3 ms·
Why not paint the satellites black on the bottom?
by whatshisface 7y ago
Why not paint the satellites black on the bottom?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jgrahamc 7y agoHeat? They are shining because they are reflecting sunlight. Now paint them black and have them warm up. They then have to dissipate the excess heat in a vacuum...
- Faark 7y agoYou're overly simplifying, but this musk tweet [0] can indeed be read as going somewhat in that direction. [0] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1132908689860415488 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1132908689860415488
- kijin 7y agoI'm not sure which is worse, a shiny satellite that screams where it is (so you can avoid it) or a dark satellite that silently blocks a patch of the sky.
- sigstoat 7y agothe shiny one. because telescopes aren't in the habit of avoiding shiny things; they use the databases of where all of this stuff is and do the math to figure out where it will be. the dark objects at least won't introduce extra photons into the optics to refract around, when they're in your field of view but not obstructing the thing you were actually trying to look at.
- Robotbeat 7y agoBy far the shiny satellite is worse. Besides, the satellites are tracked carefully by multiple parties, so any serious astronomical observation that could even theoretically be sensitive to a sub-millisecond obscuration of a ~microradian portion of the sky (such as certain exoplanet searches) would be well aware of this ahead of time (and atmospheric aberration would be a far greater effect). A dark satellite is effectively irrelevant to optical ground astronomy.
- mncharity 7y agoGeneralizing, you're asking the "obvious" question: "these are first-run prototypes, and short-lived, so why not mitigate the brightness in future?" And yes, SpX has said they plan to get telescope images to determine the bright bits, and to do the right thing. On the meta question, of why societal discussion is so far from sane... Well, there are perverse incentives... And it's not like our profession has spent the last few decades working diligently to improve discussion tooling... we've done almost nothing on it at all.
- mncharity 7y agoOn a more upbeat note, Wikum[1] is an example of summarizing threaded discussion (like HN), and Tilda[2] of tagging chat (like Slack). In addition to absorption (painting it "black"), one can also scatter (spread it out), and deflect (shine somewhere you don't care about), shadow, and mask, and otherwise change geometry to change light paths. Optical stealthing of satellites is a thing, with somewhat limited accessible literature. Though there is some[3], seemingly mostly Chinese. [1] http://wikum.csail.mit.edu/ http://wikum.csail.mit.edu/ has examples like http://wikum.csail.mit.edu/visualization_flags?id=23&owner=None http://wikum.csail.mit.edu/visualization_flags?id=23&owner=N... and http://wikum.csail.mit.edu/visualization_flags?id=20&owner=None http://wikum.csail.mit.edu/visualization_flags?id=20&owner=N... [2] https://people.csail.mit.edu/axz/tilda.html https://people.csail.mit.edu/axz/tilda.html [3] https://www.mdpi.com/2079-6412/9/3/193/htm https://www.mdpi.com/2079-6412/9/3/193/htm