3 ms·
I was one of the first users of Bitcoin, and one of the earliest developers. I'd like to have a beer with Satoshi some day, so I took a brief look at this. But
by mike_hearn 7y ago
I was one of the first users of Bitcoin, and one of the earliest developers. I'd like to have a beer with Satoshi some day, so I took a brief look at this. But I'm unconvinced.
One key claim is "they both liked gambling, Bitcoin 0.1 had a poker client in it". Beyond the obvious problem that lots of people like poker, this claim is nonsense. None of the versions of Bitcoin I've ever seen had a poker client in them. It's not even clear what that would mean - you can't implement (mental) poker with Bitcoin Script. And I don't recall Satoshi ever commenting on gambling one way or another.
Another claim is that they both knew C++. Let's assume for a moment that TrueCrypt was written by Paul le Roux (I don't know the backstory). I downloaded the TrueCrypt code and had a look at it.
The TrueCrypt code doesn't share the same rather distinctive coding style Satoshi used. Bitcoin was rare for all kinds of reasons, but one rather obscure reason is that he used a simplified variant of Hungarian notation and only wrote code for Windows. The TrueCrypt code doesn't share this quirk, but it does have a different formatting quirk that I haven't seen before (there's always a space after a function name and the argument list in invocations). Satoshi didn't use that style either. Styles can be pretty distinctive, and I've never seen one that exactly matched Bitcoin's. So it looks to me like these codebases were written by different people.
The other bits of "evidence" are all circumstantial and frequently absurd. The entire thing traces back to Craig Wright, which isn't a good sign.
- dwild 7y agoFor the poker claims, a quick Google search gave this: https://github.com/trottier/original-bitcoin/blob/master/src/uibase.cpp#L1573 https://github.com/trottier/original-bitcoin/blob/master/src... I don't know if this is the right source code though.
- Method-X 7y agoHey Mike! Are there any known examples of Nick Szabo's code anywhere?
- I_am_tiberius 7y agoI'm hearing about the Hungarian notation story for the first time. Just makes it more evident that it's Nick Szabo.
- mike_hearn 7y agoWhy?
- I_am_tiberius 7y agoHe explains it in this 1 minute interview. He lived in Hungary until he moved to the US with his parents. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZw4LNLYUgc&list=PLyajeoDXKmQ7QM8ouEObZalBUZetN9A_J https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZw4LNLYUgc&list=PLyajeoDXKm...
- mike_hearn 7y agoHungarian notation has nothing to do with living in Hungary. It's a style of naming variables in which type codes are prefixed to the name, e.g. a variable holding a name might be called lpszName for "long pointer to string terminated with a zero". It's called Hungarian notation because the programmer at Microsoft who came up with it came from Hungary, beyond that there's no connection.
- I_am_tiberius 7y agoah ok. Then I take it back;)
- I_am_tiberius 7y agoBut actually I think we should all respect his privacy - I'm just annoyed when people come up with such odd new ideas that may harm bitcoin's reputation.