2 ms·
That's your interpretation and that's the problem because you might be wrong in some subtle way that a lawyer could exploit. Also, you are looking at a single p
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
That's your interpretation and that's the problem because you might be wrong in some subtle way that a lawyer could exploit. Also, you are looking at a single paragraph, there's a lot more to this and it includes notions of linking, derivative works, distribution, etc. Lawyers really don't like having a lot of open questions around this stuff and some of the more extreme interpretations would be very disruptive for any business that wants to keep parts of their software proprietary.
The other point is that the intention of this license is explicitly to prevent people commercializing software licensed this way through proprietary extensions, additions, etc. The whole point of the license is to make that difficult/impossible. If you use AGPL software, you have to respect this intention.
Gplv3 is also not that popular with legal departments for the same reason. Even Gplv2 is generally frowned upon but better understood since there is a fair bit of case law around it and known ways of dealing with it when e.g. shipping binary kernel modules with an OS, which is one of those legally grey areas where you have to depend on legal interpretations of the license. Gplv3 was explicitly written to close some of those loopholes in Gplv2: they were unintentional.
So, this is not FUD but basically lawyers doing their jobs and they are fairly consistent in their reservations with respect to this license across the industry. You talk to lawyers in any fortune 500 company and they'll probably will be very reluctant to sign off on any AGPL dependencies.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoYou're arguing that companies should fear the license because there is uncertainty and you doubt that an unproblematic interpretation is accurate, but that that isn't FUD. It's fear, uncertainty and doubt. > The other point is that the intention of this license is explicitly to prevent people commercializing software licensed this way through proprietary extensions, additions, etc. The whole point of the license is to make that difficult/impossible. If you use AGPL software, you have to respect this intention. That may be true, but why should you care if you are not actually doing that and are only using the software without modification? > Even Gplv2 is generally frowned upon but better understood since there is a fair bit of case law around it It is pretty uncommon for there to be existing caselaw interpreting a given software license. Proprietary software licenses are commonly unique to the software, sometimes even unique to the customer. If this is a concern then shouldn't a widely used form license like the AGPL be an advantage, because then it's more likely the first time a court has to interpret the text will be in somebody else's case and not yours? > So, this is not FUD but basically lawyers doing their jobs and they are fairly consistent in their reservations with respect to this license across the industry. You talk to lawyers in any fortune 500 company and they'll probably will be very reluctant to sign off on any AGPL dependencies. Have you experienced asking lawyers for their opinions on contract text? You'll generally get back a document identifying various concerns with just about every provision in the text, because that's their job. For example, here's a fun provision from the Windows 10 license: > [you may not] use the software as server software, for commercial hosting, make the software available for simultaneous use by multiple users over a network, install the software on a server and allow users to access it remotely, or install the software on a device for use only by remote users; What does that mean? How will a court interpret it? Should corporations avoid Microsoft Windows as a result, because they might violate some interpretation of the license and then be liable for copyright infringement? Lawyers having concerns about license terms is par for the course. What you haven't established is what makes the AGPL unusual in that regard, as compared with the above or a hundred other provisions in various other licenses.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoIt's reasonable fear, not unreasonable fear if countless lawyers in countless companies seem to be coming to the same conclusions and enforcing very strict policies regarding this (fact, not imaging this). When in doubt, listen to lawyers, not engineers. FUD would be spreading unreasonable fear and uncertainty to create doubt. The thing you don't seem to get about these licenses is the generally fuzzy language about derivative works, distribution, and modifications. The legal interpretations vs. the intent of the authors vs. the technical interpration of these licenses are three things. An engineer saying, "it's fine" means absolutely nothing. These licenses are versioned for a reason: the intent and legal reality apparently don't always line up and people try to fix these things. The key point of the AGPL license is that it deliberately intends to prevent proprietary bundling/extensions of software licensed that way by demanding it is open sourced under a similar license (aka. the viral nature of the license). Gplv2 had similar intentions but contained enough ambiguity and weaker requirements that gave clever lawyers enough wiggle room to get away with e.g. creating things like Android which definitely has a lot of proprietary stuff covered in patents and other things. Hence, GPLv3 which aimed to rectify some of these ambiguities. And yes, I have experience being lectured on this by actual lawyers (with a clue no less) in the context of Nokia's OSS efforts a few years back around their linux based mobile os. They had thousands of engineers collaborating with the OSS community on hundreds of projects with all sorts of licenses. Their job: protect Nokia's IP and prevent inadvertent legal fall out with patents, copyrights, etc. due to improperly licensed software. I learned a lot talking to and listening to these people. In short their attitude was, MIT/Apache is generally fine. Gplv2, you need to know what you are doing but we know how to deal with this and mitigate potential risks. Gplv3: please avoid adding anything with this license to any Nokia product (patents were a big concern here). AGPL, no way in hell that we would approve this, ever; the risks are substantial and generally not worth it, even for server side only stuff. Regarding the MS license; lets stay on topic and not digress about the legal saviness of their lawyers. Generally my advice would be to assume they can make life hard for you and thought long and hard about how they would do that. Any court case would likely set you back more than you or your company can afford.