7 ms·
This was inevitable. As I said two years ago[1], just listen to Kik's own words: "When we looked at raising another round [of VC funding], we asked ourselves h
by modeless 7y ago
This was inevitable. As I said two years ago[1], just listen to Kik's own words:
"When we looked at raising another round [of VC funding], we asked ourselves how do we answer the question about how we will become a profitable business [...] We didn’t have an answer we really believed."
... so instead they decided to raise money from unsophisticated investors in an unregulated market, where nobody asks such inconvenient questions! No surprise that the SEC is upset.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15245656 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15245656
- colechristensen 7y agoThe regulations indeed exist because fraud in this vein was prevalent and it made it difficult to compete if you weren't defrauding investors.
- conanbatt 7y agoPlease, thats ridiculous. It exists as a moat that punishes some and benefits another at the cost of the tax payer and the common investor.
- CryptoPunk 7y agoDo you have any evidence for that? There are other ways of addressing fraud besides violating people's right to freely contract with other consenting adults, like punishing those who commit fraud to deter others from committing the crime, and public education campaigns. The idea that the government has a right to deem a certain class of investors as "unsophisticated", and thus better off deprived of the right to decide for themselves what to invest in, and prohibit an entire class of interactions, on the basis that too many instances of that class are fraudulent, upends basic principles of liberal society. The poorest households in the US spend 9% of their income on lottery tickets, showing that you can't legislate people out of misusing their funds. If anything, the attempt to do so deprives them of better investment opportunities, and better opportunities to learn how the investment world works. And this isn't free market idealism. The crypto/token investment market has become vastly more sophisticated over the last 4 years. Token sales that would have raised millions 4 years get nothing today. People need to have a bit more faith in other people, and in freedom.
- alanh 7y agonot to be that guy, but… username checks out! (inb4 hn is turning into reddit)
- CryptoPunk 7y agoYea I believe that consensual interactions, whether it's in the civil sphere, with high-risk sexual practices, or the economic sphere, with high-risk investments, should not face any government prohibition.
- workingpatrick 7y agoI'd argue that for the interaction to be truly consensual, both parties must be fully informed about the risks and rewards of the interaction that they are choosing to participate in. My reading of the SEC press release leads me to believe that the primary reason for requiring filing with the SEC for a sale of this nature is to ensure that all relevant information is available for the parties involved, thus allowing the interaction to be truly consensual.
- CryptoPunk 7y agoYou don't prohibit an entire class of interactions, and then approve them on a case-by-case basis when the centralized authority deems that the interaction is consensual. Approval-encumbered interaction is not consistent with how free society works, where people are presumed innocent, and not burdened with restrictions, until proven guilty. Speech used to be like that. You had to get approval from the state, before being allowed to publish. This was to prevent things like libel. It was called Prior Restraint. Eventually courts ruled it violated the Freedom of Speech, and we are all vastly better for that ruling. In practice it's also not flexible enough for innovation. It regiments only one acceptable way to establish an informed and consensual interaction, which precludes innovative new ways opened up by technology.
- james_s_tayler 7y agowe ran that experiment in 2017 and everyone got rekt
- Simple_Guy 7y agoalternatively, you can just let it run for a few years and the bad investors would run out of money and we are back to business again.
- ip26 7y agoA refreshing perspective compared to the usual HN "it's your fault (& no one else's) that you got defrauded on Kickstarter" position.
- pfisch 7y agoI mean it is generally your fault when you get scammed and your money is gone. Unless they scammed a third party who gave your money away. That is an entirely different can of worms. It is also the scammers fault for scamming, and they face their own set of consequences. I also think there is this bizarre double talk on HN where people say sophisticated investor status shouldn't be a thing while also condemning ICOs, which is exactly what happens when sophisticated investor status isn't a thing.
- jjeaff 7y agoOn a side note, I wish the term, "sophisticated investor" wasn't the official one. It's a misnomer because it implies there is some kind of knowledge or skill threshold required. What it really means is "has enough money they can afford to lose some". In reality, there are plenty of people who have tons of money and not a clue how to invest it well.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> I wish the term, "sophisticated investor" wasn't the official one It's not. "Accredited investor" is the official term. "Sophisticated investor" is a higher finance-colloquial bar, typically requiring one follow institutional best practices (e.g. legal and risk reviews).
- microcolonel 7y agoI hardly find that perspective “the usual [on] HN”.
- dang 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20078347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20078347
- tx-0 7y ago> just listen to Kik's own words if they had raised money by telling a story that they didn't believe to the VC's to raise money from the VC's, then they would have been guilty of something by their own words: but they didn't, and their point in saying that was they did not do that. Instead, they pivoted... The money they raised in the ICO has the SEC upset, but not for the reason your example refers to, but simply for lack of registration.
- willart4food 7y agoLOL
- boh 7y agoWhat's unbelievable is the lack of sophistication on Kik's part. Any lawyer working for them should've responded immediately to this statement (and their general nonchalance about the issue) and advised to shut the ICO down immediately. You literally can't make this any easier for the SEC. There's not much of a defense when you repeatedly admit that you're attempting to raise money by issuing something you market as an investment opportunity.