3 ms·
It depends on how the finding was made. If the court says that something is illegal via a direct conflict with the constitution, then no law short of a constit
by ajross 7y ago
It depends on how the finding was made. If the court says that something is illegal via a direct conflict with the constitution, then no law short of a constitutional amendment is going to be able to overrule the decision.
In these cases, though, (and I'm not a lawyer!) the existing decisions are on weaker grouns. The court held that nothing in the constitution or the legal charter of the USPTO gave it the power to allow protection for things like gene, software or business method patents. So trying to regulate them was beyond the powers granted to the government by itself.
So you fix that by writing a law spelling out more clearly what the USPTO is allowed to do.
The actual language in the constitution itself is very broad: "To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries". It's extremely hard to read a ban on gene patents in that, IMHO.