3 ms·
All true, but there are many downsides to the adversarial approach so we should consider exploring other types. The most obvious downside is an adversarial syst
by anigbrowl 7y ago
All true, but there are many downsides to the adversarial approach so we should consider exploring other types. The most obvious downside is an adversarial system police and the state will default to intimidation because that's the most effective tactic on most people. This manifests most perniciously in the case of plea bargains. Economic analysis of criminal justice has led to an approach of deliberately threatening people with wildly disproportionate sentences because it's a powerful incentive to plead guilty to lesser crimes and keep the costs of running a prosecutor's office down. It also promotes an unhealthy zero-sum approach to justice where in order for me to win you must lose. We're seeing now how things work out when that attitude shapes the cognition of national leaders.
Most people think they can make a better adversarial system by tweaking this or that rule, but the unwanted outcomes are baked into the adversarial approach. What works between individual humans (more or less) doesn't translate well to conflicts between individual humans and collective entities which constitute facets of the state, bth because of the yawning asymmetries involved and because the state is necessarily and unavoidably schizoid due to the distributed nature of its consciousness and that of those who comprise its cellular elements.