5 ms·
Without rankings how do you determine how to allocate scarce university spots. I think there’s much more potential for bias when every position is just based o
by prepend 7y ago
Without rankings how do you determine how to allocate scarce university spots.
I think there’s much more potential for bias when every position is just based on some committee’s prerogative in a way that is very difficult, if not impossible to measure.
- em-bee 7y agoin germany universities do it by ranking the grades of the incoming students. so i have no clue what rank i have in my class, but i do know that my grade was not high enough to get into physics because there were enough students from all over the country applying with better grades. this grade would be different every year because it depended on the grades of the students that actually applied. so while in highschool i was not able to compare myself to my peers nor was i able to evaluate my changes of getting into university. (other than obviously noting that the lower my grades, the lower my chances) as it happened, the year before the cut-off was on a lower grade that suggested that i'd make it in if it stays the same the next year, but when i applied, more students with higher grades applied too, and my grades ended up being not good enough.
- dmos62 7y agoAnonymous university exams should work.
- feanaro 7y agoThis. I have long argued that schools should optimize teaching and learning, not double in being certification authorities. The current scheme just devolves into a lot of stress for the students and selection according to school "prestige" because grades between schools are not comparable. It is also extremely stressful for students which is not optimal for the learning process. Learning should be about wanting to acquire knowledge, not being forced into it like tuna in a tuna can factory.
- em-bee 7y agowell, the general expectation is that people receive a certification of some kind at the end of their study. i mean over here i have seen "graduation from kindergarten" being treated with a ceremony that makes you think you had just received a university diploma. rather ridiculous if you ask me. but what is the alternative? every university employing their own tests would mean that students now have to prepare for multiple tests based on where they apply. a job interview system? lot's of bias and unfairness in that too. in germany school prestige is irrelevant for the university selection process, only the raw grades matter. so actually your best chance to get good grades would be to pick a school that has a tendency to give students better grades. however if those statistics are not known, as they won't be now in singapore (and i don't know if they are in germany) then your school choice is either random (with respect to learning outcome) or based on perceived reputation of being a "hard" or "easy" school. there are a number of other statistics that probably need to be suppressed too, such as the number of students that get into university from each school.
- feanaro 7y ago> but what is the alternative? every university employing their own tests would mean that students now have to prepare for multiple tests based on where they apply. Not necessarily. In many EU countries that I am familiar with, there is a standardised, country-wide test which all universities use as their main admission method and which is managed by an entity independent of high schools. Note that this is different from continuous testing throughout the duration of the program. Still, some universities administer their own admission tests in addition because you can't force the university to use only a single scoring method (well, you can't, but it's not necessarily a good idea). Even so, each university solely administering their own admission tests is how it used to work in the past and it worked rather well, despite being a bit more cumbersome. In the end, if you had real knowledge, it didn't matter that you had to take a few different tests. > a job interview system? lot's of bias and unfairness in that too. This does not matter. It just means each business is responsible for its own hires and the only one suffering from a bad hiring process is the business itself. If certain employee qualities lead to an objectively better work performance (and there are surely such qualities), the process will very quickly correct itself to detect those qualities. It's hard to tell without more context, but it sounds to me like you're conflating criteria based on grades (which are continuously accumulated throughout your schooling years) and admission/certification tests which are only administered once, at the moment you are trying to attain some certificate. My position is that the former is a bad thing, but the latter is necessary and closer to testing the thing that matters: your final abilities.
- cup 7y agoWhy are University spots scarce in the first place.
- CleverLime 7y agoNot everyone should go to University. It makes it's value smaller
- bubblewrap 7y agoIf the value becomes smaller, wouldn't it automatically result in fewer people going to university?
- em-bee 7y agoit's like gold. the more people have gold, the less valuable the gold is, because it's no longer scarce. i don't agree that more university students devalue universities however. on the contrary, more university level education is in my opinion the best response to less jobs and automation. we need ever greater and greater parts of our society in higher education to study, research and teach, because all the low level jobs will eventually be automated away. but imagine what our society can do if we are all educated to the level of a college professor. with more educated people we can address issues such as pollution and climate-change much more easily, and this can only speed up the advancement of our society.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- AndrewDavis 7y agoThat sounds logical but it doesn't typically work like that. Instead you need to then do even more than get a bachelors degree. Also known as education inflation.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- JCharante 7y ago
- forinti 7y agoLet everyone attend the basic courses. Those that make it through Calculus can then proceed.
- mnazim 7y agoThat's a completely different thing. Purpose of school education is to nurture a human child into a member of society, who understands her rights and duties; posses the knowledge and tools to exercise her rights, and discharge her duties. University has nothing to do with this.
- prepend 7y agoThese aren’t exclusive. I agree with the your defined purpose with school. But my question stands about how a university of fellowship should distinguish students who did better than others. I think there’s usefulness to some sort of statistically standardized test that is a good mix in to the many other factors that should be used- essays, activities, awards, interviews, referrals. I think it’s bad when a test is given too much weight, but if we don’t have any standards with the goal of being objective then I fear only attractive people will get into the best colleges.
- brighter2morrow 7y agoYou joke but this is actually a growing sentiment. Schools across the USA are eliminating more and more liberal arts requirements as universities become more like glorified "coding bootcamps".
- robbiep 7y agoMany European countries and others solve this by allowing entry to most people but then there are high dropout rates as you move through it. Not as efficient but also creates more opportunity
- em-bee 7y agocan you cite some references for that please? this is certainly not happening in germany or austria, and i am not aware of any other countries doing that either. searching on the topic, all i find is articles that consider drop-out rates a serious problem, and statictics like this one: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/Europe_2020_indicators_-_education https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php... that shows that rates dropped from 17% to 12% over 15 years. based on that i highly doubt that any place is using dropout rates as an intentional strategy.
- pimmen 7y agoYou can use anaonymous exams or maybe have them solve a project. If you do that, people who are qualified get in and not people who were good students as children.
- lozenge 7y agoPart of the issue is the test design. If the university takes the top 1% of performers, then it could mean you need 99% correct answers. But students scoring 97% or 99% correct on a test already know all the material. The difference is in luck and accuracy, not intelligence. The solution is to write a harder test that is only meant for the top 10% of students to take and actually contains harder questions.