3 ms·
IMO, the problem with GitHub is the community. For some reason the Ruby community rubs me the wrong way, in a way that the Java, Python, Lisp communities don't.
by kenjackson 16y ago
IMO, the problem with GitHub is the community. For some reason the Ruby community rubs me the wrong way, in a way that the Java, Python, Lisp communities don't.
While I can respect Ruby and RoR technically, it's not so far above other products that it can make up for the fact that I'd prefer not to interact with the community on a day to day basis.
Maybe I've just hit a weird sample, but I've heard other people outside of my circle make similar comments, yet I've rarely, if ever, heard it said about other communities (except maybe the Slashdot community).
- daleharvey 16y agoI believe javascript is the most popular language on github, either way I really dont see github as a "ruby / rails community"
- kenjackson 16y agoI don't have the data in front of me, but if JS is #1, Ruby can't be far behind. And while I completely believe you, it still feels to me more like a Ruby/Rails community than it does a JS community.
- thwarted 16y agoThat's because it's not a community based on language use, it's a community based on code sharing via a specific source control engine + community/social features + project management features. github has to be one of the few services/companies that use ruby that doesn't constantly push it in your face with a bunch of better-than-thou blog posts about how ruby is awesome. Twitter used to be like that (or at least felt like it) with ruby/rails and then eventually with whatever language or technology du jour they were using. None of my github projects are ruby, and I don't think many of the projects I follow are ruby (I honestly don't really keep track of that, but it would be an interesting statistic). While I know github uses ruby, I don't think of them as doing anything other than providing the github service/website. In the same way I don't really think of Facebook as anything other than providing the facebook service/website. It only comes up when we talk about hiring ("If you want to work at Facebook, you'd have to do PHP.") or when you get a fatal error (I actually got "Fatal error: Uncaught OAuthException: An active access token must be used to query information about the current user. thrown in /var/www/publisher/system/application/libraries/facebook.php on line 453" the other day -- that's only happened once for me). I'd like to think that some places concentrating on providing a good service/experience and the actual choice of implementation only matters to them and they'd use the best tools for the job (where "best" may be defined as amount of experience they have with it). Consider the perception of the language agnostic nature of github vs codeplex. I don't spend a lot of time on codeplex, but I have this perception that just about everything hosted on codeplex is written in one of the limited subset of languages that Microsoft sanctions/supports (this may be a function of the Microsoft/Windows platform, where it's non-trivial to get things like, say, vanilla ruby or python running on Windows compared to .Net stuff). Code that is hosted on github is merely known to use git for source control.
- clyfe 16y agohttps://github.com/languages https://github.com/languages
- gte910h 16y ago>MO, the problem with GitHub is the community. For some reason the Ruby community rubs me the wrong way While I get that same feel from the rubbings from some ruby folk, (I'm a C/python/Objective C guy mainly), I don't honestly feel their rubbings in relation to github at all. I mean, it's source control, what does it have to do with the language you put into it? Are you rejecting git too because rubyiests happen to use grabbed onto Linus Torvald's version of Hg?
- kenjackson 16y agoWhile I get that same feel from the rubbings from some ruby folk, (I'm a C/python/Objective C guy mainly), I don't honestly feel their rubbings in relation to github at all. I mean, it's source control, what does it have to do with the language you put into it? As the author of the original blog entry stated, feature-wise Git is similar to many other source control systems, "The issue wasn't the technology. Mercurial and Git are pretty much at feature parity (as is Bazaar)." He goes on to say that the differentiator is the community. If the source control system isn't technologically superior to other competing technologies, and the community is the differentiating factor, but the community is one that I'm not extremely enamored with, wouldn't I be wise to stay away? Maybe what you're saying is that in fact the community is not that important with repect to GitHub. It's a web front end for source control and it's really good, period. In that case, maybe it's worth another look. Although again, pretty much the only people I hear talking about GitHub are Ruby folks, and most of what they talk about is how GitHub is great because of the Ruby community.
- gte910h 16y agoI didn't even catch that in the original article which I did read. Your comment makes much more sense. Having used Hg and git, I do not feel they're equivalent. I feel Hg is quite a bit more friendly to new folks, however git is considerably more powerful feeling to moderately good folks. I'm honestly a little sad python people are so enamored with Hg :o( Honestly, the "Your repo can be marked public or private" thing gives me the willies. I prefer offerings which don't support public status, so you never accidentally dump your codebase onto the internet. But if you are doing something open source, it fantastic.