2 ms·
Last time I asked this question, the reasoning was that there are non-rational (i.e. emotional, legal) reasons why an apparent lump on an MRI has to get address
by whatshisface 7y ago
Last time I asked this question, the reasoning was that there are non-rational (i.e. emotional, legal) reasons why an apparent lump on an MRI has to get addressed, so the only acceptable point to say "don't operate" lies at the point where the doctor decides whether or not to test. Apparently, doctors get exactly one chance to say no.
- nathan_f77 7y agoThat makes a lot of sense. It also feels like a very solvable problem. If I had the option to get annual MRI scans, but I had to sign a waiver that prevents me from suing the doctor or the hospital, then I would gladly take that deal. I'd rather have the data and an expert opinion, instead of no data and no opinion. If they miss something and I die, then no problem (mainly because I'm dead, but also because I would have died anyway). If they do a biopsy and it turns out that it was nothing, then that's also no problem. It's what I signed up for, and I understand that false positives can happen. Hopefully I could find a level-headed doctor (or a black-box machine learning algorithm), and just trust them to make the right call.
- darkpuma 7y agoThe emotional reasons are particularly huge, considering the known connections between stress and general well-being: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychological_stress#Physiological_impacts_of_stress https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychological_stress#Physiolog... The connection between information and stress, and the connection between stress and a wide range of physiological effects effectively proves that more data is NOT always better. It's clear that there are cases where being given more data will reduce the general well-being of the patient.