4 ms·
Instead of telling men to slow down and take care of their kids we tell women to forget about kids and follow men in their insane quest for professional conques
by refurb 7y ago
Instead of telling men to slow down and take care of their kids we tell women to forget about kids and follow men in their insane quest for professional conquests.
This is really true.
It was just assumed that the “right” goal for women was the same career focus as men have always had.
It won’t surprise me if that changes in the future once families realize the cost of it.
- bluGill 7y agoI think it will change in the future, not once families realize the cost, but because families that have already valued kids have kids while those that didn't realize the cost die out.
- watwut 7y agoThat is because men were valued more. Women and female infested things were considered lesser. Being like a girl was insult, manning up was compliment. Besides, it is not just about career and money. This forum is full of men who don't work solely for money. Who work for challenge, to feel like they can do something special, to compete, to be with collegues, because the job fits their personality well etc.
- malvosenior 7y agoIt depends. After all “women and children first” has been the historical norm. Men have been treated as disposable for the history of humanity. Men get drafted to fight wars, women don’t. > This forum is full of men who don't work solely for money. Who work for challenge, to feel like they can do something special, to compete, to be with collegues, because the job fits their personality well etc. I have a great job but definitely work for the money. I am after all enriching the founders, execs and investors. I don’t think it’s a great idea to glamorize working for someone else.
- watwut 7y agoThat was not historical norm really. It happened once on side of titanic partly and in most situations there was no ordering. Yes, men died in wars. Then you had areas with many women and less men. The men were the ones making decisions still, voting, owning property, having accounts and the ones who were supposed to be head of household and women the ones considered stupider and having less options. Male physical power and inability to be pregnant had a lot to do with most of this. Obviously. The end result was that telling men to be more like girls would amount to massive insult. It is about work and profession being super glamorous. It is about aspects of it fullfiling human psychology in small and big things that you don't even realize until you looses it.
- malvosenior 7y agoI replied in depth up thread but I don’t agree. You’re framing this in a very specific lens of a very narrow period of time and ignoring all of the negative stereotypes about men and positive stereotypes about women that existed at that time as well.
- mmsimanga 7y agoMother's Day is the biggest day for retailers. I wouldn't say that things typical mothers of yesteryear did were lesser. Speaking as a 43 year our mothers were less in the public eye but they definitely in our hearts.
- watwut 7y agoThat is not enough for men to take "you should be more like women" as compliment or inspiring ambition back then. Typical mother of yesteryear was soccer mom and it is used as insult to this day. Typical mother of yesteryear would call with friends a lot, because she spent most of time completely alone in house otherwise - and that was but of jokes often. She would make big deal over non-existent color shade differences (this might have to do with men being more likely to be colorblind). When she complained, one just knew she is oversensitive. It does not really matter how they really were and that their husbands were alright respectful guys. What matters is that there was that collective stereotype that added up to "I dont want to be like that" for many people. > Instead of telling men to slow down and take care of their kids we tell women to forget about kids and follow men in their insane quest for professional conquests. It is not just abstract us telling men and women what they should focus on out of other context. It is more that being more like women was not appealing enough proposition to average guy. That would be something emasculating, something other guys would mock. The cool guy considers feminine things stupid - regardless of whether the thing would be actually good for him. The reverse works differently. Being more like what guys do was something inspiring for enough women. Not all, but enough. The cool girl is often the one that crosses gender boundary - even when it is not actually good for her.
- malvosenior 7y agoYou’re cherry picking various stereotypes from different time periods and not including the bad stereotypes men had in the 20th century as well: the oafish dad, the wannabe player, the nerd, dumb jock... None of this says much about people’s place in the world, more that 20th century sitcoms went for easy laughs. The reality is that being a mother has always been seen as a powerful important role (because it is). It wasn’t until the late 20th century that diminished often at the hands of feminists. You seem focused on the idea that telling a man to be like a woman is an insult but for as long as I’ve been alive people have been telling men to get in touch with their sensitive side, do more duties around the house... I don’t think you’re accurately describing the big picture, just one slice of one piece of mainstream, late 20th century culture.