4 ms·
Also NAL, but my understanding is that if no "consideration" (something of value) changes hands, the contract is null and void. This is why people sell things
by nostrademons 7y ago
Also NAL, but my understanding is that if no "consideration" (something of value) changes hands, the contract is null and void. This is why people sell things for $1 instead of giving them away, or why executives take $1 salaries instead of working for free. Thus, if he really never received anything of value for the work, it's as if the contract never happened, and ownership of the IP remains with the person who created it.
It probably is better to explicitly stipulate this in the contract, to avoid any misunderstandings or protracted legal battles.
- cosmodisk 7y agoNot necessarily the case- contract law is much more complex than this.
- TuringNYC 7y agoHow does this prevent a tricky client from paying a nominal $1 (far below whatever was promised) and again throwing the ownership in limbo?
- zdragnar 7y agoI imagine you then go to small claims court for breech of contract. Since the client made an effort to pay, but failed to pay the agreed amount, any judge will side with you. Depending on how payment in the contract was stipulated, you could also refuse partial payments. If it did go to court, I don't think a judge would find that an offer of $1 counts as a good faith effort on behalf of your client.
- perennate 7y agoIn the case that parent comment is alluding to, the contract would promise $1.
- jamessb 7y agoI would check with a lawyer in your jurisdiction before assuming that non-payment voids the contract. See, for example, the judgement in this UK case: > Finally, although the First Assignment records both that Mr Dichand and Dr Spaziante were to receive one US dollar as consideration for the assignment of the PCT Applications and further records that they both acknowledged receipt of the dollar, it was never paid by HTI. Mr Edenborough argued that as a consequence the contract was void for lack of consideration. I think the consequence is that Mr Dichand and Dr Spaziante may or may not have a claim against HTI for an outstanding debt of 50 cents each. http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/IPEC/2018/1142.html http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/IPEC/2018/1142.html
- stordoff 7y agoSlightly pedantically - England and Wales. Scots law doesn't require consideration. I'd certainly check with a lawyer though - it's been a long time since I studied it ( English law), but my understanding is that not paying is a breach of contract, and it doesn't necessarily make it void for lack of consideration.
- jiveturkey 7y agoMy NAL understanding is it doesn't matter if payment actually took place (otherwise how to enforce any normal sale transaction?), it's just whether an agreement that included consideration was in place. ie, the fact that the contract included consideration makes the contract valid. however if one side is in breach i think it's fair for the other side to go ahead and breach their responsibility also. in a case like this, anyway.