6 ms·
> Especially now that Uber has a STFU option I never understood why people are so against talking to the people that give them a ride. I once was in a very rou
by paganel 7y ago
> Especially now that Uber has a STFU option
I never understood why people are so against talking to the people that give them a ride. I once was in a very rough spot in my life and talking with taxi-drivers almost daily about the most trivial stuff (weather, politics, traffic) used to give me a very healthy reprieve from the black thoughts I used to have.
- toyg 7y ago> why people are so against talking to the people that give them a ride. I'm an ethnic minority where I live, but I'm white. Do I want to be dragged into some racist conversation fuelled by Nigel Farage on talk-radio and by made-up stories in The Sun? Nope. Even if I did, would it change anything? Nope - a 20-min cab ride is not enough time to dispel all the crap accumulated over decades of disinformation. If I had a STFU button for regular cabs, most of the time I would hit it hard. But there isn't one, so I put earphones up, send all the social signals I can think of that say "leave me alone", and tip well if they do exactly that.
- base698 7y agoWow, didn't know casual conversation solely existed to dispel app the crap disinformation. I've been doing it wrong this whole time. Before I just thought it was about giving people respect and finding common ground.
- magduf 7y agoWhen people are right-wing extremists, they can't help but bring up their BS in casual conversation. I've seen it many times. They live in an entirely different reality, where the basic facts simply are not the same as the facts you believe in, because they listen to entirely different sources of information. Talking with them is futile, as the OP said: who has time to try to dispel the crap disinformation, and it's probably not going to be successful anyway because why should they listen to you over the slick-sounding guy who has radio airtime? And what reasonable, intelligent person wants to be dragged into an unhappy political conversation every time he takes a cab ride?
- meruru 7y agoAll extremists are like that and when you single out one group it just makes you look like the opposing group's extremists. Your comment looks exactly like what a right-wing extremist would write about leftists.
- magduf 7y agoYou're right, all extremists are like that. The thing is, the OP was claiming that we need to talk to these people, respect them, engage with them, etc., even when we're just taking a ride in a taxi. My position is that, no, you don't need to try to talk to extremists when you just want to get from point A to point B, and also that trying to change these peoples' minds rarely works out. Finally, no, singling out one group does not make you look like an opposing group's extremists. If you complain about neo-Nazis marching in your city this weekend, for instance, that does not somehow make you look like an extreme leftist. The simple fact is that right-wing extremism is very common these days among certain groups of people; you're probably not going to find any extreme leftists in a random rural American town, for instance.
- base698 7y agoI was actually saying there is more to life than politics and infinite topics that don't include them. Maybe turn off the TV and get a hobby?
- dang 7y agoPlease don't cross into personal rudeness in HN comments. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- toyg 7y agoHow do you "give respect" to people who, given half the chance, would literally ship you out of the country you've built your life in for the last two decades? How do you find "common ground" with people who are seriously convinced that your mere existence is robbing them of something they cannot coherently articulate, when all the facts are that you are actually helping their own welfare? I am afraid you have no idea what being an European (or most other ethnic minorities) is like in 2019 Britain. For us, this is not your standard dinner-party "lib vs con" parlour game, or the occasional shouting match at a family reunion - it's the difference between being a citizen in a modern democracy and being something very close to a Jew in Brüning's Germany.
- hrktb 7y agoIdeally that’s a two way street, with driver that really want to talk to clients not accepting silent drives and vice versa. Otherwise, just as talking to people seem to have helped you a lot, for other people not having to talk is also a godsend. I think it’s fine to not understand everyone’s motives or functionning, as long as their needs are met somehow.
- simmanian 7y agoBeing silent in the absence of anything noteworthy to talk about is exactly the healthy reprieve some people are looking for. I personally find it absolutely taxing to talk about the weather or the traffic because I just don't enjoy talking for the sake of talking and I shouldn't be pressured to meet an arbitrary social expectation I have no interest in.
- robocat 7y agoFor that case, perhaps there should be an option to tick as you order the Uber.
- jdminhbg 7y ago> I never understood why people are so against talking to the people that give them a ride. I'm not always against talking to people, but there are definitely drivers who don't know how to read the mood in the car and will drag you into conversations you don't care about. Particularly if you're on a 4:30 am ride to the airport, you might just want to be left alone.
- JimboOmega 7y agoAs a woman, there are definitely times I don't want to deal with a driver hitting on me. It happens annoyingly frequently, and it's this delicate social situation that requires more mental effort to negotiate than I want to give it. Friendly conversation (with men and women both) is fine and I've engaged in plenty. But if a driver is too busy telling me just how beautiful I am and as a result drives me to the cargo part of the airport rather than the passenger terminal and makes me late... and I have to sort of humor him and not just say wtf because that's the social contract? Or if I have to for some reason convince him I'm an engineer and not a dancer in spite of my long legs? Yeah, I'll pass on that. In other situations I can thank them for the compliment and go somewhere else, but with a driver I'm stuck for quite a while. And sometimes I'm really not in the mood. I've complained before there really needs to be a "please don't hit on me" option, and STFU is a decent alternative.
- throwaway666666 7y agoWow it must be so hard for you to have to deal with people talking with you and trying to get to know you better! These men attempting to talk to you are literally devils! Obviously there needs to be a law passed that if you're a man, you need written permission to be allowed to speak to a woman before you do so, otherwise you should be jailed.
- dgzl 7y ago> and it's this delicate social situation that requires more mental effort to negotiate than I want to give it I understand what you're saying, and I recognize the blessing/curse that comes with attracting people. However, as I've become an adult with a career and have left essentially all my friends behind, I've realized that making new friends is incredibly difficult. Even worse is trying to find dating partners. Lately I've been resorting to just talking to strangers and seeing if I can start a conversation. Not to excuse the behavior of your drivers, but you should understand that men are having a difficult time with approaching women these days. We feel really inadequate and sort of aimless. The dating world is seriously dangerous right now and to be honest, there isn't a lot of guidance from women. I've experienced a range of rejections and the least painful are always honest and upfront. Maybe you could try that?
- smsm42 7y agoBecause for some people talking to strangers is hard. Literally - like for some people carrying a 50 lbs bag might be hard, so can be talking to a stranger. Can I take this 50 lbs bag and walk with you for a mile or two because you think it'd be fun for you? Yes, I can. Do I want to? Maybe, if you're my friend or I feel like working out or just in the mood. Or maybe not, because I don't feel like doing this work now. Maybe I just want to rest and be alone with my thoughts right now. Not for the whole life - but right now, in this moment. People have different needs and different informational metabolism. Some like conversing with strangers, some - not really.
- avtar 7y agoReading this felt like you've been observing me at the gym and documenting my behaviour. I've been trying to establish an exercise habit and at some point I'd like to become comfortable again talking to strangers. It used to be a skill that I practiced unknowingly when I was young and could talk to anyone. Now there are days when I'm done working out and it takes all the effort just to make eye contact with someone and mutter something like "hey, how was your class?"
- abledon 7y agofor an ice-breaker, dont go with an emotional check-in lol. much easier to say something humorous like 'fukin weights, bastards are gonna kill me rather than make me fit'
- smsm42 7y agoDon't get me wrong - many introverts can talk to strangers just fine if they need it (just as I can lift 50 lbs if I need it), it's just something they don't particularly enjoy doing. It's work. If it needs to be done, it will be done, but if it can be avoided - it will be avoided. I am not sure one needs some training to change that - if I don't enjoy doing something, why waste time on doing it if I could instead do something I already enjoy doing?
- actuator 7y agoI like talking with the person on the wheel on my Uber rides, unless I am busy with something important. Even when I am in a new place and don't know the local language well, I try to talk to them. It just gives a different perspective to what I usually get from my social circle and makes the time go by so fast.
- ionised 7y agoI've never been interested in talking to my taxi driver. I will if they initiate conversation just to be polite, but I'd really rather just be left alone to stare out the window and think.
- lunchables 7y ago>I never understood why people are so against talking to the people that give them a ride. Its frequently one of the few times during the day where I do not have to interact with someone, especially when traveling for work. Sometimes I just want 10 minutes to myself to think.
- dang 7y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20117510 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20117510.