2 ms·
"In general, if you can think of an explanation that does away with the need for dark matter, you can also assume experts have thought hard about it and rejecte
by pmoriarty 7y ago
"In general, if you can think of an explanation that does away with the need for dark matter, you can also assume experts have thought hard about it and rejected it for good reason."
Nobel prizes have been given for explanations which were at first rejected for what seemed like good reasons at the time, but which later proved to be the wrong reasons.
The first such example which springs to mind is the explanation of helicobacter causing ulcers.
Back to astrophysics, black holes were once considered science fictional phenomena.
- jmcqk6 7y agoJust because something like this has happened in the past does not justify believing in a theory now that is following the same pattern. This is an example of survivorship bias. You have an example where this happened, but there are thousands of theories like this that didn't pan out at all.