5 ms·
”it's just that if you sell their data (or get hacked) the email you get is useless.” It’s just that whenever Apple decides so, the email you got becomes usele
by Someone 7y ago
”it's just that if you sell their data (or get hacked) the email you get is useless.”
It’s just that whenever Apple decides so, the email you got becomes useless.
Apple is judge, jury and executioner, and it makes the laws. That is problematic.
- jen729w 7y agoI think the question is, is it more problematic than the current situation, whereby users wholly distrust companies with their data, because those companies have shown again and again that they can not be trusted with it? I’d say no.
- Someone 7y agoThat’s one possible question. Another is whether an even better remedy exists. For example, do we need the ability for Apple to delete the link between a company and all their users in one sweep, or is it sufficient to make it easy for individual users to cut such ties? If the latter, could we remove that giant master switch, or move control of it to a third party? (I haven’t watched the video, so, possibly, that giant switch doesn’t exist. Skimming https://developer.apple.com/sign-in-with-apple/get-started/ https://developer.apple.com/sign-in-with-apple/get-started/ didn’t tell me that, either)
- gpickett00 7y agoIf a better remedy exists someone else can build it. Nobody is forcing us to use Apple products/services.
- cyphar 7y ago> That’s one possible question. Another is whether an even better remedy exists. There is, it's called IM2000 where email becomes a pull-based system instead of push-based (so users would have to consent to spam, and spammers have to store their spam to send it in bulk). Unfortunately, despite many attempts to switch over we're still stuck on the current incarnation of SMTP.
- azinman2 7y agoLooking it up, it removes so many advantages of email, such as I don’t lose old mail when your now defunct IM2000 ISP goes out of business. There also isn’t an easy transition from now — I can see exactly why we’re “stuck” with what’s actually a pretty great last bastion of decentralization on the Internet, for all its warts.
- cyphar 7y agoYou could always use IMAP to sync your email as normal. The advantage of IM2000 is that it just changes the server-to-server protocol (with some changes for how clients send emails). But yes, the transition would require replacing SMTP so once again we're stuck on a system that is terrible enough to grumble about but not terrible enough to change. (I would also argue that Matrix is becoming a new decentralised system for the internet, as well as ActivityPub depending on who you ask.)
- SquishyPanda23 7y agoThat sounds like a great feature. I would love for the ability to make an email address inactive after I sign up. The percent of times I want to recieve email communication from something I have to sign up for is very close to 0.
- Nerdfest 7y agoGet your own domain through someone that has an email service that supports aliases. Every sign up can have a different address. It's like $10 per year and you're email is not at the mercy of whatever mega-corporation owns your email.
- buzzerbetrayed 7y agoAny suggestions on which provider to use?
- jsjohnst 7y agoGoogle Apps works great for this. You can also setup a catch-all account and not need to pre-configure the aliases in advance.
- lorenzhs 7y agoI use FastMail like this. They support both catch-all (comapny@domain.com) and user-specific forwards (company@user.domain.com -> user+company@domain.com) for domains with multiple users.
- wtmt 7y agoIMO, it depends on how many mailboxes and aliases you need. Providers like Fastmail charge by the mailbox (with up to 600 aliases for each). Same with Runbox, Mailbox.org, etc. (the number of aliases varies). Migadu provides unlimited domains, mailboxes and aliases for a fixed price that decides how many outgoing mails you can send everyday from all mailboxes in that account.
- Nerdfest 7y ago
- mikeash 7y agoOnly if the customer wants them to be. If the customer wants to give you their real email address, they are free to do so. If they choose not to give that to you, but you want to contact them anyway because you think you know their desires better than they do, well... that’s exactly why this is needed.
- makomk 7y agoIf Apple decides to cut off a developer, it doesn't matter what their customers want. Unless they had the foresight to bypass the default and use their real e-mail, there is no way for users to prove their accounts belong to them without Apple's co-operation. Their access to their accounts is entirely at Apple's mercy and there is (by design) nothing the developers can do to avoid this.
- scarface74 7y agoThe authentication using OATH and the email forwarding of aliases are two separate but related services. If Apple for some reason doesn’t allow the app maker to use the OATH service, I doubt very seriously that they will cancel the email forwarding without the user specifically turning off the forwarding. At that point both the user and the app provider both have generated email address.
- Wintereise 7y ago> I doubt very seriously that they will cancel the email forwarding without the user specifically turning off the forwarding. Where's this confidence coming from? If Apple sees it fit to prevent you (the developer) from accessing your Apple specific userbase for any reason / violation, other people seem correct in their theorization that there's nothing you can really do as the developer. Not implementing this new "Sign in with Apple" will also probably be interpreted as not being privacy friendly by the users, a developer can't really have that either. Pretty much the definition of being stuck between a rock and a hard place.
- 7y ago
- codesternews 7y agoEvery big company has their own laws. G,F are abusing and Apple is providing the solution and I think it is far better than what we have.