4 ms·
It seems to me that one of the most critical safety components of a nuclear reactor is the successful isolation of its operation from political or financial pre
by Waterluvian 7y ago
It seems to me that one of the most critical safety components of a nuclear reactor is the successful isolation of its operation from political or financial pressures.
How do atomic energy organizations succeed in doing this?
- Zealotux 7y ago>How do atomic energy organizations succeed in doing this? From my knowledge: they mostly don't. For example, in France, we have the Autorité de sûreté nucléaire (Nuclear Safety Authority, ASN) which is supposed to be an independent and transparent authority on nuclear safety and information. However: it has been criticized many times since its inception in 2006 regarding conflicts of interest[1][2], and lacks in terms of safety issues reporting[3]. I'm glad my country invested so much into nuclear energies, I still believe it's our best chance at tackling the upcoming crisis, but we should not let nuclear in the hands of private interests. Governments _have_ to apply a zero-tolerance policy when it comes to safety, regulation, and transparency, regardless of how expensive and inconvenient it is. We're not doing enough, in France[4], when it comes to safety, from within or without. On top of that: it's giving fuel to anti-nuclear militantism. [1] http://www.observatoire-du-nucleaire.org/spip.php?article281 http://www.observatoire-du-nucleaire.org/spip.php?article281 [2] https://www.cairn.info/revue-revue-juridique-de-l-environnement-2013-1-page-7.htm# https://www.cairn.info/revue-revue-juridique-de-l-environnem... [3] http://mai68.org/spip2/spip.php?article1347 http://mai68.org/spip2/spip.php?article1347 [4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=STjGOGkMz4k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=STjGOGkMz4k
- aianus 7y ago> Governments _have_ to apply a zero-tolerance policy when it comes to safety, regulation, and transparency, regardless of how expensive and inconvenient it is. Only in combination with some kind of carbon tax, otherwise you make nuclear too expensive compared to coal or natural gas whose costs are externalized and harder to quantify than nuclear regulatory compliance.
- odiroot 7y agoHow come France is so reasonable and pragmatic with this where most other western EU (especially Germany) are going the Luddite way?
- Zealotux 7y agoThe anti-nuclear sentiment is pretty strong in France as well[1], but if we compare to Germany for example: - in 2016, 72% of the energy generation in France was nuclear, Germany never came close to that percentage[2], therefore making it easier to transition away from it. - France invested a lot into nuclear energy and no government since then would dare to throw such a huge industry (2500 companies, 222 000 jobs) into the trash. I don't think it was the case with other European countries. There's a lot of pride surrounding our history of nuclear research (since Pierre and Marie Curie), and politicians are often accused by militants of falling for the sunken-cost fallacy or to have a misplaced pride into the industry ("En France on n'a pas de pétrole mais on a des idées" - "In France, we don't have oil, but we sure have ideas"). Ultimately: the percentage of nuclear-based energy in France should go down to 50% by 2025, I just hope we'll manage to reduce our carbon monoxide emissions as well, Germany gave up on nuclear and they're failing at that so far. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-nuclear_movement_in_France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-nuclear_movement_in_Franc... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_Germany#/media/File:Electricity_production_in_Germany.PNG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_Germany#/medi...
- pgeorgi 7y ago> France invested a lot into nuclear energy and no government since then would dare to throw such a huge industry (2500 companies, 222 000 jobs) into the trash. I don't think it was the case with other European countries. Germany all but killed off an industry of 80000 jobs (at the time) in the blink of an eye: photovoltaics. One other main difference is that having your own nuclear industry is also important for countries aiming for (or having) nuclear deterrence power, like France (and unlike Germany which merely hosts US nukes).
- Faark 7y ago
- inflatableDodo 7y agoThe only group that I know of that gets closest to treating nuclear power like you would want a civil nuclear organisation to behave, is the US Navy. Maybe part of it is that they live on theirs. Can we all globally adopt the US Navy and somehow make it their mission to provide and protect nuclear power, rather than their current mission of threatening randomly selected countries based on the whims of professional eschatologists? It would make a lot more sense overall, and I suspect they would enjoy it just as much.