4 ms·
> plugins are available for proprietary software I’m genuinely surprised that FOSS projects like Blender (or, for another example, GIMP) don’t offer ABI compat
by derefr 7y ago
> plugins are available for proprietary software
I’m genuinely surprised that FOSS projects like Blender (or, for another example, GIMP) don’t offer ABI compatibility to allow the use of plugins made for the specific nonstandard ABIs of popular proprietary systems.
Anyone know why they don’t? Is it just a platform thing—e.g. having to support those plugins would mean having to compile winelib into your project?
- mapgrep 7y agoCan whomever is downvoting explain why this approach wouldn’t work? I think the above is a very insightful comment.
- jjoonathan 7y agoI didn't downvote, but I would expect most programmers to be able to guess at the gigantic amount of effort required to maintain compatibility across a considerable semantic mismatch and at least understand the choice to spend resources elsewhere, especially in the context of open source, where there is no payroll to mitigate drudgery.
- lozenge 7y agoProbably the internal data model is different? So ABI compatibility would mean rewriting an entire model into the in-memory format of the other software, running the plugin and converting back.
- insulanus 7y agoThis is incredibly hard to do, because you have to emulate the innards of the other program. Exposing an identical API for something is super easy, it's what happens on the inside of the program that takes all the work. And since you can't know what's in the other program, it could get as difficult as e.g. reverse-engineering video card drivers.
- zrobotics 7y agoI would imagine it is due to copyright concerns-see Google's Java API implementation woes. Additionally, the wine devs have very specific rules [0] about who can contribute, ideally they don't want contributions from people who have read the win2k leaked source. And I certainly wouldn't want to give Adobe any reasons to sue me, especially as Blender almost certainly can't afford to fight them in court. [0] https://wiki.winehq.org/Developer_FAQ#Who_can.27t_contribute_to_Wine.3F https://wiki.winehq.org/Developer_FAQ#Who_can.27t_contribute...
- edflsafoiewq 7y agoBlender addons are written in Python and routinely break between Blender versions (2.8 broke basically every existing addon because of API churn). If there is not even compatibility between Blender versions, there is no chance compatibility will be maintained with random proprietary programs. Also many of the features are quite different than their equivalent elsewhere (armatures for instance).