5 ms·
Steel can make sparks. I'm not sure it can be done on concrete, but the spike may have had some rebar in the middle that would be hard enough to chip off fragm
by jandrese 7y ago
Steel can make sparks. I'm not sure it can be done on concrete, but the spike may have had some rebar in the middle that would be hard enough to chip off fragments of steel. A hot spark could then smoulder in the grass for some time (like if the guy then decided to go for a smoke break to let the Yellowjackets calm down) and be out of hand by the time he got back.
The story does kind of seem a bit farfetched as it goes on with the lengthy string of failures on his part. There is a nonzero chance the guy didn't want to cop to burning trash in his overgrown and tinder dry back yard and made up the crazy story. There's probably no way to prove it either way.
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoYou can definitely make sparks from metal-on-rock contact, FWIW. Concrete contains gravel for filler material etc.
- twothamendment 7y agoFor sure. I see it when I work in my yard late into the summer. As it gets dark I've made sparks with shovels, picks and quite often the teeth on the excavator bucket will scrape a rock and make some pretty good sparks.
- jdavis703 7y ago> There's probably no way to prove it either way. Fire investigators can trace back the origin of fires. I know in some cases they can trace it back to a specific outlet in a home. Would the investigators not be able to see the point of origin has a 24 inch concrete stake driven in to the ground? Would they not be able to see there was an overturned 4-wheeler? This story sounds so unbelievable that I’d expect trained investigators to be able to find the obvious holes (I swear, no pun was intended).
- ryacko 7y agoA lot of criminal cases were thrown out because the forensic science was proven to be incorrect. http://www.abajournal.com/magazine/article/long_held_beliefs_about_arson_science_have_been_debunked_after_decades_of_m http://www.abajournal.com/magazine/article/long_held_beliefs...
- bsder 7y ago> I know in some cases they can trace it back to a specific outlet in a home. It's not even hard. When I had a fire in my apartment while I was away, the inspector simply was actually really nice when we went through an explained everything in the aftermath: "See that "V" on the wall, that tells me the fire started here at this outlet. Note that the books you had on this shelf are charred, but not fully burned. Books are pretty lousy in terms of going up in flames. Note the books on this side, they're totally burned. Accelerant--you probably kept oil in the cupboard above them. You clearly had something heavy in this cabinet, cast iron? ..." And he just went on and on as he walked through. If you ever want to try to commit insurance fraud by setting a fire .. don't. The inspector will know--he may not be able to prove it, but he will know.
- onetimemanytime 7y ago>>If you ever want to try to commit insurance fraud by setting a fire .. don't. The inspector will know--he may not be able to prove it, but he will know. Morals aside, people will do and quite a few will get away with it. Average Joe should not, but for every fire inspector there's a smart crook.
- bitbckt 7y agoA concrete stake is not _made_ of concrete. It is made of steel.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 7y agoIndeed. They are steel stakes used to set forms to pour concrete. They look like this: https://d323w7klwy72q3.cloudfront.net/i/a/2012/20120125midwest/B6103.JPG https://d323w7klwy72q3.cloudfront.net/i/a/2012/20120125midwe...
- jdietrich 7y agoSparks are a major hazard in a lot of industries, to the extent that there is a full range of non-sparking tools made from high-strength copper alloys. They're most often used in the oil, gas and petrochemicals industries, but they're also used in dry and dusty environments like grain elevators and flour mills. https://www.avensafetytools.com/product-category/non-sparking-tools/ https://www.avensafetytools.com/product-category/non-sparkin... I have no idea whether this story is the whole truth, but it's perfectly plausible - in extremely dry conditions, a tiny ember can become an uncontrollable fire in a matter of seconds. The speed of a grass fire can be truly frightening. Take a look at this video: https://youtu.be/F79tkSKstxY?t=10 https://youtu.be/F79tkSKstxY?t=10 The fire in that video was started by the heat of an exhaust pipe, but it could have just as easily been caused by a spark or a cigarette butt. If a fire like this started in front of you, how sure are you that you'd be able to extinguish it single-handedly? What if it started behind you and it got a head start of a few seconds before you noticed it? If you were dressed in shorts and sandals rather than fire-resistant boots and overalls, would you even stand a chance? A moment of hesitation or distraction is all it takes to lose control of a grass fire. Based on the account given, I can fully imagine the desperate and ultimately futile effort made to extinguish a fire that rapidly spread out of control.
- korethr 7y agoThe video in your second link shows just how hard those grass fires can be to contain. There's what, a half-dozen to dozen riders present? And despite their effort, it continues to spread throughout the video.
- jdietrich 7y agoMost people severely underestimate the speed of fire and overestimate the speed at which they can respond. Even if a fire looks tiny, you have a very narrow window of opportunity to react before the fire spreads beyond your ability to control. The same applies to fire in the home - if you can't put it out right now with whatever comes to hand, you've probably lost your window of opportunity to fight the fire. If your sofa or curtains catch fire, there simply isn't time to fill a bucket or fetch a hose. If you don't have an extinguisher to hand and can't snuff out the flames with a blanket, you need to run. https://youtu.be/w4W82HIzUcc?t=78 https://youtu.be/w4W82HIzUcc?t=78
- korethr 7y agoIt can be done on concrete. I've split logs for firewood on concrete before. Sometimes the wood is more cooperative than anticipated, and so the the axe goes right on through the log like it's not there, and kisses the concrete. There's sometimes a spark or two when it happens.
- serf 7y agothere are plenty of ferrous iron/steel concretes. I use them for pads for my heavy equipment because it doesn't move much after the initial setting.
- tomrod 7y agoIt can be done on concrete if rocks are mixed in, not uncommon.
- lostlogin 7y agoSteel tools on concrete can definitely make sparks. I assume it requires the aggregate in the concrete to be hard or the concrete to be very old and therefore hard. I’ve noticed this when breaking up concrete at night, a horrible chore.