9 ms·
I don't like that it's required for developers to include if they include any other third-party sign-in. US competition laws are outdated with undue reliance o
by crazygringo 7y ago
I don't like that it's required for developers to include if they include any other third-party sign-in.
US competition laws are outdated with undue reliance on the concept of a monopoly.
I don't care if you're a monopoly or a third of the market or even a small company. If you run a marketplace or app store or similar platform, you should NOT be able to:
- Force usage of a separate product of yours over/with competitors (in this case, Apple sign-in, but also Apple Pay instead of Google Pay, etc.)
- Prevent competing products from appearing (whether Apple not allowing other browser rendering engines, Amazon not allowing Google Home or Chromecast to be sold, etc.)
- Rank your own items higher in search results etc. if competitors can't bid to do the same e.g. sponsored results for everyone including yourself (so Amazon Basics or Google Shopping needs to be listed as a sponsored result, not as a separate feature)
This is the kind of thing 21st-century legislation for fair competition should address.
- marcell 7y agoCompletely agree. There needs to be some concept of a marketplace that doesn't have monopoly power, and a list of "fair play" rules around those. The only difference between Apple's actions and 90's Microsoft is marketshare. It's a similarly anti-competitive in intent.
- miohtama 7y agoEuropean Union has some regulation for financial markets that have had similar issues in the past. The regulators must approve a rule book for market place, in this case of trading venue, which including onboarding and listing rules. Those rules must not discriminate against anyone - one cannot do arbitrary decisions to block or hinder someone. Everybody must access the markets fairly. We already seen the regulatory outreach coming to app stores when EU ruled that Google was hindering the distribution of Aptoide store for Android.
- kalleboo 7y ago> There needs to be some concept of a marketplace that doesn't have monopoly power The Web? I've seen reports that Apple is finally starting to fix issued related to adding PWAs to the home screen as well.
- lucasverra 7y agocan you share the source please ?
- jlian 7y agoI’m not sure if this is right approach. In fact in the 70’s, the US basically went through this back and forth, largely influenced by one book: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Antitrust_Paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Antitrust_Paradox Essentially, the book advocates that the only goal antitrust laws should have is to protect consumer welfare, not competitors. IMO, Apple’s requirement doesn’t feel like it would harm consumer welfare.
- sooheon 7y agoA well run company could build an arbitrarily large technological and financial moat on the back of consumer welfare, until it amasses enough power to completely subjugate regulatory bodies. (This is all theoretical, I don't think Apple is at that point). OTOH, anticompetitiveness is an easier thing to detect and act upon before it gets out of control.
- eastWestMath 7y agoIt seems like an absolute win for consumer welfare, to be honest.
- jeroenhd 7y agoWelp, there we go. I was surprised to see Apple introduce a feature that improved things for their customers without some ridiculous restriction and here we are: mandatory inclusion for app developers. Good job Apple, you raised your image only to crush it again with anticompetitive bullshit.
- toomuchequate 7y agoThis isnt a monopoly. As someone who has never bought an Apple product, I can safely say their monopolistic practices don't affect me. Stop buying Apple products. Its that simple.
- gman83 7y agoI don't buy Apple products (well not exactly true I have a MacBook but only because I'm forced to use that to build for iOS). But for my app which uses 1st party login or Facebook as an alternative I am now forced to provide Apple login. If Google follows suite I'll be forced to provide Google login on Android, etc. Probably I'll just end up removing all third party login too much of a hassle, although I'll definitely lose users.
- toomuchequate 7y agoThis is my biggest fear btw, I am making an App, and I realize I am getting close to needing to buy an Apple product to hit compile (Javascript) and fix bugs. The only thing you can do is educate consumers on the evils of Apple and hope they make better decisions in the future.
- zepto 7y agoWhat better decision can they make?
- ddh1118wanted 7y agoBuy a competing product; that will help to erode the Apple monopoly. That's similar to what happened to Windows Phone. They opened up development towards the end since they could no longer justify forcing developers to behave the way they wanted; they simply didn't have the market share to enforce it.
- jackjeff 7y agoShocker. I heard you are also forced to buy a Windows PC to write software for Windows!
- DavideNL 7y ago> I don't like that it's required for developers to include if they include any other third-party sign-in. Curious, why not? Because if i understand correctly it's designed so that Apple cannot see any of the data... So for what reason would you want to provide another third-party provider, but not Apple Signin? To me it seems a huge win for consumers privacy wise, and Developers have nothing to loose.
- clarky07 7y agodevelopers definitely have something to lose. If nothing else, it takes time to implement a new process that you already have working. not a win for privacy, but i'm sure there are some that would be unhappy about not getting the data the other providers are giving them.
- jakobegger 7y agoAn important distinction is that Apple is not forcing consumers to use Apple Sign In. They are only requiring developers to offer it as an option.