3 ms·
Isn't DNA comparison between species supposed to get some idea of what came first? Shouldn't we be able to answer Which Came First, feathers or flight?
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
Isn't DNA comparison between species supposed to get some idea of what came first? Shouldn't we be able to answer Which Came First, feathers or flight?
- ncmncm 7y agoIt's a dumb question, really. What would they use to fly with, before the feathers -- pixie dust? There is a legitimate question: what did they use feathers for, before they used them to fly with? Because nobody ever grew feathers just because they wanted to fly real bad. All kids try it. Doesn't work. It turns out feathers are really, really useful for all kinds of things, if you look. So, "what else are feathers for?" doesn't narrow down much how it led to flying. We know how squirrels, frogs, fish, even tree snakes get lots of reproductive fitness by catching air. Best bet is, it was something similar. Nailing down the exact process will take a hell of a lot of fossils. Then we can start on pterosaurs and bats which don't, you know, use feathers.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoAgain, DNA should give some answers. About the relative timing of precursors to feathers for instance. Or ancilliary genes/proteins to feather production - are they used for anything else? All this could point to feathers-before-flight. Not such a dumb question?
- matt_kantor 7y agoUnfortunately DNA doesn't last that long. We'd need samples from something like ~200 million years ago, but DNA only survives about 1 million year even under the best conditions. EDIT: Unless you were talking about comparing DNA from living species. The closest living relative to birds is crocodilians, but they're pretty distant from one another and might not be useful for the kind of analysis you suggested.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoYes this type of analysis is usually done on existing branches of life. With some evidence in the fossil record of when those forms diverged, a before-and-after picture can be formed?
- flukus 7y agoTo the best of my knowledge we don't have any non-avian Dinosaur descendants to compare with.
- ncmncm 7y agoAs usual, asking the right questions is harder than getting answers to them. The wrong questions are easily answered but teach nothing, or are unanswerable.