5 ms·
I think part of the problem is "protected classes". I learned the other day that if you're over 40 you're a protected class for engineering in California. If
by jedberg 7y ago
I think part of the problem is "protected classes". I learned the other day that if you're over 40 you're a protected class for engineering in California.
If you're a protected class and you have a job, that's great! It will help you a lot. But the unintended consequence is that companies are more reluctant to hire someone in a protected class, because if they are legitimately bad at their job, they are harder to get rid of.
I still think we should have protected classes, but the protection needs to reach into hiring too. Maybe make companies have to submit written justification for not hiring someone in a protected class? I don't know I'm just spitballing here.
- WalterBright 7y agoIt's well known that the harder the government makes it to fire someone, the equally harder it will be to get hired. It's just that people don't want to believe it.
- bachmeier 7y agoI can't speak to California law, but in general the bar for age discrimination is so high that it doesn't mean much.
- koolba 7y agoThe threat of a lawsuit, no matter how frivolous, is enough to dissuade employers.
- donjigweed 7y agoThese days, holding all other factors constant, SV companies will generally hire {gay|female|trans|minority} candidates before {male|white|indian|asian}. So companies are apparently not at all concerned about hiring members of protected classes, rather they prefer to hire them. Now, if you want to make the argument that older employees don't boost the companies D&I numbers, while at the same incurring the risk of a protected class, that's a subtly different argument....
- shearskill 7y agoTFA is about ageism which still affects all the “preferred” candidates you listed. How many older women engineers do you work with?
- seattle_spring 7y agoWant to share some statistics on what percentage "older women" have CS degrees versus how many have them overall?
- hash872 7y agoWas completely with you until the last paragraph. As the poster above me says, the more you regulate hiring, the more reluctant companies are to do so. You can look at the entire continent of Europe for a 500 million person example of this- sclerotic uber-regulated hiring markets with intense bureaucratic rules around who can be hired or fired, who can be laid off, under what circumstances, etc. The end result of this regulation is dramatically higher unemployment rates and companies that are terrified to hire FTEs because it's so hard to get rid of a bad one. Hiring needs to be less regulated, not more so
- aiisjustanif 7y agoUnemployment rates: Ireland: 5.4% UK: 3.8% Germany: 3.1% Portugal: 6.3% Poland: 3.5% Czech: 1.9% Sweden: 6.2% Finland: 6.7% That about ~230mil people. Mate what are you talking about.
- repolfx 7y agoWorker protection isn't standardised. The countries with the lowest unemployment rates have relatively dynamic labour markets. Try France: 8.7%, was 10% as recently as 2015. Italy: 10.2% Of course, unemployment is much worse for young workers in these countries. If you can't fire anyone then hiring is risky, so jobs tend to end up taken by older workers who then "camp" in the jobs even if they suck. Reverse ageism at work!
- fjsolwmv 7y agoIt would be even more efficient if people stopped being racist/agist/sexist and hired based on merit and potential. Until then, we have laws.
- arcturus17 7y agoTend to agree with deregulating hiring but some economies with heavily regulated employment like Germany (I’ve lived there, it is a nightmare to fire grossly incompetent employees) have very low unemployment rates.
- 7y ago