5 ms·
This might sound cheeky, but it's a serious question: Where do you get this idea from? There seems to be a lot of people who are strongly pro-nuclear primarily
by ZeroGravitas 7y ago
This might sound cheeky, but it's a serious question: Where do you get this idea from?
There seems to be a lot of people who are strongly pro-nuclear primarily because they're pessimistic about renewables.
Whereas from my perspective, renewable tech is doing well enough that I consider climate change to be purely a political problem now.
Unfortunately that same politics has generated an absurd amount of informational chaff. There's multiple layers: climate change is a hoax, it's just cycles, it's actually beneficial, it won't be that bad, solar is a net waste of energy, you can't run a grid on more than 30% renewable and so on and so on.
It seems to me that the people that are enthusiastic about nuclear are coming from that same information bubble, possibly via American libertarianism, where they've been exposed to anti-renewable propaganda for years. They probably have internalized lots of misconceptions as a result. It's just that being vocally pro nuclear is a bit more of a rational and socially acceptable position to take than most of the other propaganda so as long as they stick to that it's hard to tell.
However, it's still wrong. I don't consider myself anti-nuclear, but it's just not the most cost effective way to generate low carbon energy. And that rollout of cheaper options would happen slightly faster if people like yourself (and Bill Gates) stopped acting like it was some impossible pipe dream and that we need to wait for nuclear to save us.
- YjSe2GMQ 7y agoRenewables are great, but not deployed nearly quick enough: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_energy_consumption https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_energy_consumption Not an expert, but right now I only believe in solar geo-engineering. And, of course, never buying a waterfront property, since at this point we'll almost certainly go above 2*C. PS. It's fascinating to see Miami real estate prices completely ignoring the incoming doom: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MIXRNSA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MIXRNSA
- cheerlessbog 7y agoHydro is mostly built out. Scalable storage isn't proven. How does renewable replace base load?
- jacobush 7y agoThis seems an unpopular opinion, but maybe we don't need more base load. Maybe we need more on availability load. With all the magic of connected devices, they could cope with varying electricity?
- cheerlessbog 7y agoHearing, maybe refrigeration, in future electric car charging. Beyond that doesn't most load require consistent power?
- jacobush 7y agoHeating + cooling must be the largest consumers. And these are great candidates for "layered" service.
- Mvandenbergh 7y agoOf US Commercial electricity use about 40% is refrigeration, cooling, heating, and ventilation which can all time shifted at least intra-day with good building practices. 10% is lighting which realistically can't - you need lights when it's dark. 15% is computers which can sort of load shift because most office computers are now laptops - with good communications systems you can tell laptops how aggressively to charge / whether to run off battery. The rest is "other" quite a lot of which is small electronic devices like tablets and phones charging and then a grab-bag of misc. stuff. Half of residential electricity is some kind of temperature shifting (heating, cooling, refrigeration, freezers, ventilation). Essentially with good insulation you can get to a point where you can load shift 50%+ of your electricity consumption on an intra-day basis. Electric car charging of course is a perfect load to match to renewables as well. That doesn't solve the issue of inter-day fluctuations - what happens when you have a cloudy, high pressure system sitting over a substantial part of your generation for a week - but it does mean that we can go pretty far. We may have to keep more open-cycle gas around for those times which will have to be funded on a capacity basis.
- 7y ago
- peteradio 7y agoWhy throw all the eggs into one basket? There is plenty of work to be done rolling out both and plenty of people to do the work.