3 ms·
The article cites the fact that there are 10 administrators for every actual doctor or nurse, and these lines should be cut in half to instead be spent on more
by ineedasername 7y ago
The article cites the fact that there are 10 administrators for every actual doctor or nurse, and these lines should be cut in half to instead be spent on more doctors and nurses.
I think this represents a gross oversimplification, overlooking the necessary work of administrative staff. It's not unlike the airforce: there are about 23,000 pilots but 500,000 personnel, a ratio of more than 20:1. It takes a lot to support the enterprise that keeps planes in the air.
In the medical profession, someone has to keep the enterprise running. Cataloging medical imagery & seek and retrieve records as needed. Accountants and HR departments, IT departments, working with insurance companies, all of it. Even with the amount of EMR work doctors & nurses may do themselves, it takes a tremendous amount of background "plumbing" work to allow them to focus on the actual treatment. I'm not saying there isn't any administrative bloat anywhere, but I am saying that non-practitioner staff in the industry feel this resource crunch quite a bit themselves too. The technician running the radiology suite feels just as much pressure to help fit in that extra patient and stay beyond scheduled hours to do so. Treating the entire non-doctor/non-nursing staff as bloat is an extreme disservice to the mission critical work they perform.
I am literally taking my 1.5 year old son home from the hospital today after an emergency visit that kept us there for days, and during this ordeal I dealt with at least 3 or 4 non practicing staff that went above and beyond their duties to help with something and smooth the process over for the work that doctors and nurses needed to perform. These staff feel the ethical drive to serve every bit as much, it just happens to be less visible.
- danmaz74 7y agoHow much of the administrative staff you mention is only needed because hospitals have to work as for profit organizations? And don't forget to add the administrative staff from the insurance companies themselves.
- ineedasername 7y agoInsurance companies are a separate issue, though some of their administrative functions would be required in any healthcare system. (Certainly not all though). As for hospitals working for-profit, about the only administrative function I can think of that is unique to that model is marketing. I may be missing something, but even so it would be very, very much less than the 50% the author of the article would do away with.
- nugget 7y agoNon profit status isn't an instant fix for a dysfunctional system. Once the profit motive is removed, other incentives take over as primary motivators. The not for profit, Government-run Veterans Affairs hospitals have a higher administrator to physician ratio than most private hospitals and are well known within medicine for inane administrative roadblocks to effective patient care.
- ineedasername 7y agoYes, the profit motive does enforce at least a little pressure on reducing unnecessary overhead. This is of course not universally the case.