9 ms·
"Americans sense that something is wrong with the places where we live and work"
- hsmyers 16y agoI spent almost a decade as an art major at various campus's across the US and one of the dirty secrets was that while we put up with shit from the business majors 'cause we knew better (we told them to try and sell their products in plain unmarked brown paper bags), we all snickered when anyone talked about 'talent' and 'architecture'...
- evizaer 16y agoI'm not a particularly fast reader. I'm genuinely interested in what this article may be trying to say, but there's so much lard in this writing that I had to stop reading after a few paragraphs to save myself the potential huge time loss inherent in getting through the entire thing and being disappointed by the end meaning. The writing is so full of overwrought huge abstractions and hyperbole instead of concrete fact that I can't push myself to even get halfway through it. I do share the feeling that it describes, though, about the uncaring nature of the way we seem to construct towns these days.
- gte910h 16y agoThat's what the Atlantic is like. They rarely take pieces that aren't in a similar style.
- duffbeer703 16y agoThe article is dressed up a bit because Kunstler (the author) is someone who seems to exclusively write and speak on this topic. (And by "topic", I mean says the same thing over and over and over and over again, then repeats himself.) He lives somewhere where I live near Saratoga Springs, NY, which is a late-blooming, but vivid example of the sprawl that he talks about. I've heard him speak a few times... nice guy, good points, but just like a politician on the stump, it gets tired after awhile.
- edw519 16y agoFrom September, 1996. Can the momentum of sprawl be halted? It's already started. That McMansion 40 miles from town has already lost half its value since 2006. What will it be worth when gas hits $10/gallon? Cheap energy built the sprawl; expensive energy will kill it. But things still may not play out like OP would like. In my hometown, mom and pop businesses are still being replaced by big box chains, even in town. I never thought I'd see Home Depot, Target, & Costco 3 miles from downtown. If it's too expensive to drive to the sprawl, we'll just bring the sprawl to them.
- jerf 16y agoOil is going to get expensive; there's no particular guarantee that energy is going to get expensive, though. (It will if we mindlessly continue our current policies, but expensive energy will have a way of clearing our minds about certain priorities.) And given that we're talking decadal time scales, how will "sprawl" be affected when we're using time-shared automatic-driving electric cars (and generalized transport network)? I think there's a lot of fervent hope from a lot of people that sprawl is doomed by expensive energy, but personally I rather expect that technology will end up "saving" it in the end, a further testament to the trend towards decentralization, not erasing it.
- robak 16y agoOil has had a constant price in gold and silver since 50s. So, it's not oil getting expensive, but your gauge of expensiveness (dollar) getting very cheap. Ergo, energy prices will go dramatically up == Dollar will go dramatically down. Next place to see suburbia growing is China, not US.
- usaar333 16y agoWhat feels so strange is that the price of gas matters so much, Sure a commute 40 miles each way will increase in cost from $5.33 to $13.33. But $8 seems hardly a concern when you are wasting 1.5 hours a day driving. Cheap energy is certainly necessary to create sprawl, but it isn't the only thing. Rather urban areas are often downtrodden in the US. Take a look at San Francisco, a pretty nice place by big city standards; compared to its suburbs, it has worse transportation infrastructure, worse schools, more congestion, more noise, more expensive, more danger, more pollution. The benefits win out in my 20s, but I sure wouldn't want to raise a family there.
- jazzyb 16y agoThe author of this article gave one of my favorite Ted Talks on the same topic: http://www.ted.com/talks/james_howard_kunstler_dissects_suburbia.html http://www.ted.com/talks/james_howard_kunstler_dissects_subu...
- wpeterson 16y agoI wish this TED talk were the topic rather than his older Atlantic Essay. Much better job of advancing and conveying his ideas.
- jerf 16y agoAh, yes, the classic "Deep down inside, everybody really thinks just like me" essay. I do not think everybody in America thinks just like an "architecture critic". In fact I suspect most people in America, if introduced to an "architecture critic" would say "And what's that?" If people were really upset about this, it wouldn't be happening. Alas, deep down inside, "everybody" pretty much likes what's happening.
- mech4bg 16y agoHaha exactly what I thought when I read this. Also with lines like this: >We hear this unhappiness expressed in phrases like "no sense of place" and "the loss of community." People are ALWAYS complaining about something, and usually talking about how much better something or other was (while quietly forgetting/ignoring all the problems with the previous state). Personally I think it's a pretty rad time to be alive. Something for everyone.
- mech4bg 16y agoEven more interesting, this was written in 1996 by the looks of things?
- brc 16y agoIt's a common sentiment - the essay in which the author laments how everything is wrong, because they don't agree with it. In one of the pg essays, he reflects (I'm paraphrasing from memory) how it might be lamentable how everyone prefers fast food and reality TV to Mozart and Fresh produce, but you can't call it wrong. I think pg calls this 'trying to say that up is circular or down is blue' Because if that's what people prefer, it's what they prefer. The job of people contributing to society is to provide what people want, not to try and herd people into your own vision. In a democracy, there's going to be large amounts of people who live life in a different style to your own. One of the hardest things for people as they get older is to learn to accept this and let them be. You don't have to make fun of them, or try to change them, just let them be, and ask that they leave you be as well. There are far too many people trying to boil the ocean these days and institute social changes where it isn't wanted or needed. People will adapt and change as their circumstances and tastes change. The market will follow them.
- russell 16y agoWhat the critics seem to forget is that when these wonderful places were built they were out of reach for most Americans. My grandparents did not have running water or central heating. In the cities most people, especially immigrants, lived in tenements. After WWII there was pent up saving and pent up demand. People bought cracker box houses because they were cheap and way better than what they had been living in. They bought cars, because they were affordable, enabling urban sprawl. As a kid, I lived in a farmhouse in Maine with little heat, no plumbing, no running water and cold as hell. I remember my parents drilling a well, putting in a bathroom and heat. What they and others did wasnt pretty, but in the prosperity of the times we joined the middle class.
- kemiller 16y agoMore to the point, those grand houses (not to mention, all manor of nice public works like subways in NYC) were built on the cheap labor of people who couldn't dream of owning their own home. The reason that kind of architecture became scarce in the 50's is that it became prohibitive for the merely-rich (as opposed to super-rich) to hire armies of artisans to cater to every detail.
- grellas 16y agoI grew up in a town of 80,000 in the midwestern U.S. and remember it as being completely undistinguished in terms of "character" - it had very average homes, many clustered about a fading downtown, it had light suburban sprawl, it had a meat packing plant and a lot of agricultural-related enterprises and a very few smokestack industry buildings with related infrastructure (railroad lines, etc.). It had absolutely nothing to commend it as far as "character" goes. On top of everything else, it had almost no aesthetics to speak of, being covered for much of the year in deep (and often dirty) snow blankets and drifts. Yet it had more "soul" and "community" than most of what I have experienced in living in more sophisticated places (San Francisco, Silicon Valley) in 40+ years since I moved from there as a kid. Why? Because it had great people. That is what makes "community," not buildings as ends in themselves. Now, a place like San Francisco has incredible character in many of its neighborhoods. Aesthetically, it can't be beat for those qualities that make a place special. But I would wager that the vast stretches of Silicon Valley lying south of the City contain large majorities of their residents who couldn't stand city life and far prefer the openness of the suburbs, sprawl and all. I have lived with such people for many years. They love such qualities as "safe," "quiet," "consistent" [as in quality of a neighborhood], and the like. When a Wal-Mart opens up, they are excited about the savings they will get in shopping there. And the same goes for all the other elements that we associate with "sprawl." Now, it may be spiritually consoling to some, as it is to the author, to be able to walk past and appreciate the fine qualities of old courthouses and other custom-built buildings of the past. In a free society, however, such aesthetics are always balanced against utility and, when people have a choice, they will often choose utility. Yes, we would all love to own that old Victorian that has so much character and that sells for $3 million in a cute San Francisco neighborhood but many people don't have the luxury of being able to afford such a thing, no matter how aesthetically pleasing. For some, that little house on a busy corner of an undistinguished suburban town will have to do because this gives them an affordable home in which to live and to raise their kids. Those are the kinds of homes I and my friends all grew up in and we did not think for a moment that our souls were being deprived of what we needed or that our close circle of friends somehow lacked community just because we couldn't run with the snob crowd. I think an article like this reflects one legitimate way of looking at life but it is a mistake to project this view on society at large. While the author's viewpoint might be seen as commendable from an idealistic perspective of how things ought to be, I would guess there are few people who consciously think this way in living their day-to-day lives. A vast number of them have lived many years in such places as "plastic city" (what San Jose has been called for years) and not given even a second thought about the alleged deadening of their souls as a result of that experience.
- Umalu 16y agoFor a different perspective on this, check out "The Grass is Indeed Greener: How I gave up dreaming about the big city and learned to love the suburbs". http://architectureandmorality.blogspot.com/2010/10/grass-is-indeed-greener-how-i-stopped.html http://architectureandmorality.blogspot.com/2010/10/grass-is...
- Mz 16y agoSemi-abandoned dream of mine was to go into urban planning or something related. So I have an interest in the built environment that goes back a few years. Surprising and eye-opening occurrence in my life: I gave up my car closing in on three years ago. Me and my two adult sons do a lot of walking locally. Walking has caught on in my neighborhood, in spite of a lack of a side-walks and huge undeveloped tracts of land and other types of discouragements. With more people walking locally, the local air is cleaner and the plant life is healthier...etc...which seems to encourage more people to walk. The neighborhood also seems to have gotten safer, this based on certain subjective impressions but also on the fact that we no longer get police cars staking out the entrance to our apartment complex, which was a routine thing when we first lived here. Anyway, how people behave is apparently less dependent upon the built environment than I thought and that behavior is important in building the fabric of community. People know each other more now and are friendlier and the streets are safer...etc. The neighborhood has changed a good bit in the time I have been here.
- stretchwithme 16y agoThe buildings that survive are the ones we are left to look at. And in such a young, rapidly expanding country, a far smaller percentage of the buildings are old, even if every one of them had survived.
- japherwocky 16y agoSo much of what this guy rambles about is so moot to anyone who's ever actually worked in the building industry. Why is he even qualified to have this opinion? The premise that buildings "nowadays" are universally cheap and inferior is stupid: There have always been shitty buildings that don't last, because poor people also need homes. Cheap buildings today are significantly better protection against the elements than shacks from the "good old days". I agree with the spirit of the articles, so I guess I don't care (Yes, we should encourage people to spend more money in the building industry! Yes, hire a local artisan to make something!), but I think an economic argument is more compelling than an emotional one.
- grantheaslip 16y ago> There have always been shitty buildings that don't last, because poor people also need homes. (Haven't read the article yet) That's probably where his mistake came from. He's judging the buildings of the past by the ones that are around now, which are (by nature of the fact that they still exist) higher quality. All of the shoddily-constructed ones are gone now. Textbook selection bias.
- whatusername 16y agoThankyou for that. I've been a bit on the 'good-old-days' side about Buildings and completely forgot about survivorship bias. Just like all the music these days is crap (when we compare to only the best songs that we remember from 30 years ago). I think there might be something in the idea that we did it 'better' for public buildings in the old days (Are there any buildings that cost remotely the amount of National GDP that the Pyramids or the Great Wall did?) -- But I think you're absolutely right when thinking about averages.
- jacques_chester 16y agoLabour used to be much cheaper. The master builders could afford to build beautiful buildings with twiddly adornments. Where I was living earlier this year was near Guildford, in Perth, Australia. Not far away is the old Midland Rail Yard. The site is dominated by three giant industrial sheds built for rail engine maintenance. Internally they look much like any 1900s factory, with brute thick walls to support fixed cranes and fantastic natural light from 2-story wall windows and sawtooth roof windows. Outside the brickwork is formed into lovely arches with tasteful adornments. All in all these utterly functional buildings are beautiful. (Only half-decent photo I could find online: http://www.flickr.com/photos/sengster/134135743/in/photostream/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/sengster/134135743/in/photostre...) Today you could not justify the cost. Brickwork of that kind takes too long and so costs serious money; windows like those allow too much heat in. So instead we get lego buildings, giant concrete cubes without soul or feeling. Where the money is spent these days is no longer on craftsmanship, it's on wanktastic monuments to some puffed up architect's desire to win an architecture award. Go find a building in your city that has won any such award since the 60s. Dollars to donuts it is ugly and impractical.
- powera 16y ago"Labour used to be much cheaper." - with 10% unemployment in the US (that's higher if you use more accurate measures), I'm not quite sure why the reason for this would be a lack of available labor.
- jacques_chester 16y agoI didn't say "lack of labour", I said "cost of labour".
- kgermino 16y agoUnfortunately with modern day unions and minimum wage laws high unemployment doesn't translate into lower wages, at least not for craftsmen.
- snth 16y agoOne of the things the author doesn't mention is fire codes. I assume this is one of the reasons buildings are built further back from the road, and also one of the reasons that catastrophic, city-demolishing fires are a thing of the past in the U.S.
- mhb 16y agoCounterpoint: http://www.metropolismag.com/html/content_0898/aug98wha.htm http://www.metropolismag.com/html/content_0898/aug98wha.htm
- enjo 16y agoThe complaints in that article mostly stem from systemic problems with abandoned city cores. In areas that have seen large-scale gentrification the schools have predictably seen similar increases in achievement. Crime tends to follow a similar trajectory. What he's describing the headache that comes with being an urban 'pioneer'. I'll also take exception with gems like: Nobody lays in their bed in Plano and hears gunshots half a mile away. Except that they do. I still own a house in Plano (in the most suburban 'safest' part), and in the year in a half that we lived there (2005-2007) we: * had a neighbor (3 houses down) forced at gunpoint back into their house, tied up, and robbed blind. All happened in broad daylight. * had a gun-fight in the parking lot across the street from our development * had multiple muggings and car-jackings all within close proximity of our house.
- akgerber 16y agoThe places we currently build are by no means the product of a free market. Automobile-based transportation is heavily subsidized both through direct taxation paying for automobile-optimized roads as well as minimum parking requirements that essentially proscribe building anything resembling a walkable neighborhood in many cities. And those requirements mean that anyone who doesn't drive to a business is forced to share in the cost of providing parking for a business (which can be tens of thousands of dollars a parking space). It's also quite rare for a business to ask employees to pay for parking or to give any money back to employees that don't use free parking.
- erikpukinskis 16y agoThe problem goes much deeper. Everything we consider culture--architecture, holidays, leisure activities, beauty standards, music, movies, career norms--have evolved over the last fifty years to exploit us most efficiently for cash. Our culture no longer cares about us. It exists only to fuel "economic growth". I'm sorry if this seems reactionary or trollish. It is my true belief.
- elblanco 16y agoOne of the problems is that there are actually relatively few big cities in the U.S. that also have the quality of being nice places to live. Most of them are huge (or formerly huge) manufacturing centers, populated by people looking for unskilled jobs. Cities are generally built as "nice places to live", they arise because cities are efficient nodes for economic exchanges to take place. Some urban areas have almost no housing at all! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tysons_Corner,_Virginia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tysons_Corner,_Virginia Outside of parts of New York, SF, Seattle (and maybe 2 or 3 others), most urban centers are high crime dumps with the additional quality of being frighteningly expensive to live in and then completely surrounded by vast heavy industrial wastelands. Don't get me wrong, I'd give my left leg to live in NYC at the standard of living I have in boring suburbia. But back of the envelope calculations show I'd have to make 3-7x what I make now. At least the nice folks that built my suburb designed it with a walkable layout to a commercial town-center stocked with everything from a Gym and Movie theater to a dozen restaurants and groceries so I can pretend I live there. Most people who write this kind of stuff really don't mean "people should live in cities"...what they really mean is "people should live in city (singular), and that city should be NYC or SF (or Seattle in some cases)".
- cturner 16y ago"Even the best streets in the world's best towns can accommodate people of various incomes." I wonder how the author can say this with a straight face. The only way to prevent clumping into income groups is through the dystopian planning law - which he claims elsewhere to criticise. If people see cheap housing near where they're friends live, they'll buy it and convert it, and it becomes expensive housing.
- Symmetry 16y agoReally? If you consider that more poeple would be living in and paying rent for the cheap housing than for the expensive housing it isn't obvious that this would all go one way. I don't think that we can or should try to totally eliminate the variations in income among neighborhoods, but we can stop passing laws that make it worse.
- qaexl 16y agoSteve Blank wrote an article http://steveblank.com/2010/11/24/when-its-darkest-men-see-the-stars/ http://steveblank.com/2010/11/24/when-its-darkest-men-see-th... on why the traditional barriers of entry for businesses, particularly Internet-based businesses, are -simultaneously- falling down ... at the same time that a large number of recent-collage grads are entering the workforce in the middle of recession, with the real estate market still crashing around us. It means that not only is it easier to start your own business, many people are forced to.
- qaexl 16y agoWow. Hacker News ate my text. Let's try this again. Steve Blank wrote an article http://steveblank.com/2010/11/24/when-its-darkest-men-see-the-stars/ http://steveblank.com/2010/11/24/when-its-darkest-men-see-th... on why the traditional barriers of entry for businesses, particularly Internet-based businesses, are -simultaneously- falling down ... at the same time that a large number of recent-collage grads are entering the workforce in the middle of recession, with the real estate market still crashing around us. It means that not only is it easier to start your own business, many people are forced to. Indeed, http://www.fastcompany.com/1707431/the-rise-of-the-homepreneurs http://www.fastcompany.com/1707431/the-rise-of-the-homeprene... talks about the "homepreneurs", having home-based business. One interesting thing reading this and reading the interviews in Founders At Work was that many of the tech founds then and the founds now say that it is much more acceptable now to operate a business from the home than it was say, in 1980. The idea of a garage-based business in Palo Alto is the stuff of legends, but the reality was that in mind 1970s, 1980s, even the early 1990s, you don't get as much credibility with a home-based business. With the number of big IPOs and "rags-to-riches" stories, garage-based businesses are more acceptable. So is the fact that people can rent Class-A digs to woo customers and investors. But think about this in the context of that Atlantic article. The article talks about how the traditional mixed-use neighborhoods wove residential with commercial concerns. Someone living in a traditional neighborhood could get all of their basic living needs by walking, all within a 5 minute walk. In other words, it -seems- that a "home-based" business is more acceptable in the present than in the past, but dig deeper into a past when towns were planned around neighborhoods instead of zones, and you see this is actually an American tradition. What's different now is that the barriers of entry are falling particularly for web-based businesses. People outside of IT -- and even inside IT -- don't know this, but virtualization has changed the game since 2005. In late 1990s, the cost for setting up your server and a landline was in the tens of thousands. In 2005, it has dropped into the thousands, and probably less. With virtualization now, we're talking about ~$10/mth for base cost; expert labor costs much more than the servers themselves. Even product-based businesses operate virtually now, as described in Tim Ferris's Four Hour Workweek. Product fulfillment can be outsourced to competent firms. So are product design and marketing. Just-in-time inventory has made its way to small businesses, so there isn't a need to warehouse inventory yourself. My point is that the numbers of people with a non-traditional job -- that is, unless you look all the past 1920s when it was traditional to own your own business -- can fly under the radar of zoning laws. And further, there will be an increasing demand and pressure for traditionally-planned, neighborhood-based communities. I don't think homepreneurs want to live in surburbia. I have friends who drive out to the local coffee shop, to get their socialization while "working from home". And if that coffee shop was instead a pleasant, 5-minute walk away?