3 ms·
You can still have causality.
by sp332 7y ago
You can still have causality.
- pavel_lishin 7y agoCan you expand on this? How can you have causality - cause and effect - that's divorced from some sort of flow of time?
- kowdermeister 7y agoIf I turn on a very simple computer, then the clock starts at zero. From the computers perspective that's all there is, it doesn't know the cause. From my point of view there absolutely is a case, me pushing a button. This is not a god argument, there might be natural processes that can trigger such events.
- pavel_lishin 7y agoThe computer, and the external universe of which it is unaware, still have time.
- Cyph0n 7y agoTotal amateur here: how do we know that time did not exist before the beginning of the universe?
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoAlmost-total amateur here: We don't. We really don't. We don't have any physical evidence of anything from before the big bang (presuming that's what we call the "beginning"). Zero. All we have is people having views on the current situation, trying to apply those views backwards to "before", where they may or may not fit, and saying "I think it's like this".
- wuliwong 7y agoI don't think this is an accurate analogy. The computer's space-time and your space-time are the same in this analogy. The space-time that our universe exists in would not be the same as the space-time that some extra-universe process would be inside if the big bang theory is accurate. This isn't an analogy for causality without time, this is causality for the creation of our universe if the big bang theory is wrong and space-time didn't expand out of a point some billions of years ago, ie. that our space-time existed "before" the big bang and there were processes outside of our universe that were still inside of the same space-time as ours.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoIf the computer is simulating a spacetime, they're not the same. You could - hypothetically - pause the computer, check its state, change a few variables, and the simulation would experience instant modifications. A slow simulator could take many "real" time units to calculate each in-simulation time frame - and this would be invisible in-simulation. And so on. You have a fully causal system, but the simulation is ruled by its own independent emulation of causality. Of course a computer implies a conscious user. But let's attempt some wild speculation and suggest that a "simulation" could also be a completely natural process - something that happens in a much bigger causal substrate: a kind of causal symmetry breaking, where a subset of possible relationships crystallises out of a bigger set of possibilities and then continues independently, losing some degrees of freedom. A simple two level topology is the simplest possible model. But "causality physics" could allow all kinds of topologies - nested, circular, fractal, etc.
- burlesona 7y agoAlthough it raises an interesting question, because physics has a lot of issues with time. Just as in the computer example, why could we not imagine that our universe exists inside the space and time of larger superuniverse, and perhaps the phenomena that explain times arrow is easily observable in that universe, but not in ours.
- karmakaze 7y agoGood point which brings us to a simple explanation. Time zero isn't when the h/w is booted, it's when the software is started. As unpopular as the simulation theory is, many difficult issues can easily be thought about. Except for the rest of the turtles.
- abtinf 7y agoLogically, cause and effect precede time. The concept of time integrates your perceptions of cause and effect. We observe various causes and effects require variable amounts of time, we omit the specific amounts of time, thus inductively identifying the abstract concept of time.
- 0815test 7y agoBoth causality and the "flow" of time are ultimately artifacts due to the fact that a "universe", by definition, is something thay starts out in a highly-ordered state and evolves away from it. The basic laws of physics are time-symmetrical, at least in a practical sense - they do not involve any distinction between "cause" and "effect".
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> a "universe", by definition, is something thay starts out in a highly-ordered state and evolves away from it. I don't think that's "by definition". That's by observation of an example of one.
- bduerst 7y agoOur existence is limited to four dimensions, so we perceive things through the scope of time, including cause -> effect. On the level of higher dimensions, it's difficult for us to perceive how cause -> effect would play out, but it's similar to how you would influence a drawing of a 2D stick figure. You could draw a house next to the stick figure, and that would cause the house to exist, but to the stick figure it would only perceive a single line with a start and finish on 1 dimension. To that stick figure, cause and effect would be perceived as the two points on the line, though your four dimensional pencil caused it to exist on a different dimensional level.
- antidesitter 7y agoAccording to some theories, space and time arise from causality. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causal_sets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causal_sets
- xenocyon 7y agoCausality is just human perception and there's nothing special about time. Let me try to explain this in three ways, going from intuitive/trivial to non-intuitive/mind-blowing: • You can have causality in space rather than time: e.g. a convolutional image filter at pixel 13 might consider pixels 12, 13, 14 (of which the first two are causal and the last is non-causal, if we consider higher numbers as going "forward") • You can have non-causal filters in time: e.g. audio compression at time 0:30 might consider not only the portion of audio from 0:00 to 0:30, but also the audio from 0:30 to 2:33. (This doesn't seem that remarkable, because the track has already been recorded, so it's not in "real time".) • Finally, what we usually think of as intuitive causality in "real time" is simply a question of entropy. We think of a person dying because she was shot by a bullet, but we could also replay the movie backwards and think of all the tissues of a human body coming together in such a way as to propel the bullet backwards at a high velocity - in other words the wound causes the bullet to fly! The only reason we don't think of it this way is because the latter explanation decreases rather than increases entropy. As it turns out, physicists can show that entropy is also the exact reason why we remember the past and not the future. (And if we did remember the future and not the past, we would simply think of the future as the past and vice versa, so things wouldn't feel any different.)
- quotemstr 7y agoCausality without time makes no sense. Even if you don't have a ticking clock, you can define "time" with a counter and a Lamport clock. Any time you have state, you have time. A timeless universe is hard to grasp.
- abtinf 7y agoTime without causality makes no sense. Time is an identification that entities move and change. The entities themselves cause all actions. The nature of those actions is determined by the nature of the entities.
- morsmodr 7y agoTime is another dimension that we 'perceive'. Hence for our frame of reference, which is bound by time, asking what is outside this frame of reference makes no sense. But frames of references are relative and meant to be broken. Similarly it is hard to imagine any object that can be purely 2D in nature, because we are biased to perceive the world in 3D. So we think that every object has to be 3D, even the smallest organism, or even atoms. But a 'fake' example of 2D is a tv screen. It gives us an example to imagine 2D. The point I am trying to make is that time is just our perception. To say causality is always tied to time is a bias created by viewing the universe through a 'time' tinted/colored glass. The point of singularity where gravity is so high that time comes to stand still, but is still present - this is a possibility. So maybe time just pauses between big bangs and flows at lower density and lower gravitational fields
- SomeOldThrow 7y ago> The point I am trying to make is that time is just our perception. So is causality—I'm not really sure what your point is.
- morsmodr 7y agoBecause we are limited by our perceptions of time (and causality as well) doesn't mean we shouldn't wonder what could have been before the start of the universe. Maybe time started when universe started, or maybe time always existed and was super slow or literally paused at singularity - the gravity is so high (way more than the gravity of a super massive black hole) that time had paused. So maybe there was something before the big bang and I don't think 'talking about that makes no sense' should stop us from talking about it :) I am also confused a tad about the point I wanted to make though, lol. Maybe causality and time is perceived differently in higher or other dimensions that we do not perceive as of now in our human level of evolution. So the assumption of causality exists only due to time being present could be something relative to our perceptions and not true
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]