4 ms·
A comment that sounded sincere was deleted while I responded to it. Quick answer: I mentioned a religious congregation because I thought it wasn't well-known i
by neilv 7y ago
A comment that sounded sincere was deleted while I responded to it.
Quick answer: I mentioned a religious congregation because I thought it wasn't well-known in HN circles.
My intent was actually to use this as an opportunity to try to explain something I know about some complicated group. All of us fellow humans have so much misunderstanding between so many groups, contributing to conflict and disrespect, often for no good reason.
(For example, religious/cultural congregations aren't just about doctrine and dogma passed down from parents -- or often aren't even about that at all, for many people -- but are often things that people are in for reasons we can maybe appreciate and understand. Then we can address actual problems better, together.)
- pessimizer 7y agoI'm the opposite of religious, and there's no doubt that the political strength (and happiness, and comfort) of religious groups lies almost completely in the fact that they meet regularly at a dedicated meeting facility, and this while this meeting can be gotten out of, it requires some sort of excuse, and an individual's consistent absence is considered a mild crisis for the group. The group is also expected to favor its members, and to provide mutual aid, and as the group increases in size, that mutual aid is often delivered in a form mutually beneficial to the helper and the helped e.g. one member needs work, another member needs a worker they can trust. Many/most religious people have a very loose idea of the orthodoxies of their own religions, but they know everything about what's going on at their church, and in the lives of other people who attend it. Secular traditions can't really survive over the long term without designing similar structures. I doubt that individualist ideologies can do this at all, because they tend to feel that obligation without contract is not a thing, and even that the strength of obligation with contract is directly related to the ability to enforce that contract.
- brighter2morrow 7y agoI think it's hard for no religious institutions to form cohesive groups because they don't have a commonly-held value structure. Indeed once you start to impose values on group members then for all intents and purposes you become quasi-religious because there's no materially bound "value-driven particles" or similar physical structure to values.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- krastanov 7y agoThere are plenty of secular groups that have cohesion (either between entire family units or between people without the rest of their family): non-religious scouting organizations, hiking groups, various volunteer groups, some political groups, gaming "clans", fan clubs, neighborhood groups... All of them are easy to join and leave and have churn, just like churches do when people move in or out of their region.
- em-bee 7y agoany group that has a common goal will work here. Linux User Groups, scouts, you name it. none of these groups would stay together without a common value structure. religion is nothing special here.
- em-bee 7y agoany religious group that considers your occasional absence as a crisis is a group i'd stay away from. but fortunately not all religious groups are like that. if anything, for things like scouting and sports groups, or any kind of group where you learn something together it is more important that members attend regularly.
- Kuiper 7y ago>>while this meeting can be gotten out of, it requires some sort of excuse, and an individual's consistent absence is considered a mild crisis for the group. >any religious group that considers your occasional absence as a crisis is a group i'd stay away from. Indeed, which is probably why the poster you're responding to specifically made the point about consistent absence (not occasional absence) and it being a mild crisis. Most religious communities I've observed are also quite lax about what qualifies as an excuse. For example, any sort of travel (be it vacation, visiting family, going on a business trip, or traveling with the team for little Jimmy's soccer tournament), seems to be accepted as valid excuse. So are other institutional commitments, provided that they don't become regular/recurring reasons for missing religious attendance. "I overslept" or "I was tired after staying up late Saturday night" or "I decided that there were other activities I'd prefer to spend my Sunday doing" are not. Furthermore, having your absence declared to be a "mild crisis" for the group is not necessarily a bad thing: certain excuses like being sick (or caring for a sick family member) are likely to draw the support of the group; if you're in a small religious community where people hold each other accountable for religious attendance, there's a decent chance that if members of your church know that you missed Sunday service due to being ill or pregnant or recovering from surgery (or caring for a family member who is any of the above), some of them will stop by later in the afternoon (or later in the week) to drop off a home-cooked meal or some other sort of care package. (I understand that some people might prefer to deal with their health situation in private without having a community of people who take it upon themselves to offer support, and I've always been one to appreciate the benefits of solitude and privacy, but in contemporary society I feel like we may have veered too far in the direction of isolation and atomization.) >if anything, for things like scouting and sports groups, or any kind of group where you learn something together it is more important that members attend regularly. Many religious practices involve a service that involves teaching (for example, a "sermon" that is delivered to a congregation by a preacher), so for many people, religious attendance falls into the category of "group where you learn something together." Indeed, I've observed it's common for many churches to have weekly sermons that are part of a "series," offering a sort of week-to-week continuity as they provide a deep exploration of a single topic over the course of a month, so if you miss a single service you might perhaps be inclined to ask a friend what was covered in the sermon later in the week when you meet them at something like a Wednesday Bible study or a Tuesday morning prayer group.
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoThis is a really good point, and one that I think a lot of non-religious people don't get. Organized religion is first and foremost a community. It's friends and neighbors being kind to each other. It can turn toxic when that community is used to abuse people, impose bigotry, and demand blind loyalty. But that's not fundamental to the concept, and indeed many religious people and church groups don't do that. I grew up in a very tolerant, progressive Episcopalian family, for example. As a teen I went to a summer church camp where the theme for the entire week was sex and how to approach it with tolerance and wisdom. If you want to understand and guard against the awful parts of religion, you need to understand the good parts that make people participate in the first place.