3 ms·
It never ceases to amaze me the trust that the tech industry has in both the competence and the benevolence of the government.
by scarface74 7y ago
It never ceases to amaze me the trust that the tech industry has in both the competence and the benevolence of the government.
- pwinnski 7y agoI don't think that the government is generally competent or benevolent, but I am 100% sure that the tech industry is not benevolent, and that bothers me in direct proportion to their competence.
- enraged_camel 7y agoFurthermore, with government, there is at least some notion of accountability. Imperfect as it may be, generally speaking when people in government fuck up, they have to deal with repercussions and consequences. Furthermore, there are mechanisms such as FOIA that any citizen or organization can utilize to find out if and when those fuck ups happen, as well. Big Tech though is basically a closed black box that has immense power and is almost totally unregulated. This leaves an incredible amount of room for abuse. Therefore, I am totally okay with a semi-competent, sometimes-benevolent entity that is accountable to the public (government) to much more tightly regulate this industry.
- scarface74 7y agoPeople don't vote based on monopolies and privacy. Politicians can get away with all matter of things if they appeal to the electorate's baser instincts and prejudices. EDIT: "Prejudices" don't necessarily mean race, religion, etc. It also could be "evil capitalist" vs "evil socialist" or "baby killing war monger" vs "peace loving hippy". And giving more power to the government couldn't possibly lead to abuse.....
- bko 7y ago> generally speaking when people in government fuck up, they have to deal with repercussions and consequences. Re-election rates for congressmen over the years hovers at around 90%. Senators are around 85%. Perhaps they're all doing a great job, but I'm skeptical https://www.opensecrets.org/overview/reelect.php https://www.opensecrets.org/overview/reelect.php
- bko 7y agoIt's a lot easier for me to switch phones or services than it is for me to switch jurisdictions.
- _bxg1 7y agoThe government is at least supposed to serve the populace, even if it has a spotty record of actually doing so. Corporations, on the other hand, don't even have to pretend to have society's best interests in mind.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- scarface74 7y agoGovernment doesn't serve the populace - they serve geography. A person living in California has far less national voting power than someone living in Rhode Island or Middle America since each state has two Senators regardless of their size and the Electoral College favors smaller states. Congressional districts even for representatives mean you have more voting power if you're in rural areas than if you live in major cities. Middle America and the Bible Belt don't vote based on tech issues.....
- raverbashing 7y agoOh you mean the US government then And you're absolutely right, and if California has an issue with that they can push for changes or even for their separation from the US (taxation without enough representation and all that).
- minikites 7y agoIt never ceases to amaze me the trust that tech workers have in both the competence and the benevolence of capitalism.
- scarface74 7y agoWell seeing that tech workers are benefiting from capitalism why wouldn't they trust it? What's the alternative? If you have a household income over $60K (the national average), are you willing to give everything over $60K up to make things more "fair"? Yes I'm all for the social safety net.
- ianstallings 7y agoDo you think that government ownership would lead to more competence and benevolence? If so, just visit the inside of any government agency.
- techsupporter 7y ago> If so, just visit the inside of any government agency. How is this still a retort? OF COURSE MANY GOVERNMENT AGENCIES SUCK. That is the direct result of fifty-plus years of "government is terrible, elect us and we'll prove it." Even some of our more popular agencies are so underfunded they can barely do their original mission, much less the aspirational stuff we want of them. NASA says it'll take--pulling numbers out of thin air--$10 billion to reliably go to the moon. Our electeds' response is "you can have $3 billion" and then we complain that NASA hasn't sent anybody to the moon yet. Never mind this patchwork of responsibility where virtually everything is no one's actual fault or job. The much-complained-about Department of Motor Vehicles is, in various states, operated as an independent entity, part of the department of transportation, part of an agency that handles licenses for everything that needs a license, or simply just kind of happens. There's no one whose job it is to say "this thing needs to work well" and since everyone doesn't like it, it doesn't command any kind of respect for being paid properly. And then speaking of paid properly, why on Flying Spaghetti Monster's Earth would someone go to work for a state or local government and get paid, especially in tech, on average about two thirds of what he or she could be making in the so-called "private sector," or go to work for the Federal government and not only have the same wage penalty but ALSO be subjected to random "well, we couldn't get our heads out of our ass so you're not getting paid for anywhere from one to one hundred days, sorry" instances. "Just visit the inside of any government agency" my shiny metal ass; we MADE this problem and now we kick dirt at it as though decades of voters bitching about government haven't gotten us exactly the front-line government services we deserve as a consequence of those votes.