4 ms·
Why are the BBC quoting the BBC's opinion on this? Are the BBC making a political opinion statement about the police in another country? The BBC have always lo
by chrisseaton 7y ago
Why are the BBC quoting the BBC's opinion on this? Are the BBC making a political opinion statement about the police in another country?
The BBC have always loved to report about themselves and often literally interview themselves. It's not unusual for them to report about their own report of an interview between themselves and one of their own executives. But this is become really bizarre now.
- johneth 7y agoWhat would you think about their transparency and impartiality if they didn't report on a story they're involved in? That's why.
- chrisseaton 7y agoThey should let other people report on stories that involve themselves, obviously.
- johneth 7y agoThe BBC reporting on stories about itself doesn't stop other people from also reporting on stories about the BBC. Isn't that obvious?
- chrisseaton 7y agoI didn't say it stopped them. I know it's possible for them to do it. I said they should stop doing it. It's completely impossible to be even remotely impartial reporting yourself. Isn't that obvious?
- johneth 7y agoYou said they "should let other people report on stories that involve them", implying that somehow they could stop that. Bit of a blurry sentence. > It's completely impossible to be even remotely impartial reporting yourself. Isn't that obvious? No. It depends on the organisation. In the BBC's case, I'd say the opposite is true.
- chrisseaton 7y ago‘Should let them’ as in ‘leave it to them’ not ‘should permit them.’
- matthewmacleod 7y agoNo, it’s totally non-obvious to me that this would be the case. It seems frankly ridiculous that you would think they shouldn’t - particularly when there is no evidence whatsoever to suggest partiality in this case. The BBC news organisation often reports on statements or events affecting themselves or other parts of the organisation. Most high-quality news sources do the same. If anything, I’d actually expect them to be taking even more care than normal to avoid bias when they do so.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI disagree I’d prefer they recuse themselves, like any other professional with a potential conflict of interest would.
- happytoexplain 7y agoAn opinion is not an article. A news organization may report an opinion, factually, as part of an article, if it is relevant, even if the source of the opinion is themselves. It makes perfect sense to me.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI don't think the BBC should give any political opinion on any news story, ever. But if they want to, why don't they report the story and include their opinion straightforwardly? Why do they resort to the mental gymnastics of issuing an opinion and then reporting on that opinion as a new story as if it's a separate thing? Makes me think they know it's wrong so they contort themselves like this to do it.
- johneth 7y agoThe BBC (organisation) is giving the opinion. BBC News (an independent division within the organisation) is reporting on it, likely in the interests of full transparency. The BBC has certain obligations, one of which is "sustaining citizenship and civil society"[1], of which freedom of the press falls under. So in this case, I'd argue they're obligated to defend it by giving their opinion, especially when it's happening to a fellow public broadcaster (the ABC). [1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidelines/bbc-editorial-values/charter-and-agreement https://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidelines/bbc-edi...
- chrisseaton 7y agoTheir charter also requires them to a reflect a diversity of opinion. Literally quoting your own opinion first is the worst approach to diversity of opinion I can imagine.
- r3bl 7y agoThat's because you don't understand what "opinions" are (at least, in this context). News stories should be brief and answer "5W" questions (who, what, when, where, why). As such, they're supposed to be based on the facts alone, and others should draw their own conclusions from them. Opinions, on the other hand, are used to put the news stories into context. Journalists are supposed to have more background to the stories than you could learn from just reading the facts (since they're the ones that wrote them). That background can be used to help you interpret those facts. In this case, an incident happened. BBC put out an opinion piece to tell you why you should care about that incident before they had enough facts to answer all five of those questions. A news story links to that opinion so that they could help you with placing those answers into context.
- shusson 7y agoThe ABC was modelled after the BBC and still has a lot of similarities with the BBC [1]. It makes sense that the BBC has an opinion on this and is quoted. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_Broadcasting_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_Broadcasting_Corpor...
- Angostura 7y agoBecause the BBC News operation try and maintain an editorial firewall between itself and the rest of the corporation. In this case BBC News reporting that a UK broadcaster (the BBC) feels the attack on ABC is worrying is relevant to the story.