5 ms·
> The underlying issue here in this one is that people (apparently so far!) want to use AWS/GCP/etc more than they want to use mongo, redis, cockroach, or any p
by kelnos 7y ago
> The underlying issue here in this one is that people (apparently so far!) want to use AWS/GCP/etc more than they want to use mongo, redis, cockroach, or any particular technology.
There's nothing stopping people from using BSL-licensed software on AWS/GCP/etc., as long as they aren't running it for the purposes of offering a hosted version of that software. And Amazon/Google/etc. still really wants to offer hosted CockroachDB, they can purchase a license, which helps fund development, and would probably be a financial rounding error to an outfit like AWS.
> Unless something comes along that is "better enough" that people are willing to buck AWS to use it, this approach of relicensing fails.
> (and the customers certainly don't care about your licensing scheme)
I think you're misinterpreting how this license works and what it actually restricts, or you've overestimated the number of users this will affect. Most customers don't have to care; for the common use ("I want to install CockroachDB on AWS/GCP/my own server and use it as a data store for my product"), the licensing change is immaterial and they can use the software in the same way as they could when it was Apache-licensed.
The only way this backfires is if Amazon creates a clean-room CockroachDB workalike and offers it as a hosted service. Even then, it's not a slam dunk: for example, I'd very much prefer to run redis myself on bare EC2 instances than use AWS ElastiCache, as the latter just generally doesn't meet my availability requirements. I've also once migrated a service from redis to DynamoDB and had a terrible experience during and after, so switching to a theoretical workalike isn't without its costs and risks.
- freeone3000 7y ago> There's nothing stopping people from using BSL-licensed software on AWS/GCP/etc., as long as they aren't running it for the purposes of offering a hosted version of that software. There is. This is no longer an OSI license, which means it's no longer on the automatic whitelist. Using CockroachDB now requires running through legal, which really makes me reconsider just using the hosted whatever offering, despite the issues.
- foobiekr 7y agothat's kind of a "for now" issue. eventually these will become common enough that things will shake out, but it will take years.
- tolmasky 7y agoHasn’t happened for GPL3, and I would bet it won’t happen for these either. More importantly, the one-click solutions offered by amazon, GCP, etc. will always be the GPL2/MIT/etc licensed products, while the others will require you to either install and manage on your own, or sign up separately outside your main cloud provider. This will be an additional point of friction (potentially more so than the licensing woes).
- amenod 7y agoI wouldn't be so sure of that. For AWS it is risky to not support popular platforms, because it gives their customers a reason to move elsewhere. AWS is not the only cloud provider around (and certainly not the cheapest). There is a reason they developed an alternative to MongoDB instead of just saying "sorry, we don't support MongoDB because of license". They couldn't buy a license from them because that would set a bad example (they are not really fond of these alternative licenses) and they probably didn't want to maintain MongoDB codebase (before relicensing), so this was the only solution left.
- dragonwriter 7y agoNo, it's fairly inherent; the OSD is very well aligned with the considerations that would support whitelisting licenses that adhere to it.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> The only way this backfires is if Amazon creates a clean-room CockroachDB workalike and offers it as a hosted service. Or offers a managed service of one of the open source products competing in the same space. Or acquires one of the existing proprietary alternatives and offers it as a managed service. Perhaps even while paying Cockroach’s license fees, offering the most popular hosted Cockroach, and still encouraging customers to shift over time to lower-cost alternatives (Amazon already does this with Windows and SQL Server; no one trick pony first-party SaaS platform is going to be anywhere near what Microsoft has deployed against AWS.)