4 ms·
First, God is not a thing, so let's rephrase that as God is logically and metaphysically necessary. Consider a person poking a stone around with a staff. The s
by bobthechef 7y ago
First, God is not a thing, so let's rephrase that as God is logically and metaphysically necessary.
Consider a person poking a stone around with a staff. The stone moves only insofar as the staff moves it and the staff moves only insofar as the person moves the staff. Thus, the stone moves only insofar as the person moves it. Analogously, the existence of things, here and now and at any moment, must have a cause that is causing it to be here and now or at any moment. The cause of the existence of something here and now must be other than the thing itself because a thing cannot account for its own existence. If a thing could account for its own existence, then it would need to be identical with existence. But if a thing were identical with existence, then only it could exist and nothing but it. Furthermore, no change would be possible because if a thing is its own existence, then any change could only lead from existence to something that isn't existence, i.e., non-existence. So existence precedes things and things exist here and now because it is, like the person pushing the staff, causing them to be.
We call this cause of existence God and if anything exists it necessary follows that there is a foundational cause and that is God.
- galaxyLogic 7y agoYou can call it "God", meaning the above is your definition of "God". But I think that is highly misleading because the word "God" is used in the Bible and it speaks about a very specific type of thing, not defined like you define it but as something which created everything in 7 days, spoke to Moses etc. Using the same term "God" as Bible, Book of Mormon, Koran and other books do but with a different "definition" is highly confusing and misleading. You should call the "cause of existence" simply "Cause of Existence". If you need a shorter way to refer to it a good one would be "CoE", not "God". Why use the same name as Bible unless you are saying you are talking about the same thing that Bible is, the thing that spoke to Moses?
- checkyoursudo 7y agoOnly things exist.