4 ms·
Why do they ban third-party advertising in particular? It seems like advertising should be allowed as long as it's display only with no outward information flow
by criddell 7y ago
Why do they ban third-party advertising in particular? It seems like advertising should be allowed as long as it's display only with no outward information flow. Basically ads equivalent OTA television or magazine ads should be allowed.
- m-p-3 7y agoMost likely to limit and control the ability to track this category of users.
- RickS 7y agoPresumably because third party insertion doesn't give the app creators sufficient control over what's shown. This happens all the time. Forbes.com starts serving malware and then cry "we didn't know! the third party guys just put whatever in that box!" So it's not (just) the outward flow of information, but the additional policing burden of a separate inward flow of graphics.
- criddell 7y agoThat makes a lot of sense.
- lozenge 7y agoBecause no ad network is trustworthy. It avoids stories like "developer's labour of love banned over ad network that resold space to ad network that resold space to ad network that put an inappropriate ad".
- scarface74 7y agoMarco Arment created his own ad platform that he curates for the Overcast podcast player partially for that reason and he didn't want random binary blobs shipping with his code.
- astrodust 7y ago"Developer's labor of love taken over by a publisher that got acquired by Evil Corp which allowed anyone to buy ads on their platform."
- mithr 7y agoIn general, I believe it's based on the belief that children in partiular don't yet have the necessary mental tools to be able to properly analyze content -- basically, that they're influenced by media to a much higher degree than adults. > Basically ads equivalent OTA television or magazine ads should be allowed I would guess that proponents of this approach also feel that the contents of TV/magazine ads should be strictly controlled (and probably they are -- I'm not sure what the exact regulations around these are, but I am sure it's much harder to publish a blatantly misleading magazine or TV ad, without consequences to the advertiser or the network/magazine, than it is to publish one online).
- snek 7y agoNot just a belief, it's been studied many times, and it is in fact illegal to have "native" advertising on children's TV shows, at least in the U.S.
- scarface74 7y agoAlmost all cartoons aimed at kids hope to make money on related merchandise. A lot of animated shows were cancelled because while the ratings were good, they skewed toward older teens and adults that didn't buy toys. Two that come to mind are "Young Justice" and the original "Teen Titans". Cartoon Network specifically made "Teen Titans Go!" to skew younger. This isn't a new thing, they killed off most of the Transformers in the 80s movie so they could introduce a new line of characters/toys.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- eli 7y agoThen why are first-party ads allowed?
- pwinnski 7y agoI hope this is step one, and that first-party ads are step two or three.
- lotu 7y agoI'm interpreting this as third party targeting, not that you can't use a third party handle the process of targeting, serving, and billing ads. If they are saying that the game company has to have their own ad platform that basically means only Google and Facebook will be able to release ad supported child targeted games on iOS in the future, which doesn't really make any sense to me.
- pwinnski 7y agoIf they choose to interpret the rule as "no ad-supported child-targeted games on iOS, period," that sounds good to me. I hope they do.
- nkrisc 7y agoHonestly all advertising targeted to children should be banned. It's just not fair. Children don't stand a chance against marketing crafted by adults. You're pitting the mind of a child against that of a trained, professional, adult marketer. The kid is their clay to be molded.
- gameswithgo 7y agoadults don't stand a chance either.
- majewsky 7y ago> Children don't stand a chance against marketing crafted by adults. Nobody can stand a chance against someone well-versed in applied psychology (i.e. a marketer).
- TeMPOraL 7y agoEspecially that it's really you vs. a whole industry of well-paid professionals weaponizing psychological research.
- repolfx 7y agoThe fact that so much advertising barely works is the basis of Google's entire business model. The idea that adverts are all made by masters of psychological manipulation is laughable - most of it is considered successful of it just manages to get the name noticed and remembered at all.
- AJ007 7y agoThis seems to be getting missed, but those kids apps are serving ads for adults. Google has gone way out of their way to make it confusing to block mobile ads (you used to have to add a blacklist domain.) Last year they removed support for that and required advertisers to check an option within the ad campaign. Earlier this year they removed that option. This is a win for advertisers, a loss for publishers and ad networks making money from mis-targeted ads.
- kalleboo 7y ago
- cwkoss 7y agoChildren are not mature enough to understand that advertisements are lies meant to sell products, and can believe the content of the advertisements are true. This is harmful to society, particularly as young children are not capable of making purchasing decisions anyways - this is adversarial brainwashing of the most vulnerable.
- criddell 7y agoThat's true of advertising in general and not third party advertising in particular. Somebody else posted what I think is the correct answer - it removes the possibility of a third party showing inappropriate content to kids.
- lathiat 7y agoIt sounds simple but one of the biggest frustrations is that kids accidentally click the ads which take you out of the app into something else. And constantly get confused. Hence it also requires the apps not to have external links etc.