone else's sugar consumption affects me in the way that cigarette smoke does. Since I have to pay taxes and forced public health insurance premiums (that are based on my income rather than claim history or health), that's what it must be. Anything unhealthful indulged by a large segment of the population is increasing that burden.
- beatgammit 7y agoWell, life insurance does that. I recall having someone over to check my health and they had me fill out a form detailing the types of activities I do (it even covered skydiving). Since I'm healthy, I got a fantastic rate. However, nothing like that happened for my health insurance. The closest I have is a program that helps pay for my gym membership if I go regularly. The really silly thing is that I'm not able to go regularly because I ride my bike a lot, yet I am likely more healthy because of that than many of the people who go to the gym regularly. Honestly, I would totally be down with a voluntary system like that for things like obesity, smoking, etc. If I present a lower risk to the insurance company, shouldn't I be rewarded with lower rates? If that were the case, I think more people would make real changes to their lives instead of fiddling with fad diets, pedometers, and gym memberships. Saving $20/month on a gym membership or getting a free Fitbit is less motivating than saving $100/month for being healthy.
- humanrebar 7y agoThis is closest to where I am on this issue, but I do worry that government-set premiums will be affected by lobbying more than anything else.
- lm28469 7y ago> What we should have is health insurance premiums based on risk factors such as obesity, even in public systems. Next thing we know we're all constantly monitored for every single health metrics and pay more for every one that is slightly off. "Bacon every morning ? Well sorry sir but that'll be $30 more per year. Oh and you drive to work instead of cycling, that's another $60. Our tracking system tells us that you were sitting more than 7 hours per day on average for the last month so we'll have to charge you $0.55 per seated hours for the next 6 months. You should also think about your monthly running goal, you only have 3 days left and 36km to go." We could also stop insuring people when they start getting unhealthy. Imagine the profit !! /s What we should do is better educate people about health and stop trying to get them addicted as much and as early as we can.
- kazinator 7y agoTo avoid these complexities, insurance companies use past claims history as an estimate of future claims and hence premiums. Of course, that apply very well for one-time items like life insurance.
- kazinator 7y ago^ that doesn't apply well ... to
- ricardobeat 7y agoYou’ll get your premium raised for high glucose or cholesterol levels in the Netherlands. Prices are regulated though, and you can’t be denied insurance.