4 ms·
Minnesota's supreme court shot down such cameras years ago and as far as I know it didn't turn into mad Max on the roads compared to other states. It doesn't s
by duxup 7y ago
Minnesota's supreme court shot down such cameras years ago and as far as I know it didn't turn into mad Max on the roads compared to other states.
It doesn't seem like there is a great deal of benefit.
- dokem 7y agoYea I haven't really ever seen anyone run red lights. Is it even a problem?
- avocado4 7y agoIt's pretty normal to run red lights in San Francisco.
- btrettel 7y agoMight depend on the location. I've seen more red light runners in the half decade I've lived in Austin than the remainder of my life. Another possibility is that I might be paying more attention to the problem now than before.
- frosted-flakes 7y agoI don't think it's common to blatantly run a red light. In fact, it's extremely frowned upon in Western society, to the point that 99% of people will wait for the green signal even if it's the middle of the night and there's no-one around (compare that to, e.g. India, where I've heard that traffic signals are mere suggestions). But stretching the green past the yellow and into the red? That happens all the time, and I suspect it's the vast majority of what these cameras catch. People justify it because "oh, it was just a few seconds" or "but it was still yellow!".
- kolinko 7y agoThe all-famous „dark-yellow” :)
- zachwood 7y agoWhere I live, it happens hundreds of times per day. And that's just the ones recorded. https://denverite.com/2018/12/05/denvers-small-force-of-red-light-cameras-and-electronic-speed-traps-will-grow-but-cdot-blocked-police-from-putting-them-at-crucial-dangerous-intersections/ https://denverite.com/2018/12/05/denvers-small-force-of-red-...
- RandomBacon 7y agoIt's extremely common in Houston, Texas. Also very common is uninsured motorists, unlicensed motorists, and unregistered vehicles; so make sure to have the appropriate coverage and look both ways even when you have the green light. I highly recommend front and rear dash cams. Famous epitaph: He died defending his right of way. His way was right, his will was strong, But he's just as dead as if he was wrong.
- HillaryBriss 7y agoMy sense in Los Angeles is that traffic laws mostly go unenforced. This allows persistent, continuous safety hazards for pedestrians and compliant drivers. We have a situation where running stop signs and red lights, speeding, reckless driving and gridlocking behaviors are rewarded and very, very rarely penalized. State laws require revenue from traffic violations to flow to the state of California rather than to the locality so the LAPD's incentive to spend costly officer time on traffic enforcement is quite weak. IMHO, in Los Angeles, automated enforcement measures would be worthwhile.
- stefan_ 7y agoYou don't believe there is a great deal of benefit improving road safety despite the abysmal safety record of personal car transport? Vehicular deaths are the leading cause of death for teenagers and below, often killing people that weren't even driving themselves. The vast, vast majority of those deaths involve trivially controlled and avoided law-breaking such as running red lights, stop signs or exceeding the speed limit.
- duxup 7y agoDo you feel red light cameras reduce those deaths?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoI'll flip the question: Drunk driving is the leading cause of vehicular deaths. The government could require manufacturers include an breathalyzer in all cars, and make it so cars don't start unless you use that. Unrestrained occupants are one of the other leading causes. Again, we could make cars not start unless you buckle up. If the reason for invading our privacy would be to save our lives, why not go where it actually matters and actually avoid people breaking the law instead of enforcement. Why go with a system that extends police tracking to all public areas while minimizing the actual lives saved?
- stefan_ 7y agoI think breathalyzers would be great, but I believe the reliability isn't at all there. Seatbelts are only a protective devices once you are already in a crash, not their root cause. Modern cars will also already incessantly beep to you, and people stupid enough to buy a defeat device for them might as well fly out the windshield for all I care, their behavior isn't likely to cause much harm for others. But I'm not at all opposed. I'm happy to do away with speed cams if we can simply have modern cars enforce the speed limits they already know about.
- 7y ago