7 ms·
Doesn't everyone publicly look forward to proving their case in court when the inevitable legal battle is obvious? Not many folks say "Oh man I don't want the
by duxup 7y ago
Doesn't everyone publicly look forward to proving their case in court when the inevitable legal battle is obvious?
Not many folks say "Oh man I don't want the SEC to sue me, I'm gonna get creamed in court!"
- nostrademons 7y agoA lot of people think it, but if you're thinking it the last thing you want to do is publicize that and invite people (particularly the SEC) to ask "Why don't you want the SEC to sue you?" A number of smaller ICOs just settled with the SEC and refunded the money to investors when they got a Wells Notice. Those are all the folks who said "Oh man I don't want the SEC to sue me, I'm gonna get creamed in court." Kik is different in that they have deep pockets, strong legal counsel, and a product that's been out there for 8 years.
- duxup 7y agoWell a messenger app for 8 years, but that's not really what the lawsuit is about.
- nostrademons 7y agoThey want to add payments to their messenger app. That's a known business model and a hot area right now - WeChat pioneered it, Line does it too, and Facebook is working on a cryptocurrency-based solution that does the same thing.
- dmix 7y agoThe rewards could be huge if payments via messaging apps takes off in the west. It's really too bad WhatsApp sold to Facebook of all places. We could have a privacy-oriented chat platform with a cryptocurrency "small cash" type of transaction system built on top. Combined with some informal craigslist style mini-stores, which flourished in China via Wechat. I'm sure FB/WhatsApp could do it via normal payment channels, probably involving Visa/Mastercard. But the privacy story is awful for such a critical piece of software. Assuming they could pull it off. Maybe Kik could take up the privacy flag? WSJ made a nice video of how Chinese people live "cashless" via WeChat in Shenzen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=75AXINUL47g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=75AXINUL47g
- duxup 7y ago"Maybe Kik could take up the privacy flag?" I feel like most services that aim to replace another one ... just want that information for their own purposes, not the customer's benefit.
- southerndrift 7y agoIf you think the WhatsApp situation is sad, start thinking about Skype and Paypal.
- shyneeup 7y agoDon't know enough about crypto, but whats the benefit of a payment system for messenger apps to run on crypto at all? If you're transacting through a centralized messaging platform doesnt that defeat the purpose of a decentralized currency or ledger?
- solotronics 7y agoIt would open up ways to get money into and out of your chat app with less friction.
- nostrademons 7y agoAlso saves you from the "How do I know you won't run off with the money?" and "What happens if Kik goes out of business?" questions. The value of a blockchain is that your digital tokens exist independently of the sponsoring organization, so the sponsoring organization cannot just alter or shutdown their database to make your funds go poof. Granted, if Kik went bust tomorrow those tokens would most likely have no value, since their use is tied to Kik's messenger app. But in theory you would still own the tokens and could transfer them to anyone who would accept them.
- mountainofdeath 7y agoThat's only true in the case where the underlying cyptocurrency is actually accepted outside the platform. In theory, if your app is transacting money, it keeps the equivalent cash in an insured bank account which is exactly how PayPal and similar work. If it's not widely accepted, it's basically the same as in-game tokens/currency. Speaking of in-game tokens, people have used them for the same purpose of cryptocurrency e.g. capital flight and money laundering.
- itake 7y agotrue, but their primary user base is teens that barely have a credit card.
- basch 7y agoFBMessenger already has best in class payments built in, without crypto.
- JackFr 7y ago> Kik is different in that they have deep pockets, strong legal counsel, and a product that's been out there for 8 years. Except they don't. The only money they have is from an unregistered sale of securities which was only undertaken because they HAD NO MONEY. Their product costs more to run than it makes, and is irrelevant to the SEC lawsuit.
- at-fates-hands 7y ago> The only money they have is from an unregistered sale of securities which was only undertaken because they HAD NO MONEY. Don't you think this would come out at trial? Sounds like the only reason they came out with an unregistered ICO was in order to generate revenue it needed to continue operating. That's a huge red flag for me if I'm an SEC investigator
- solotronics 7y agoI am not sure if this is a legitimate argument because you can apply the same logic to Uber and Tesla.
- greglindahl 7y agoUber and Tesla sold traditional securities to accredited investors, the same way that everyone else normally does.
- MagnumOpus 7y agoExcept that they confirmed to laws and SEC regs and Kik didn't? That makes all the difference...
- nostrademons 7y agoUber "conformed to laws" is rich considering HN commentary on that company over the last 8 years... (To be fair, the SEC is pretty much the one government agency that Uber did not piss off - it's just the IRS, FBI, DoJ, and almost every local government in America that they're in trouble with.)
- will_brown 7y agoIf that was the case Kik wouldn’t have spent an alleged $5M unsuccessfully trying to settle this matter. No most people don’t raise a $100M in violation of securities law...or even “testing” security laws, especially when Kik could have obtained the SECs opinion through a No Action Letter request. Why didn’t Kik avail themselves to the law and process before raising $100M from the public?
- mindcandy 7y ago<Remember Bitcoin came out in 2009> Patrick Gibbs: > First of all, you have to consider the SEC’s normal process for that sort of thing. It is very difficult and it takes a very, very, very long time for the SEC to give that kind of forward-looking advice, usually in the form of a no action letter. I mean, here we are in 2019 and they have only just recently released what I think is the very first no action letter relating to a cryptocurrency and that matter has been pending for well over a year. > So it’s not practicable in a business that’s moving as quickly as this business was in 2016, 2017, to go and ask the SEC for a no action letter like that because the process just takes too long, and in a situation where in our view it’s quite clear that what we were doing is outside the scope of the SEC’s authority, we don’t generally think we have to go and ask the SEC’s permission to engage in business activity that is outside the scope of their authority. https://unchainedpodcast.com/kin-sets-up-5-million-defendcrypto-org-to-take-on-the-sec/ https://unchainedpodcast.com/kin-sets-up-5-million-defendcry...
- will_brown 7y ago>Patrick Gibbs: First your citing the Cooley attorney who advised the company...of course he is going to justify his own legal advice. It’s not going to look good when the court determines Kik knew if could have sought clarification from the SEC but didnt Because the SEC no Action Letter process wasn’t practical. Let’s also keep in mind Cooley is the Firm that developed the SAFT (security agreement for future tokens) released their SAFT whitepaper into the wild telling startups to use their SAFT legal framework to raise money with ICOs legally and these are some of the first companies the SEC targeted for enforcement actions.
- Shivetya 7y agoHere is the deal though, the SEC employs administrative law judges (ALJs) who even the President cannot remove and generally are immune electoral control and accountability The SEC also enforces gag orders on settlements to hide the proceedings and discovery from the public which only allows them to continue their abuses of the system. A common thread among SEC settlements, also in CFTC and CTFB settlements is summed up from a recent SEC agreement "mak[ing] any public statement denying, directly or indirectly, any allegation in the [SEC’s] complaint or creating the impression that the complaint is without factual basis" So basically you have no recourse against government agencies whose quasi legal status pretty much makes them immune to the checks and balances as specified in courts. If you want a closer to home comparison, FISA courts operate pretty much the same way. There is no disclosure other than what the government wants you to know and they have the full resources of the US government to take you down, the common tactic is to bankrupt individuals or threaten it to get the deals they want.
- duxup 7y agoThis isn't anything like FISA.... that is a bizarre comparison.
- wbl 7y agoYou can always appeal an ALJ order to federal court where it is reviewed de novo.
- Animats 7y agoHuh? Most SEC settlements are public. The SEC issues a press release. Here's a typical one.[1] As for settlements with the terms "mak[ing] any public statement denying, directly or indirectly, any allegation in the [SEC’s] complaint or creating the impression that the complaint is without factual basis", that's what pleading guilty looks like in a civil enforcement matter. You can't say "yes, we did it, and we'll pay the penalty rather than going to trial" to the SEC, and then turn around and say publicly "we didn't do it".
- village-idiot 7y agoIn my opinion it’s a bit like hearing the accused proclaim their innocence. My response is always “well yeah, everyone declares that they’re innocent”.