6 ms·
Quantum transitions take time – the news is its experimental demonstration
- rubidium 7y agoOr more accurately: "The time it takes to make a quantum leap has been experimentally measured for the first time". There is experimental news. Very cool and newsworthy. Just not new theoretical news.
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoplease tell us the amount of time it takes! It must be an incredibly small time, but no one in the discussion or the brief abstract did I see it.
- tlb 7y agoFor a transition of an electron between energy levels that emits a photon, should the time it takes for the transition be the same as the duration of the probability envelope of the photon? If so, that's easily observable by looking at the width of the spectral line. If the transition is fast, that implies a short duration and therefore the spectral lines should be smeared out.
- lisper 7y agoYes, that is exactly right. All of this just boils down to the energy-time version of the uncertainty principle: the more precisely you can measure when a transition happened, the less certain you can be about the change in energy of that transition. Here is another example of this principle at work: http://blog.rongarret.info/2018/05/a-quantum-mechanics-puzzle.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2018/05/a-quantum-mechanics-puzzl... http://blog.rongarret.info/2018/05/a-quantum-mechanics-puzzle-part-deux.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2018/05/a-quantum-mechanics-puzzl... http://blog.rongarret.info/2018/05/a-quantum-mechanics-puzzle-part-drei.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2018/05/a-quantum-mechanics-puzzl...
- effie 7y agoWhat you're saying about uncertainty principle is strange. The principle says the longer the transition takes, the sharper the spectral line can be (but does not have to be, hence the inequality). There is nothing about uncertainty of measurement of time of some point event. The transition is not a point event. If the two states involved in the transition are known, then change of energy is known. How long the transition will take depends on strength and frequency characteristics of the external field, but the energy difference of energy of the molecule after the transition is over does not depend on that.
- lisper 7y agoYes, everything you say is correct. That's exactly what makes this experiment so interesting. They didn't just measure the energy state at one time and then again at another time. That wouldn't work (because of the quantum Zeno effect).
- will_brown 7y agoI have a elementary question about the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle (my understanding is Quatum Leap/transitions are just a description of the uncertainty principle wave function)... As we know from “flatland” as a sphere passes through the flatland plane, the sphere can be measured as a dot/circle at any given time. https://demonstrations.wolfram.com/ASphereVisitsFlatland/ https://demonstrations.wolfram.com/ASphereVisitsFlatland/ Wouldn’t that measurement of a higher dimensional object passing through the lower dimensional world sort of begin to appear and fit the definition of the uncertainty principle for particles in our own 3D world? In other words as the 3D sphere is measured passing through the 2d flatland flatlanders can either know the position of the sphere or momentum, but as they measure one more accurately they can’t measure the other as accurately? I guess what I’m trying to ask is it accurate to use the uncertainty principle as a flatlander describing a 3D sphere passing through flatland and if so, Would that give any credence to the bizarre possibility that particles in our world are actually 4D objects?
- zitterbewegung 7y agoNo
- lisper 7y ago> Quatum Leap/transitions are just a description of the uncertainty principle wave function That is almost right. But it's not a description of the uncertainty principle, it's a manifestation of the uncertainty principle, specifically the time-energy uncertainty principle. But none of this has anything to do with flatland. It has to do with Fourier analysis: the more localized a signal is in the time domain the more spread out it is in the frequency domain, and vice versa.
- RootKitBeerCat 7y agoI love Hacker News
- jpmattia 7y agoThe link brings us to an article focused on how another article in Quanta Magazine did not summarize an article in Nature correctly. Really, the right thing to do is go directly to the Nature article, and read the abstract. If you've been reading things about QM, even as a non-physicist, then you're probably pretty close to understanding the abstract. Moreover, a quick reading of the Quanta Magazine article makes it seem as though they shifted the focus of the original result from predictability and determinism to instantaneous transitions. (Although I note I haven't had time to read and fully digest the Nature paper.) From the abstract in Nature: > The times at which the discontinuous jump transitions occur are reputed to be fundamentally unpredictable. Despite the non-deterministic character of quantum physics, is it possible to know if a quantum jump is about to occur? Here we answer this question affirmatively: we experimentally demonstrate that the jump from the ground state to an excited state of a superconducting artificial three-level atom can be tracked as it follows a predictable ‘flight’, by monitoring the population of an auxiliary energy level coupled to the ground state. The experimental results demonstrate that the evolution of each completed jump is continuous, coherent and deterministic. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-1287-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-1287-z
- kgwgk 7y ago> To go smoothly from 0 to 1, the system transitions through a series of superpositions of both states, i.e. it starts out entirely in state 0, and then transitions smoothly to being mostly in state 0 and a little bit in state 1, to being half in each state, to being mostly in 1 and a little bit in 0, to being entirely in 1. Not really. An atom can be described by its quantum state only if it's isolated and in that case its energy is constant. If the states s_1 and s_2 have different energies E_1 and E_2 then the quantum state may be a superposition of the states s_1 and s_2 with an expected value for the energy between E_1 and E_2 but no "smooth transition" is possible. For the transition to happen the atom has to be coupled with an external field. One way to think of it is as the evolution of the system composed of the atom plus a photon, where the transition between the states "excited atom and no emitted photon" and "unexcited atom and emited photon" happens at constant energy. Edit: See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spontaneous_emission#Theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spontaneous_emission#Theory
- duality 7y ago"An atom can be described by its quantum state only if it's isolated and in that case its energy is constant." How do you figure? As a contradiction, take your atom+electromagnetic field system, describe the transition from excited atom to unexcited atom + photon state, and project out the E&M field. Voila, now you have a quantum description of an atom transitioning between different energy states. Its dynamics may look funny, i.e. they may appear nonlocal, they may not conserve energy, etc. but that's different from saying "there is not a quantum description of these dynamics" which is what you're claiming.
- kgwgk 7y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_state https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_state > project out the E&M field. Voila, now you have a quantum description There is no wavefunction describing the state of the subsystem because the system is not separable. > Its dynamics may look funny, i.e. they may appear nonlocal, they may not conserve energy, etc. but that's different from saying "there is not a quantum description of these dynamics" which is what you're claiming. What is the “quantum description of these dynamics”? Quantum mechanics is usually based on something like the following postulate: “The state of a physical system is described by a well-behaved function of the coordinates and time, Ψ(q, t). The function contains all the information that can be known about the system.”
- Anon84 7y agoDiscussion on the Quant magazine article from yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20105091 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20105091
- JumpCrisscross 7y agoThe paper’s abstract [1] states: “certain classical phenomena, like tsunamis, while unpredictable in the long term, may possess a degree of predictability in the short term, and in some cases it may be possible to prevent a disaster by detecting an advance warning signal.” Is there a name for such class of phenomena? For the opposite, where small-scale unpredictability (e.g. particle motion) because large-scale decipherable (fluid mechanics), we have the law of large numbers and “emergent phenomena.” [1] http://qulab.eng.yale.edu/documents/theses/Minev_ZK-Dissertation_Jumps.pdf http://qulab.eng.yale.edu/documents/theses/Minev_ZK-Disserta...
- mcnamaratw 7y agoSure, a quantum transition takes time. But demonstrating that point experimentally is not new this year. In The Feynman Lectures on Physics, vol II, p. 35-4, Feynman describes an experiment by I.I. Rabi. I think Rabi did the work in the 1940s. The reciprocal of the transition time is the 'Rabi Frequency'. http://mriquestions.com/who-discovered-nmr.html http://mriquestions.com/who-discovered-nmr.html https://www.aps.org/programs/outreach/history/historicsites/rabi.cfm https://www.aps.org/programs/outreach/history/historicsites/... Back to 2019, the dissertation abstract underlying the news story here doesn't appear to claim that this is the first experimental demonstration that quantum transitions take time. Which is probably good.
- astazangasta 7y agoI'd like to point out that this sort of story vitiates the Popperian tale of how scientific knowledge is created, i.e. it was "known" well in advance of experimental evidence that something is true, and the confirmation is seen as banal.
- qtplatypus 7y agoWhich is ironic since popper had a real problem with QM.
- cubano 7y ago> To get around this problem, Devoret and colleagues employ a clever trick involving a second excited state. The system can reach this second state from the ground state by absorbing a photon of a different energy. The researchers probe the system in a way that only ever tells them whether the system is in this second “bright” state, so named because it’s the one that can be seen. The state to and from which the researchers are actually looking for quantum jumps is, meanwhile, the “dark” state — because it remains hidden from direct view. This is absolutely brilliant work. I had no idea that experimenters had found a way around the quantum measurement problem. I have always wondered "how in hell can people experiment with something that is actually affected by simply LOOKING at it?" This gives me my answer. Even though this idea is only one step in the findings of this article, I am so glad I came across it.