3 ms·
> Apps in the Kids Category may not include third-party advertising or analytics. Totally agreed for advertising... but analytics are essential to improving th
by crazygringo 7y ago
> Apps in the Kids Category may not include third-party advertising or analytics.
Totally agreed for advertising... but analytics are essential to improving the quality and usability of apps including for kids, and they're a real cost to roll your own. Using third-party analytics is like using a third-party JPEG or MP3 decoder: it almost never makes sense spending 100's or 1,000's of hours writing your own.
So I don't get it. What's the harm for kids in third-party analytics? Third-party analytics are just a service, they're not necessarily ever correlated with anything else. But even if they are, the only argument I can imagine is not helping further build up advertising profiles... but if kids aren't seeing the ads anyways then again, what's the harm?
- dawnerd 7y agoBecause it’s wrong?
- crazygringo 7y agoWhat is wrong about it? "Because it's wrong" isn't really a response without something backing it up. That's what I'm asking -- what's the harm, where's the wrong? The harm in advertising is obvious. A harm from third-party analytics is not.
- dawnerd 7y agoAnalytics can be harmful too. Developers use it to make the app/game stickier, more attractive to children. Children also have no way of consenting or even knowing what analytics are. Not only that but there’s no knowing what happens to the analytics at third parties - regardless of their privacy policies. Basically all third party analytics are designed to build profiles and help marketing. Plenty of safe ways to track interactions that don’t rely on third party scripts which gobble up all kinds of data. Plus might even be illegal depending on jurisdiction.
- notatoad 7y ago>Developers use it to make the app/game stickier, more attractive to children another way to phrase that is "developers use it to make the game more fun"
- Avamander 7y agoAddictive does not always mean fun. Kids love bright things like lasers and love to shine them into their eyes (I know I did), doesn't mean it's a good idea - even if it is fun.
- mobjack 7y agoMany third party analytics tools can be configured to track user behavior anonymously without any PII data. It is a feature because at least some developers want a solution to protect users privacy while still being able to gather data to improve user experience. This feels like throwing the baby out with the bathwater. There are reasonable steps that can be taken to stop advertising trackers without a blanket ban on everything.
- scarface74 7y agoHow hard is it really to add your own analytics? Isn’t it just logging what your users are doing and sync it to your server when you get a signal? I was writing stuff like this for enterprise field service Windows CE devices over a decade ago.
- crazygringo 7y agoLogging is easy. Waiting for a connection and syncing reliably and testing that it works is a little harder -- annoying but not too bad. Provisioning a database to store the data, maintain backups, index properly for queries etc., and maintain so it doesn't run out of space or degrade in performance as datasets grow by many orders of magnitude is an entirely separate skillset and harder still. Visualizing it -- coming up with complex SQL queries and then dumping them into a graphing tool and overlapping different data series on the same graph -- will take forever. A big part of analytics is exploring and looking for patterns. The person with the business background doing the exploring probably isn't a programmer or a SQL expert. So a pre-built GUI for this is huge, and will be the hardest thing of all to program. So, pretty hard. Or... you can throw in a third-party tool with all of that, and have it all work in an hour or two.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tclancy 7y agoBut the last two steps can happen on your side. The data can go to a data store someone else maintains like AWS and you can use any number of packaged visualization tools on top of it.