8 ms·
Researchers propose solar methanol island using ocean CO₂
- tambourine_man 7y ago>…and has an energy storage efficiency of 8% over a 20-year lifetime. The concept is fun to imagine but these numbers look pretty lousy.
- sp332 7y agoThe energy is free, so efficiency is only important for comparison reasons. Is there something better we could be doing with that solar panel output? Solar panels themselves are maybe 22% efficient to begin with so this process cuts the efficiently to about 1/3. Personally, I'm impressed that it's even positive.
- hirundo 7y ago100meter^2 x 170,000 solar panel units (to replace long-haul transportation fuel) would be a 1700km^2 square, 41km per side. That's a bit smaller than Fiji and more compact. If you add 50% for methanol manufacture it's almost up to the area of Haiti. So the oceans have plenty of room for it anyway.
- mrfusion 7y agoWouldn’t it make sense to build these on large lakes and skip the desalination step?
- fernly 7y agoOne reason that springs to mind is the shortage of large lakes near the equator. Solar "lily pads" would be much less efficient on the Great Lakes or Lake Baikal, and have seasonal swings of output.
- sp332 7y agoThat wouldn't help de-acidify the oceans. But I guess through diffusion it's all connected anyway.
- riffraff 7y agoThe Mediterranean is connected to the oceans and to the black sea but their salinity is really different, I do not believe diffusion works as easily.
- sp332 7y agoRight but if you take CO2 from the Mediterranean, then it will absorb more from the air, which means the oceans will absorb less from the air.
- credit_guy 7y agoThis sounds like a brilliant idea. Instead of off-shore wind farms, off-shore solar power generation. Convert the electrical energy into chemical one (methanol) and ship it to the consumers. No need for huge upfront investments (those huge wind turbines must cost a pretty penny), or for large underwater cables to carry electricity inland. These floating solar panels could be deployed far away from maritime sea lines, like in the middle of the Pacific. Plenty of sun. No problem with sandstorms, like for solar farms in deserts. If a hurricane is forecasted, you pack up and move away. No need to buy the land from owners who want to hold out for a better price. What's not to like?
- bsder 7y ago> What's not to like? Salt. Salt makes operating things in the seas an absolute maintenance nightmare.
- D_Alex 7y agoOh, yesss. Also, bird poop. Seriously - it is already a problem for solar cells on unmanned offshore oil and gas platforms.
- credit_guy 7y agoIf this was completely without any obstacles, it would have been brought to market about 50 years ago. There are obstacles for sure, but they don't sound insurmountable to me. Salt. Salt is a problem for anything that floats on the ocean. Plenty of things do that, it's not such a deal breaker. Bird poop. You need to either be close to some islands, or in the middle of some migration line. In the Pacific ocean there are millions of square miles that don't qualify for either of that. Barnacles, mollusks, etc. Maybe you can get away with some special paints, or with periodic cleanup. Mauybe you need to coat the bottom of the floating structure with some film of pesticide-infused plastic. I don't know. But I'm willing to give this idea a chance to succeed. What are the alternatives? Floating nuclear power plants?
- 7y ago
- frankbreetz 7y agoThis is such a novel idea. This is an example of why we need huge investment in this type of thing(idk if you call it green). I would have never thought of something like this, it won't impact the average person's life and it is carbon neutral. If this exact thing won't solve the biggest problem of our lifetime, something like it will.
- readams 7y agoWhy not just do this on the shore instead of a floating ship with unmaintainable floating solar islands? I suspect the more realistic scenario though would be to use a huge nuclear power plant to make fuel by pulling CO_2 from the air.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- danielharan 7y agoUnless we have costs breakthroughs in nuclear, solar is going to stay cheaper.
- andromeduck 7y agoI doubt solar is actually cheaper for this process right now.
- wallace_f 7y agoLast I read Japan still has green plans involving hydrogen. They could just save a step, thereby also conserving energy. In fact, that's an old proposition as an alternative to fossil fuels. Too bad nuclear has enormous public image and political cost problems.
- bjelkeman-again 7y agoThis seems like an old Idea, repackaged with a bit of new technology, i.e. solar panels. Here is a paper from 1984, suggesting methanol production from Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion (OTEC). https://www.jhuapl.edu/techdigest/views/pdfs/V05_N2_1984/V5_N2_1984_Avery.pdf https://www.jhuapl.edu/techdigest/views/pdfs/V05_N2_1984/V5_... What is OTEC? http://www.otecnews.org/what-is-otec/ http://www.otecnews.org/what-is-otec/ Disclaimer: I started OTEC News once upon a time.
- moneytide1 7y agoInteresting idea, I wonder how it can be protected from rough seas?
- bamboozled 7y agoIt says in the article that it would be built in areas of the ocean where break wave heights don’t exceed 7 feet.
- hackerbabz 7y agoBut is that just where wave heights rarely exceed 7 feet? It seems like they would still need some kind of safe mode to deal with once per year/once per ten years conditions. Maybe the could fold up.
- moneytide1 7y agoAll the land above sea level between 1'-20' soon (relatively) to be usurped by the measurable volumes of ice being depleted already have lots of pipe and structural (piles and beams) infrastructure protected underground and may could be retrofitted to support the safe mode folding you are suggesting.
- wolfi1 7y agoI wonder about the energy payback time or in that case rather the CO2 payback time. The CO2 released through production of silicon is not negligable (in fact for every silicon atom a CO2 molecule is released regardless of the CO2 released during the energy production)
- URSpider94 7y agoI found an article from 2010 saying that the CO2 breakeven for solar PV was at around the 3-year mark. That article mentioned 225 W panels, the state of the art today is 400W with presumably the same CO2 load to produce. So that would put the payback at more like 2 years. It would get worse again to account for the energy losses in the desalination, CO2 collection and conversion.
- zeristor 7y agoSince this CO2 production at a point source it should be easier to capture, and so removed from the equation. It sounds like quite a concentrated source of CO2.
- longemen3000 7y agoFor what I know, about methanol extraction, it depends of various factors. If we can sacrifice portability, we can just pump salt water to a facility, extract the CO2, and pump it back. What I find novel in this approach is the utilization of seawater for the carbon extraction, but the other steps are known or in active research.
- manicdee 7y agoSpaceX will be looking for bulk methane and oxygen supply at their offshore Earth-to-Earth transport system within the decade.
- infogulch 7y agoThese floating fuel production facilities could be nice for ships too - refueling en route means you have to carry less fuel and you run more efficiently.
- cheschire 7y agoWhat happens to sea life when we restrict the sun over a large area like this? How much microscopic sea life would be killed off in enormous quantities, and would that generate toxicity worse than the CO2 currently being absorbed by the ocean?
- DougN7 7y agoThese secondary effects are what I’m concerned about as well. Seems this would create a dead zone.
- blacksqr 7y agoThere's already a highly efficient solar-powered process for extracting carbon dioxide from seawater called "growing seaweed." It would be far more efficient simply to collect seaweed from the ocean and put it through fermentation and dry distillation processes to produce ethanol and other fuel products. No new technology breakthroughs required.
- blix 7y agoI do believe there is work being done on this. That said, removing carbon from the oceans, burning it and releasing it back into the atmosphere feels a little bit counterproductive to me.
- EugeneOZ 7y agoAt least it will slowdown oceans acidification until people find how to give enough power to the planes without liquid fuel. In this particular idea I don't like the ship - it will pollute the ocean while transferring the fuel.
- afiori 7y agoI ear a lot of talk about airplane pollution, is it actually a significant contribution?
- T-A 7y agoAbout 2% of CO2 emissions, according to this: https://www.atag.org/facts-figures.html https://www.atag.org/facts-figures.html
- EugeneOZ 7y agoDoesn't matter. Point is: while we need airplanes, we need to power them. While we can't power them using "green" sources of power, we should use liquid fuels. And while we need them, this idea (topic-starter) sounds reasonable.
- blacksqr 7y ago
- LifeLiverTransp 7y agoWhy not produce artifical steam - aka clouds when the wind is right and make it rain over dry country?
- _Microft 7y agoI couldn't find anything in the paper how or if the channels are filtered. Microorganisms in the water would be subjected to pretty abnormal conditions while being pumped through the acidic and basic channels, so I hope they do filter the water well?
- kwhitefoot 7y ago> electrifying trucks .. has proved intractable in the near-term, Really? See https://logisticsmgepsupv.wordpress.com/2019/06/01/supermarkets-and-electric-vehicles/ https://logisticsmgepsupv.wordpress.com/2019/06/01/supermark..., https://www.libertyplugins.com/blog/2019/06/07/byd-electric-garbage-truck-now-servicing-seattle/ https://www.libertyplugins.com/blog/2019/06/07/byd-electric-..., http://mechcrunch.com/2019/05/10/rigterink-logistics-group-tests-eactros-mercedes-benz-passion-blog-mercedes-benz-smart-maybach-amg/ http://mechcrunch.com/2019/05/10/rigterink-logistics-group-t... I don't claim they are perfect but it does seem not to be intractable.
- degyves 7y agoThe most impressive to me, is to read only a single comment worried about the ecological impact and the sustainability