5 ms·
> The fact that we want to get each other off at all is driven by evolution, This begs the question. Gay sexual desire is a counterexample to this claim. > a
by foldr 7y ago
> The fact that we want to get each other off at all is driven by evolution,
This begs the question. Gay sexual desire is a counterexample to this claim.
> a species that doesn't have an urge to get each other off goes extinct pretty quickly.
Evolutionary considerations may set boundary conditions. It doesn't follow that the sexuality that humans in fact have has an evolutionary explanation.
There's a dilemma here. If you're going to paint a picture of evolution as a ruthlessly fitness-optimizing process, then you have to take gay sexual desire seriously as a counterexample.
If, on the other hand, you accept that evolutionary theory per se only rules out extreme possibilities (e.g., a completely asexual species that reproduces sexually), then you also have to accept that the specifics of human sexuality may not have any explanation in evolutionary terms.
>Really, you think quest for knowledge is at all comparable to the 2000 years of active persecution?
The persecution of gay people continues. Non-religious bigots will often justify it on alleged evolutionary grounds ("it's not natural"), just as religious bigots will often justify it in terms of Biblical proscriptions.