4 ms·
> "anti-abortion" over "pro-life" Seems fair. > and “pro-choice” over “pro-abortion” ok... what
by exabrial 7y ago
> "anti-abortion" over "pro-life"
Seems fair.
> and “pro-choice” over “pro-abortion”
ok... what
- taborj 7y agoAnd here they said they were doing this to avoid political obfuscation. I sense they're being a bit disingenuous.
- plotteddancer16 7y agoYes, it’s very disingenuous
- gtf21 7y agoNot really. "Pro-life" isn't a very accurate statement as the definition of "life" is not agreed. "Pro-choice" is accurate, as it denotes a position which is in favour of giving women the choice to abort, it's not "pro-abortion" in that it is encouraging women to have an abortion.
- ufmace 7y agoEh pro-choice seems just as misleading to me. Choice could mean any choice about anything. Seems like they're trying to conflate a choice about abortion with being in favor of any ordinary choice. Both sides have their own preferred terms that try to conflate something uncontroversial with a highly disputed position. That's a common enough thing in politics for sure. It's highly biased and not as all neutral to allow one side to pick a misleading name while requiring the other side to use a more literal name.
- taborj 7y agoI think we should use "pro-abortion" and "anti-abortion". That is, after all, the relative positions of the two sides, and it tells us the specific issue at question. But the word "abortion" has negative connotations, so being "pro" abortion has negative connotations. It's a PR problem, mainly.
- Xylakant 7y agoI, personally, am against abortions. I, however, understand that it’s not my body that a baby will grow in and it’s not my circumstances that the persons considering an abortion live in. I can’t put myself in their shoes. I’m firmly pro-choice. It’s their bodies and their lifes. I’m also pro-life as in “create the circumstances that make as few people as possible face that choice.” Create circumstances where being a single parent is not the first ranking cause of being or becoming poor. Create support networks. Create a suitable safety net. Ensure proper childcare options. Make sure that mothers don’t die during childbirth from entirely preventable causes. If you want to be pro-life in a real sense of the word, care about what happens after the baby is born.
- taborj 7y agoI'm genuinely curious, so please don't take this as an attack. It sounds like (and please correct me if I'm mistaken here) that you're against abortion essentially because they don't affect you or isn't something you would choose to do. Is that accurate? I'm curious what makes you against abortion, then? Most people who are against abortion don't want anyone to have them (with certain exceptions) because it's effectively taking a life. But that's obviously not your reason, and I'm must confess I'm struggling to come up with a scenario wherein you can be against abortions, but think they're okay for other folks. That doesn't sound like against it to my ears, because you are supporting it in general (i.e. you wouldn't vote to make them illegal). And supporting abortion would make you pro-abortion. Again, not trying to attack or belittle or anything like that, I'm absolutely, genuinely curious.
- Xylakant 7y agoOk, I’ll try to explain in different words: I, personally, would not choose an abortion. But I’m male and well enough off with a sufficiently good support network by friends and family so that I’m fairly confident I could make a good living even as a single parent. We do have a 2yo kid, so I have a rough idea of how much work even a single one can be :) I wish that no abortions were necessary. It’s an ordeal. A human in the making doesn’t get to live. (I consciously avoid “killed”, I don’t consider 8 week old embryos living beings). In that sense I’m against abortions. I wish we wouldn’t need them. For the record: I’m not religious. However, other people’s circumstances differ. A woman has to actually carry the child to term. Pregnancy is a major health risk. Kids rate high as risk factor for poverty. Men tend to leave families and leave the kid behind. They might not feel ready for a kid yet. I value their bodily autonomy higher than my limited personal view on the matter. I can’t possibly enforce my choice on them. I’m pro reducing abortions. I’m against banning them. It’s their choice to make and I’ve know people go through that and I’ve never felt like it was an easy choice to them. I consider myself lucky that I was never forced to make that decision. The only way out of that dilemma is to help people not end up facing that choice (sex education, easy access to birth control, ...) and to make it easier for people to decide against abortions (health care, child support, ...) Reduce total harm inflicted. I consider anyone calling himself pro-life without first tackling those issues to be a fake. So that’s where I’m at.
- gtfratteus 7y agoPro-abortion and anti-abortion are the only fair terms for describing the sides of this dispute. It's pretty blatantly biased to allow one side to use their preferred term while assigning a less flattering term to the other side. Make no mistake, The Guardian is propaganda.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- insickness 7y agoSo they will call the pro-choice movement by the name the pro-choice movement uses and they'll call the pro-life movement by the name the pro-choice movement uses as well. Disingenious to pretend this is neutral.
- Xylakant 7y ago> Disingenious to pretend this is neutraL. Good that they don’t do that, then. And good that they’re not obliged too, either.
- mistermann 7y agoJust as readers aren't obliged to take what is printed in the newspaper as unbiased fact, or even an honest attempt at it, for obvious reasons. Luckily, I'm sure this is the only topic that has the wording massaged to influence opinions.
- Xylakant 7y agoYou’re attacking a strawman. I didn’t say readers should take anything as unbiased. I just pointed out that the guardian neither pretends to be unbiased, nor would it be obliged to be. So what’s the point you’re making?
- mistermann 7y ago> I didn’t say readers should take anything as unbiased. Nor did I say you did, speaking of strawmen. > So what’s the point you’re making? I guess that creating an implicit/casual mainstream narrative that is objectively false may contribute to second order unintended negative consequences (as in: "hmmm, if they're being untrue about <subject A>, maybe they're doing the same on <subjects B,C,D> as <authoritarian leader> claims"), and that it is doubly silly to do when you mostly have the truth on your side. It's only a theory, measuring such things is notoriously difficult, but I think it jives extremely well with human behavior on both political extremes.