2 ms·
> we can record all of your internet activities including messages, banking information What the app was capable of collecting is different from what the app a
by lern_too_spel 7y ago
> we can record all of your internet activities including messages, banking information
What the app was capable of collecting is different from what the app actually collected, which was clearly specified when signing up. The app is still available in the Play Store, and people still use it because nobody was surprised by what it collects. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.android.apps.userpanel https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.and...
> Were they upfront with Apple about their use of the enterprise certificate?
Who cares? There's nothing evil about circumventing some arbitrary Apple policy to give users an app that they want.
> Yes Apple stored data on Chinese servers, but your private keys never leave your device.
Not your private keys but Apple's private keys, which gives the Chinese government unfettered access to everything Chinese users store in iCloud https://techcrunch.com/2018/07/17/apples-icloud-user-data-in-china-is-now-handled-by-a-state-owned-mobile-operator/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/07/17/apples-icloud-user-data-in.... Worse, the change was applied retroactively to data the users had stored in iCloud prior to the change. No other US tech company comes close in evilness.
- scarface74 7y agoWhat the app was capable of collecting is different from what the app actually collected, Yes they pinky promised not to collect all of your data. So will you email me your social security number if I promise not to use it? Who cares? There's nothing evil about circumventing some arbitrary Apple policy to give users an app that they want. Yes there is nothing wrong with breaching a contract.... Not your private keys but Apple's private keys, which gives the Chinese government unfettered access to everything Chinese users store in iCloud https://techcrunch.com/2018/07/17/apples-icloud-user-data-in... https://techcrunch.com/2018/07/17/apples-icloud-user-data-in.... Worse, the change was applied retroactively to data the users had stored in iCloud prior to the change. No other US tech company comes close in evilness. That’s not how public/private key pairs work and the article said no such thing. The app is still available in the Play Store, and people still use it because nobody was surprised by what it collects. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.and.. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.and.... So you’re absolutely sure that every single person who downloaded the app was aware of what it was able to collect and that everyone who downloads it was legally of age able to consent to data gathering?
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> Yes they pinky promised not to collect all of your data. So will you email me your social security number if I promise not to use it? That's dense. If you use Apple email, they also collect your social security number if someone sends it to you, and they (and the Chinese government for Chinese users) have the ability to reset your password and gain access to any service is sign up for, despite pinky promises otherwise, and Apple's software has permission to read absolutely everything you do on your phone. In just the same way, what they have the ability to do exceeds what they tell their customers they do. What the app actually collected was specified, and there remains no evidence that they did anything more than they told the panelists. > Yes there is nothing wrong with breaching a contract.... There is certainly nothing evil about giving users what they want in spite of the whims of a capricious (and actually evil) middleman. > That’s not how public/private key pairs work and the article said no such thing. Apple encrypted user's iCloud emails and iCloud data in a way that Apple still has access to for search. It is Apple's keys that matter in this case, not the user's keys for communicating with Apple. The article said exactly such thing: "Before a switch announced in January, all encryption keys for Chinese users were stored in the U.S., which meant authorities needed to go through the U.S. legal system to request access to information. Now the situation is based on Chinese courts and a gatekeeper that’s owned by the government [emphasis added]."
- scarface74 7y agoThere is certainly nothing evil about giving users what they want in spite of the whims of a capricious (and actually evil) middleman. So users want to install software that can intercept all of their communications? I’ve never heard someone say, “I would give up all of my privacy and install a network sniffer/key logger on my device of someone paid me* Apple encrypted user's iCloud emails and iCloud data in a way that Apple still has access to for search. It is Apple's keys that matter in this case, not the user's keys for communicating with Apple. That’s also not how email works. Email is not a secure communications and is never encrypted. Besides that, you don’t need to use an Apple provided email account. The article said exactly such thing: "Before a switch announced in January, all encryption keys for Chinese users were stored in the U.S., which meant authorities needed to go through the U.S. legal system to request access to information. Now the situation is based on Chinese courts and a gatekeeper that’s owned by the government [emphasis added]." That’s not how public/private key encryption works - despite what you read from techcrunch. The whole purpose of a public private key pair is that you (or your device) creates the key pair, you send the public key out for anyone to use. They then use the public key to encrypt a message and you keep your private key. Anyone can encrypt a message and only you can decrypt a message with your private key. Am I really explaining how public/private key encryption works on Hacker News?