5 ms·
It appears this would block pretty much all the major analytics tracking cookies (e.g. Google analytics, mixpanel, etc.) based on the linked Disconnect list, ht
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
It appears this would block pretty much all the major analytics tracking cookies (e.g. Google analytics, mixpanel, etc.) based on the linked Disconnect list, https://disconnect.me/trackerprotection https://disconnect.me/trackerprotection .
While I realize that's kind of the point, in my mind there is somewhat of a difference between "the site I'm on is tracking me to figure out how I use their site" vs. "any site I visit is essentially aggregated data because all the sites use the same major trackers and ad networks". I wonder if the big analytics companies will need to change their business model, or at least their tech, to account for these kinds of changes.
- flattone 7y agoThat is so well stated. I think from a pure interested user perspective the bottom line is I don't care what happens to anything as long as I'm not tracked/measured etc. Find another way or just get lucky with the correct mixture of creativity and hiring. My web browsing does not exist for companies to exist.
- jeena 7y agoThey could ask me how I use their site, instead of giving the data about every step I do to 3rd parties.
- creato 7y agoPeople that respond to such questions surely are a very biased sample of the overall user base.
- chris_wot 7y agoSo let's make more people respond to such questions. The answer is not to say "it's biased" but to fix the core issue.
- cortesoft 7y agoNo. I hate those questions and don't want to answer them. Just let me use your site and figure out what works from there. You can still have analytics with this Firefox change, you just have to use your own domain for the cookies.
- cortesoft 7y agoYou mean like those survey pop ups that come up halfway through an article? I hate those. Those have caused more suffering for me than 3rd party tracking.
- reissbaker 7y agoUnfortunately, many common adblockers also block first-party tracking where your data is only being sent to the company whose site you're interacting with. For example, I know that uBlock Origin blocks Airbnb's tracking code on the Airbnb website — even though it just sends data back to Airbnb-owned domains.
- mobjack 7y agoIt looks like these changes only affect third party cookies, while most analytics software relies on first party cookies. These changes make it harder for analytics companies to track users across domains, but still allows site owners to analyze their own traffic.
- SimeVidas 7y agoI had to check on my site but yes. Google Analytics cookies (they start with “_g”) are set on the website’s domain.
- rhaksw 7y ago> this would block pretty much all the major analytics The list [1], which includes many APIs, also breaks hundreds of websites [2] that access those APIs [1] https://github.com/disconnectme/disconnect-tracking-protection/blob/master/services.json https://github.com/disconnectme/disconnect-tracking-protecti... [2] https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1101005 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1101005
- hansen 7y agoI doubt there are many users out there who care if someones analytics stuff breaks.