5 ms·
> Noise is my main concern with drone delivery networks. What about 20-50 lb flying machines falling onto sidewalks, roofs, and streets? You don't see amateur
by vkou 7y ago
> Noise is my main concern with drone delivery networks.
What about 20-50 lb flying machines falling onto sidewalks, roofs, and streets?
You don't see amateur RC aviation enthusiasts flying their model airplanes in the middle of the city, and I sure as hell don't want to see a corporation doing this on an industrial scale.
Why not ground-based drone delivery?
- jagger27 7y agoNot to mention people's heads! I have faith in agencies like the FAA to keep things safe and reasonable, and where that isn't enough NIMBYs and municipal governments will pick up the slack, no doubt.
- derekp7 7y ago> I have faith in agencies like the FAA to keep things safe Has this faith been shaken by the recent 737 Max issues?
- patrick5415 7y agoNo. Air travel is still incredibly safe, a few high profile accidents notwithstanding.
- throwaway5752 7y agoWhy are you downvoted? Safety is a thousand times more concerning - the drones will mechanically fail, they will hit bad weather, they will collide with birds, there will be new drone delivery market entrants and will need coordination across systems... If a drone fails at an expected operating altitude, it can kill someone easily on the ground. If it fails at height over a highway, what if it kills a bus driver or causes a tractor trailer to lose control? What if they hit electric lines? What else can go in flight corridors at the same altitudes? Do they container chemicals or voltages that first responders have to be aware of?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zjaffee 7y agoThere's a reason why it's taking so long for Amazon to get FAA approval for drone delivery and this is exactly why. There are people in important places asking these sorts of questions already. My guess personally, is that drone delivery will ultimately just be a tool for a self driving truck to get the package from the truck to the door. Drones are not nearly good enough as it stands today to do end to end deliveries at an industrial scale outside of maybe a few rural areas.
- greenburger 7y agoThe same people in important places that approved the 737 Max?
- BrandonMarc 7y agoYes ... so they have experience in crashing planes, which is relevant. /s
- pwinnski 7y agoIn the sense that they are human, yes. Even in the sense that they work for the government, which narrows the pool to 20,000,000+ But also, no. Not the same people.
- greenburger 7y agoI get your point but the relevant agency division FAA AVS employees 7,200 people [0]. Fewer than that are involved in certifying aircraft safety. Agencies like all other human groups have cultures. [0] https://www.faa.gov/about/plans_reports/congress/media/fy17_avs_wfp_final.pdf https://www.faa.gov/about/plans_reports/congress/media/fy17_...
- dragonwriter 7y agoWasn't a critical issue with 737 MAX that incumbent manufacturers are able to self-certify equivalency without any review? So, to the extent the Boeing 737 MAX team is not reviewing Amazon's applications, no, not the same people.
- buu700 7y agoInteresting point. Maybe instead we should be using self-driving cars with drones (or something ground-based, like RC skateboards) only handling moving packages from the car to the door.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoThis exists: https://nuro.ai/ https://nuro.ai/
- joshvm 7y agoThis probably isn't for cities. I was at a conference a few years back where Prime Air gave a talk. It was quite a vague talk, but admittedly it was hilarious watching Takeo Kanade grill the speaker on technical details that he refused to elaborate on. Things have no doubt moved on, but they were talking about use cases like delivering to rural areas where people have big gardens to land in. So potentially places where sending a delivery truck miles out of the way would be expensive (e.g. a 20 minute detour to one house). That's where the interesting applications of drone delivery are. That drone is pretty big, and they're getting extra lift out of the wings which conveniently double as prop guards. Flight time is presumably at least an hour, if it can get something to a customer in half an hour (and has to get back). You'd need quite a few since each drone can therefore only make around 10-20 deliveries a day if they swap out the batteries when it lands. 30 mile round trip range is pretty decent. Also on size - you need somewhere to land it with a few metres wriggle room either side. There's no way that's going into a built up area. There's no point doing drone delivery in urban environments, the safety case is insane and you're competing with excellent existing delivery channels.
- megablast 7y agoIt can't be worse than the cars and trucks it will replace, which kill 40,000 people every single year in the USA alone.
- vkou 7y agoHow many people do Amazon delivery drivers kill/year? Pretty sure it's not 40,000.